Marble cakes are both homey and festive at the same time. A marble cake looks slick when you slice into it and reveal the delicate pattern of the two batters swirled together.
My first experience in working with this type of mixture came about as the result of a marbled chocolate terrine that appeared first in the pages of the old Cook’s Magazine, and then in my chocolate book. Everything about it was right – the texture, the flavor, the quantity of mixture in relation to the mold – everything that is, except the marbling. Even when I hardly mixed the white and dark chocolate mixtures at all, what I got was a few streaks of dark and white, and mostly a muddy combined color. After several frustrating attempts I realized that I had too much dark chocolate mixture and re-cast the recipe so that there was twice as much white chocolate mixture as dark and the terrine mixture marbled perfectly. This marble cake is proportioned in the same way: rather than dividing the base batter in half, I like to remove about a third of it and add the chocolate.
Thanks to my old friend Ceri Hadda who shared her mother’s recipe years ago.
A note about Bundt pans: The Bundt pan came into its own and became a standard piece of American bakeware in the 1960s when the Tunnel of Fudge Cake won the grand prize at the Pillsbury Bakeoff. Back then, Bundt pans were made of lightweight pressed aluminum and baked cakes to perfection. Lately, all you can buy new are heavy dark-colored Bundt pans lined with black non-stick coating. The dark colored pans and coating make cakes bake excessively dark, and I don’t think that the black non-stick coating works well at all. Look for an old, lightweight pan in a flea market, garage sale, or thrift store. Even the faux copper and faux pewter ones, meant to be used as Jell-o molds, bake better than the newer, heavier ones. Prepare any Bundt pan by buttering it with soft, not melted, butter for a thicker coatng, then coat the buttered surface with fine, dry bread crumbs, which release better than a coating of flour. Finally, give the bread crumbed coating a generous spray with vegetable cooking spray, and I guarantee that your cake won’t stick to the pan.
Makes one 10-inch tube or Bundt cake, about 24 slices
BASE BATTER
2 2/3 cups all purpose flour (spoon flour into dry-measure cup and level off)
1 2/3 cups sugar
2 teaspoons baking powder
1/4 teaspoon salt
12 ounces (3 sticks) unsalted butter, softened
7 large eggs
3 tablespoons dark rum
CHOCOLATE BATTER
2 tablespoons dark rum
2 tablespoons milk
1/2 teaspoon baking soda
6 ounces bittersweet (not unsweetened) chocolate, melted and cooled
2 cups Base Batter, above
One 12-cup tube or Bundt pan, buttered, coated with fine, dry breadcrumbs, and sprayed with vegetable cooking spray
- Set a rack in the lower third of the oven and preheat to 325 degrees.
- Combine the flour, sugar, baking powder, and salt in the bowl of an electric mixer. Stir well by hand to mix and add the butter. Beat the mixture on low speed with the paddle until the mixture is a smooth, heavy paste, about a minute or two.
- Whisk the eggs and rum together. On medium speed, beat a third of the liquid into the flour and butter mixture. Beat for 1 minute.
- Stop and scrape the bowl and beater. Beat in another third of the liquid and beat for 2 minutes.
- Repeat step 4 with the last of the liquid.
- Remove the bowl from the mixer and use a large rubber spatula give the batter a final mixing.
- Combine the rum, milk, and baking soda in a medium mixing bowl and whisk well to dissolve the soda. Scrape in the chocolate and whisk it into the liquid. Add the 2 cups of base batter and whisk well to combine.
- Scrape half the remaining base batter into the prepared pan and smooth the top. Cover with the chocolate batter, making as even a layer as possible. Finally top with the remaining base batter and smooth the top. Use a wide-bladed table knife or a thin metal spatula to marble the batter: Insert the knife into the batter at the central tube with the wide side of the blade facing you. Draw the blade through the batter to the bottom of the pan and up and out the side of the pan closest to you, repeating the motion every inch or so around the pan, describing a spiral into the batter, almost as though you were folding egg whites into it. Stop when you get back to the point where you started. Don’t bother to smooth the top of the batter – it might disturb the marbling.
- Bake the cake until it is well risen and firm, and a toothpick or a small thin knife inserted midway between the side of the pan and the central tube emerges dry, about an hour.
- Cool the cake in the pan for 5 minutes then invert a rack on it. Invert and lift off the pan. Cool the cake completely.
Serving: This doesn’t really need any accompaniment.
Storage: Wrap the cooled cake in plastic wrap and keep it at room temperature. Freeze for longer storage. Defrost cake and bring it to room temperature before serving.
What bake goods are you making this holiday season? Gather will draw one respondent to win a copy of Modern Baker. Comments must be posted by Sunday, December 14th.


Comments: 70
Rum cake is very tasty. This looks like a great recipe!
This year I have made chocolate chip cookies and banana bread. In the week ahead I will be baking some Danish Christmas cookies such as pepper nuts and vanilla strings.
as for what baked goods? i like the ambrosia macaroons recipe in the new bon app...and we always make tons of yummy cookies!
For the holidays I ship variety boxes of cookies, tangy macadamia nut gingerbreads and, of course, a few flavors of bundt cakes because they travel so well. Nothing like sweet breads and cakes filling a kitchen with warmth and soothing aroma at the holidays!
--Great tip about the dark pans --have seen the results you described and now I know why.
Will be making Stollen this Christmas; Mom cannot bake this year, so I am stepping up to the plate. Even though I know her recipe by heart, but it will not be the same.
Baking at Christmas is one of my traditions and loves!!!!!!
I introduced my family's soda bread to my step son's family this weekend. It was a hit and so much fun to share a tradition that is near and dear to my heart with my new, extended family.
I am going to try a caramel apple cake this week. Wish me luck, this baking stuff is fun and pretty new to me.
As for me and my house, we're making gingerbread in every form. Gingerbread ornaments, gingerbread houses and, my favorite, soft molasses-rich ginger bread cake topped with applesauce and cream. Indeed, I think I'll need to make up some of the gingerbread cake right now.... ; )
My family is probably going to be baking it's normal holiday food... I'm especially looking forward to making chocolate covered pretzels. Maybe I'll even convince my mom to help me make some magic cookie bars!
My list this year includes: Scotch lace cookies, my origional fudges: pumpkin, eggnog, irish cream, and pomagranite. Depending on what is left in my pantry i will make carmels, eng. toffee, rum balls, brittles..... i so love to bake and make/create camdy for other people :>} Teachers get some each year, after dealing with my boys all day, they need the sugar :>}
Thanks for the recipe
I have already made a few batches of cookies for Christmas and froze them so that I wouldn't be so busy all at once with baking.
I have made Sugar cookies, I cut them into stars and trees and decorated with colored sugar. Chocolate chip cookies, a double batch of fudge, some cookie bars, and I have a few thumbprint cookies frozen too. Then I have some peppermint bark I made up that I didn't freeze.
Then I am also still going to make some more cookies, just havn't decided what kinds yet.
Bundt cake looks great. And they are so moist!!!
My favorite bundt cakes that I make is Amish Banana Cake with caramel frosting or Chocolate Fudge cake with homemade fudge frosting. Usually with the fudge frosting I have about a 3/4 of a cup left over and I'll put it in the center of the cake for those that like extra frosting. It's a hit every time.
I making a Pineapple Nut cake. Delicious!
Thank you for the recipe.
I love baking in my Bundt pan....they are my favorite shaped cakes....and one of my favorite recipes is the Chocolate and Liliko'i (passion fruit) cake
Chocolate and Liliko'i Cake