As a mom of three, I've seen my own children struggle with fitting in and being bullied. It was listening to their experiences, and my own frustrations, that led me to consider the topic of school shootings. I also kept thinking about how it's not just in high school where we have this public persona that might be different from what we truly feel inside...everyone wonders if they're good enough, smart enough, pretty enough, no matter how old they are. It's an archetypical moral dilemma: do you act like yourself, and risk becoming an outcast? Or do you pretend to be someone you're not, and hope no one finds out you're faking?
This book was VERY hard to research. I actually began through my longtime legal research helper, who had a colleague that had worked in the FBI and put me in touch with the Jefferson County Sheriff's Office -- the people who investigated the Columbine shootings. I spoke with them, and they sent me DVDs and material that had never been made available to the public, which helped a bit to get into the mindset of the shooters. The next contact I made was with a woman who served as a grief counselor to the families who lost children at Columbine. However, I really wanted to talk to a school shooting survivor...and yet I didn't want to cause anyone undue pain by bringing up what will always be a difficult subject. I was actually in Minneapolis, doing a reading, when the Red Lake shootings occurred. It was the most surreal feeling: there I was in a hotel, writing a scene in the book, and on the TV next to me was a reporter saying exactly what I was typing into my fiction. I went to the bookstore event that night and was telling folks about the way my two worlds had collided...and a woman came up to me afterward. She knew someone who'd survived the Rocori shootings in MN and was willing to put me in touch with her. Through that connection, I not only spoke with two teachers who shared with me their story of the shooting...but also a young man whose friend died that day. It was his commentary that shook me the most -- as a writer and a parent -- and that became the most important research I did for this book.
Although the media is quick to list the "aberrant" characteristics of a school shooter, the truth is that they fit all teens at some point in their adolescence! Or in other words -- these kids who resort to violence are not all that different from the one living upstairs in your own house, most likely -- as scary as that is to imagine. Two other facts that surprised me: for many of these shooters, there is the thinnest line between suicide and homicide. They go to the school planning to kill themselves and decide at the last minute to shoot others, too. And that, psychologically, a single act of childhood bullying is as scarring emotionally as a single act of sexual abuse.
It is always hardest for me to write a book that has kids in it close to my kids' ages -- and Nineteen Minutes does. I think that every parent has probably experienced bullying in some form -- either from the POV of the bully or the victim -- so it's a pretty universal subject. But in many ways, watching my children as they struggled to find their own place in the social hierarchy of school did make them guinea pigs for me, as I was writing the book. I know that many of my readers are the age of the young characters in this book, and over the years, some have written me to ask if I'd write a book about bullying. But it wasn't until I began to connect what kids experience in school with how adults treat other adults who are somehow different that I began to piece together the story. Discrimination and difference at the high school level will never end until the adults running these schools can go about their own lives without judging others for their race, religion, sexual orientation, etc. How ridiculous is it that America prides itself on being a melting pot, when -- as Peter says in the novel -- that just means it makes everyone the same?
If I could say one thing to the legions of teens out there who wake up every morning and wish they didn't have to go to school, it would be this -- and I'm saying it as both a mom and a writer: Stay the course. You WILL find someone like you; you WILL fit in one day. And know that even the cool kids, the popular kids, worry that someone will find out their secret: that they worry about fitting in, just like you do.
I see Nineteen Minutes and a previous book of mine, My Sister's Keeper as very similar books -- they are both very emotional, very gut-wrenching, and they're situations that every parent dreads. And like the moral and ethical complications of MSK, you have a kid in Nineteen Minutes who does something that, on the surface, is absolutely devastating and destructive and will end the lives of others. But -- given what these characters have endured -- can you blame them? Do I condone school shootings? Absolutely not. But I can understand why a child who's been victimized might feel like he's justified in fighting back. I also think it's fascinating to look at how two good parents might find themselves with a child they do not recognize -- a child who does something they can't swallow. Do you stop loving your son just because he's done something horrible? And if you don't, do you start hating yourself? There are so many questions raised by Nineteen Minutes -- it's one big gray area to wallow in with your book group!
I'd love to hear from you about this subject and about Nineteen Minutes. Share your thoughts here at http://borders.gather.com and I'll stop by periodically to say hello. Thanks!


Comments: 66
How wonderful to read your writing on Gather! I read in the local paper how you visited a high school the other day to discuss the book. It strikes me that the more this kind of topic is out in the open the bigger the benefit to the kids themselves, who have a huge need for information so as to reflect, process and understand. A fictionalized account is a great way to convey this.
"Remember, this is only for 4 years. You've already been through one year. That means there are only 3 years to go - and then you NEVER, EVER have to have anything whatsoever to do with these people again IN YOUR ENTIRE LIFE. They are just a temporary annoyance - and you should give them all the attention and validation you would give any other temporary annoyance like a mosquito bite".
Whenever I read of a school shooting I always feel horrible for the parents of the shooter who will receive much of the blame. Are they really at fault?
Two weeks ago, I read The Tenth Circle. I was so impressed with the story and the undercurrent of knowledge that you had obviously done a great deal of research to obtain. I loved the book. Although I didn't win an advance copy of the newest book, I DID try!! LOL
Right now, I am reading Vanishing Acts. This is a very different book. I don't recall ever reading a book where I really get to see each major character's thinking in so much detail! I'm really enjoying it!
Thanks for stopping in at Gather so that we can express our love for your writing directly to you.
Keep writing, I'll keep reading!
Marsha F.
The subject of bullying is near and dear to my heart. The memories of being bullied are still clear in my mind, even though the occurences are now some thirty years in the past.
I think one of your most poignant points is how adults act bullyish towards other adults whom they label as "too different." I'm currently working on a treatise of violence in our culture. I'll look for your book.
Thanks again, and best of luck to you.
All the continued best,
Jared
I am anxious to read Nineteen Minutes!
This sounds like an interesting premise, and there's no denying your talents as a writer. I look forward to all the sets of nineteen minutes it takes to read your new book!
I cannot wait to get your new book. I am a huge fan! I enjoy the way your readers are forced to explore different opinions of all the situations in your writings. Our worlds are so busy that we tend to operate with blinders on and we really need to open our eyes and hearts to all people that are affected, not just the obvious ones.
Thank you for such provoking and always unpredictable books!
I agree that school violence is a great concern, and it is nice to see that the issues are out in the open. When Columbine happened, many people didn't want to discuss it around high school aged children for fear. I think it is best to get it out there so everyone knows what can help prevent this in the future. Good for you!
Keep up the great writing... I can't wait for your next book!
I was glad to see that you are on Gather! I look forward to reading Ninteen Minutes. I met you a while back when you did a reading at the Framingham MA library. (You gave me advice on hair products because we have the same hair).
I look forward to attending another reading of yours in the future!
Kind regards,
Leah
You are quickly becoming one of my favorite authors. I've read six of your books, and each one keeps me riveted -- I cannot turn the pages fast enough to see what will happen next. Plain Truth, Songs of the Humpback Whale, Vanishing Acts, Tenth Circle, Salem Falls, and now Nineteen Minutes -- all fabulous pieces of writing. I plan on reading the rest of your books over the next few months.
Nineteen Minutes struck a particular chord with me, as I was bullied quite often in high school -- being on the fringe, never quite fitting in. High school can be some of the most rewarding and some of the most hateful years we experience. I had some good teachers who I could confide in, and some who turned a blind eye to what was happening. I know what it's like to be the last one in the gym with the "bully girls" bombarding you relentlessly with dodge balls, being laughed at because I couldn't afford the newer and more popular clothes to wear to school, called names, etc. I still remember hating to get up for school, ditching classes (or whole days!) so that I would not have to face the torment. I tried desperately to fit in with some group - ANY group. Four years seemed like forever, but eventually (mercifully) they passed. And your comments on Gather are true -- one day you DO fit in, one day you DO belong. I am 48 years old now, and all of that seems a very distant memory.
I would recommend this book to high schools across America as required reading, and I would advocate teaching tolerance as a requirement for graduation. Thank you for writng this book.
I am a HUGE fan of your writing. Everytime I read one of your books, I get sucked in and cant put it down until its done. I am so excited to read Nineteen Minutes but I curse myself because I am a paperback reader and will not do hard covers. Dont ask why, I dont know myself. I just recently finished The Tenth Circle which I loved! My Sisters Keeper blew me away and I cried like a baby at the end. Then again, a lot of your books do that to me. I am excited to buy Nineteen Minutes the day it is available in paperback and also equally excited to see that you are working on ANOTHER new novel, Change of Heart. Your dedication to your craft is amazing, thank you for contributing such rivoting reading for your fans!!
This book must become required reading in schools, students and teachers need to realize what their words, actions or complete inattention have profound effects.
Thank you for your response. I think there may be schools who have very generic policies. As you identified in your book, the school policy was one of no tolerance, but there were no specifics about what to do, how to act, how to enforce, what the consequences would be, etc. I think we need to start with anti-bullying policies at the grade school level and insist as taxpayers that our school boards not only adopt, but enforce, these measures without exception. But how many parents go to their local School Board meeting? How many even know who is on the Board? How many are involved in PTA? How many schools face language barriers where the students speak better English than the parents? How many other policies either go unwritten or unenforced? And how many parents want to really be involved? All the parents may be FOR the anti-bullying policies, until their child is the one doing the bullying and suffering consequences. Then it's a whole other ball game. Then the parents come down on the school for singling out their child. There are no black and white answers to such a grey area, unfortunately, but I agree we need to start somewhere.
Gwen
You are coming to my town, Toledo, Tuesday March 20, for an Authors! Authors! event. I know the event is almost sold out. I know you will reach so many more readers now with your visit here.
Thank you for writing books that touch us in a way and make us want to become more involved in working on solutions to the problems that plague our young people these days.
I will continue to promote you!
Diane
The other reason that I must thank you is that I remember when my community went through school shootings. There are a lot of memories here that are still fresh, which probably explains my attachment to the ideas you present. I remember Columbine like yesterday, though I was only a freshman in high school. I could not believe what was going on. In this community (Denver Metro area), you either knew someone there or knew someone who did. I had a little of both, though it was not something we talked about. I remember seeing police in my schools hallways wondering where the madness had come from. Though I was not in the school, it affected me in little ways that I see now. About 2 years after I graduated, my schools rival had a student shoot at the school's sign. It was surreal, as my sister was attending my old high school, which was under lockdown. She didn't know what to do. It was almost like watching my freshman year from the outside looking in, with fewer reporters.
Thanks again. I look forward to finishing this book and seeing you in Denver.
Gwen, thanks for the comments. I still believe that most adults are too afraid to actually let the kids be part of the conversation, and it's my belief that they're going to teach US something about tolerance - after all, you could argue that bullying still occurs at the governmental level, so who are we to preach to the younger generation!? I think when kids realize the school administration is taking this topic seriously, they are more than ready to offer suggestions. And it's not going to be some sweeping global change, like locking doors after school starts - it's going to be one child, thinking twice before he teases someone, because he understands what the aftereffect will be; it's the victim realizing other people care about him. One mind at a time...
Heather - wow, thanks for sharing your story about growing up in Denver during Columbine. I've met young survivors of school shootings and it really isn't something you ever get past - you get through it, instead. I'm glad you bring that experience to the table now, where you work. Just because it's an uphill battle doesn't mean we shouldn't be fighting it.
Thanks!
Jodi
I am really looking forward to reading this book, thank you for being such a great author!
Kristina*
Society seems to be becoming less civil all the time and aggression more prevalent. Understanding the whys and hows might enable us to deal more productively than we have recently.
I think you are right when you say the children will teach US all something. When my husband and I lived in a small but densely populated unincorporated area a number of years ago, 63% of the student population came from homes where English was not the primary language. We volunteered our time at the Teen Center 4 nights a week, and it was inspiring, to say the least. These kids grew up with a rainbow of friends, exposure to many other cultures, languages, skin colors, even hair styles, you name it! And there was ... tolerance, acceptance, comraderie. We, as adults, have already formed so many biases and prejudices (even though we are slow to admit it, maybe even embarrassed to admit it). It was refreshing to see these kids all getting along without any of those hang-ups. There is something to be said for diversity -- it breaks down the social barriers that society puts up and expects us to live within.
That is not to say there were not problems, but we witnessed kids of many different backgrounds, different economic situations, different religions and upbringings -- all working it out and "chilling" side-by-side. Even the least athletic were welcomed onto teams as we structured basketball, floor hockey, and volley ball games for them. As I said, it was inspiring and fulfilling. And it taught me more about tolerance ance acceptance than any parent-child talk ever did.
I have just finished reading 3 more of your books with another 3 waiting in the wings. Keep writing and keep touching on those tough subjects. I find a little bit of myself in every one of your books, as each one resonates with realism. You are truly gifted. Do you have any plans to do a book signing at the Algonquin, IL store in the near future? It woud be an honor to meet you.
Gwen
Gwen - thanks too for your comment - I don't plan to be in Algonquin IL in the near future, but you never know...I hope to meet you one day. Thanks for sharing your story - it sounds like a great eye-opener!
Jodi
I just happened to come across this article. And today of all days. I had gone to my mothers 2 blocks from my house (to snag some Easter left overs) my 1st grade son wanted to ride his scooter there and back. While I was standing by the car waiting for him these 2 kids came up to him and I heard words back and forth. I walked down the block to see what was going on and my son informed me that these kids are the 2 bullies he has been telling me about. I have some online shopping to do and I plan on getting a copy of your books. I appreciate when a writer explores these kinds of topics. I can imagine how hard the research was. Thanks for writing it.
Just when we were all feeling safe again, the deadliest shooting in US history occurs on the campus of Virginia Tech. I immediately thought of "Nineteen Minutes". Although details are still sketchy, and no motive has been determined for this horrific act, my heart goes out to all the parents, friends, families and associates of those who have been affected by this shooting. We will all be watching closely to see just what could have provoked this, and what we can do to prevent it from happening again in the future. I can sense that the administration at VA Tech is second guessing its decision not to shut down the campus after the first shooting this morning, for not warning the students and faculty by whatever available means they had in place. Should they have over-reacted and erred on the safe side? Or was their initial thinking justified. Was there more than one perpetrator? Or was this the same individual? So many questions still to be answered. So many lives shattered today. Funny, I'm reading "Keeping Faith" right now. And I'm praying for people I do not know....
Gwen
WOW! I had just finished Nineteen Minutes the day before the VaTech shooting. Talk about having a perspective! The news shows should be clamoring to have you as a guest to discuss the topic-you definitely know all the angles! Your books are ALWAYS thought provoking and emotional for me. I love being jarred out of my ruts and challenged to think differently. And the plot twists never cease to amaze me! Keep writing!!! I recommend your books to everyone I talk to. I just left my job at Borders where I pushed MSK constantly and had customers coming back for another "jodi fix". My next read is Salem Falls-can't wait to get started.
bev
Teachers have said those exact same words to me--that's how kids interact; it will only get worse if we intervene; it's normal; we stop what we see, but we can't see everything. My son's observations about how the kids treat each other and how the teachers often choose what they see are all there, too. And the conversations I've had with both my son and with teachers are there practically word-for-word, too.
I feel lucky that a bullying situation that I handled poorly when my son was 11 led me to research how to do it better. Four years later, I knew what to do. Also in this book was the worst result of the 11yo situation--my son was angry and disappointed with me for not defending him better. I vowed that would never happen again. This time, I knew what entrenched attitudes I was up against and I knew how to argue against them. We got the situation resolved to our satisfaction and the best part was my son's big hug and , "Thanks, Mom." To him, the most important thing was that I listened to him and fought for him.
Thank you for writing this book.
Nineteen Minutes seems to follow that philosophy. The unpublished novel that I have written, (Tar and Feather) is all about teasing, name calling, and the overall shadow nature of human humor.
Congratulations on your overall success and my compliments on this piece specifically.
I am a new teacher and my family is very concerned with the possibility that such a thing may happen at my school. I am not however, I just want to teach kids and treat them well, respect them, and love them for who they are. I can't teach with fear in my mind. I just have to go forward. However you do bring about an excruciating painful idea about the parents of a child that does something so terrible. How do they cope?
They're so similar, How they both set off bombs and it goes into the cafeteria and they line up the jocks.
Nineteen Minutes really helped me to see the other side of the story.
Before I had read it I would have never really thought about the shooters side.
I know all about bullying and singling people out for their differences, I'm in high school.
I related really well to Josie.
Anyway I'm going on!
Thank you so much for writing your books, I own nearly all of them and can't help but read them multiple times.
I've never found an author as talented as you, and I doubt I ever will.
and one more thing.
At the end of Salem falls, like the very ending.
are you trying to imply that Gillian and her father have a relationship or he is abusing her or something? I didn't really get that.. 'he kissed her on the lips, their secret was safe'
But then again I read it a long time ago.
Thanks :D
Sacha.