Since joining the Gather Community Feb-06 I have occasionally received and of late noticed for others' creative efforts what, in person, might be considered conversation stoppers.
You know the ones--dismissive comments such as: you're not the only one, or: yes, we've ALL had that happen--comments which seem to emanate from the depths of the get-over-it/how-unimpressive category of attitudes.
It's as if your critics insist you realize that two minutes of their lives had been wantonly squandered by their clicking and reading an article, poem, or other (substandard) content, and that the content's author was at fault for the whole shebang.
And furthermore, they're simply hapless clickers and trusting readers expecting no less than stellar entertainment--but foiled by dastardly writers who dare waste a reader's precious time...why, the noive!
An All-Too-Human Trait?
We tend to relate what we newly hear or read to past experiences or to something we know about, at least in part, in order to undertand what we're reading and perhaps to empathize with it, if so moved. And who doesn't appreciate discovering content with concepts which are totally new and unknown to them?
Now to me, the most interesting writing is some combination of both--the common-ground approach helps me make sense by offering something I can relate to, while new thoughts may encourage a sprint to the finish line with a sprinkling of spice to entice.
Then live-and-learn may become read-and-learn in the happiest of cases.
But That's Not What This Is
It would never occur to me, even if I felt my time had been carelessly trumpled or that clicked-on material was of no interest post-click, to spend more time by commenting with a sassy "we've ALL been there"--and with only the "done that" left off in mock politeness thereby further extending my own imagined or feigned martyrdom.
Now I know that many southerners of the US persuasion are often considered mannerly in the old-fashioned sense of the word but I "do declare" there is much difference to be found between a veneer of politeness vs. respectful courtesy--one is sneer, the other sincere.
You know it, I know it, and anyone with an active cerebral cortex knows it.
A Shout-Out to My Wonderful Gather Connections
Never have I taken y'all's kind, encouraging comments lightly!
Yet, as another cliche about southerners goes, there may lurk a stem of steel supporting yon magnolia blossom. Or you might say that an ironic fist resides within the velvety glove.
However, secretive backbones are never to wielded without serious provocation and hopefully are held in check whenever possible in order to promote the greater good, uplift the general welfare, and cheerlead for the sake of harmony all around.
And My Point Would Be?
My intention here is to follow the come-hither Gather directive by being creative of a sort while using my innermost thoughts and feelings about the Gather Experience without unduly attracting--or ruffling the feathers of--the snark among us, however entertaining that could turn out to be.
If toes are squashed in process, an ouch! may readily suffice in reply. Then if you will accept my pre-apology, I'll send along to you my enthusiastic recommendation for my favorite and delightful Footbath Salts (I'd bring some by, but I don't where you live) so that you may have a lovely, relaxing soak for your barking dogs, and simultaneously, a supportive mood lift which will surely tame your raging inner critic.
For after all, if you've stalwartedly managed to plow thus far into this dam-burst of irony, this mitten of pseudo-snarkery, you deserve a treat, and I'm quite thrilled with you.
But in the interest of disclosure, I must inform you that you've just whiled away a minute or so of your life which will never return, yet for that I thank you heartily, courteously, and agreeably for your valiant exertions.
Now what might you make of such flummery as this...so seemingly spun as if from the emperor's new clothes?


Comments: 33
No one is forced to read any articles or view any images. If you don't' like it, don't read it. If you have a different opinion, state your views without any name calling.
Or...did I? ;)
If the article does not move me, thrill me, etc., there's nothigng to say.
Just move on. Unless getting your name in print by putting it there is so unbelievably important to you...
If you can't be nice, be quiet. Be supportive, loving, helpful or move on...
Take care Jude, and oh....I'll send you a bill for my time, ha ha.
and i'm always right because my earring are more sparkly than yours. so there.
;) thanks, John, your check's already in the mail...or...apply above rhyme...but not the lady part...
jessie, your momma knew best! What else did she say?!?
In the article, I thought you were asking for honest input from the reader, and that you found the "I was here" comments demeaning.
But then I got to the, "If you can't say anything nice don't say anything at all," part in the comment thread and it seemed you were agreeing with that message and that confused me.
The best I can do now is express my thoughts as I read the article. I appreciate when anyone takes the time to read something I have written. I feel (and I thought you were saying you feel the same) a bit 'stung' when someone leave a comment that doesn't confirm that they have even read what I've written. I would rather read that someone totally disgrees with the point of my article, caught an error in the second paragraph, or has a question for me than one of the comments you used as an example in the article.
I'll be back to see if I've totally misunderstood and need to start over.
Maybe Gather should pass out a free copy of "Miss Manners' Guide to Excruciatingly Correct Behavior: The Ultimate Handbook on Modern Etiquette" to every Gather member upon sign up?
Sandy--thanks for your comments. My agreement with Jessie's comment was due to my assertion that criticisms may be given courteously rather than with conversation stoppers such as mentioned. "If you can't say anthing nice-ly" is probably closer to my article's point--which doesn't mean insincerity--the rest of my point (to the extent that I had one! I come from a long lime of weavers and sometimes I like to spin.)
If I've still confused you, you've probably tapped in to the deep streak of paradox which resides within my core. ;)
And I also agree with Leanarda's comment!
I do try to live by the creed of saying things nicely, whether I agree with the writer's point/content or not.
Must've been Grumpy Grumpiola, mystery Gatherer, who sent this article's rating down from a previous 10 har har--snarkery lives and thrives!! ;)
Unless I misunderstood your article, you are asking people to please be kind whether they agree with your article or not. Alas, I am afraid that is like asking General Sherman not to burn Atlanta. Some people just can't help being rude and snarky, that is the way they were raised. Maybe we should start a group for the Southern Genteel, and offer etiquette lessons. For instance, don't pick up sugar cubes with your fingers, there are tongs for that. Tea is always sweet and iced. Tea any other way must be designated ie: hot tea, unsweet tea, etc.
You go GA girl and PLEASE paint me a magnolia. Magnolias are one of my favorite flowers.
June, are you a member of G.R.I.T.S? Well you should be if not!
June--sadly, I must confess I'd rather savor a turpentine smoothy than a mint julep. In Atlanta they used to prefer Peach Brandy...the Ladies, that is.
Cognac curdles my teeth enamel, but then I'm not the go-to girl for alcohol. Around here we'd be more likely to offer that cold glass of iced tea--or 'ice tea' as 'they say.'
There are several blends of teas that blend together well served hot over ice. That must be why they're called blends.
All in all, I'm more than a little pleased with y'all's discourse on the topic of...whatever the above topic....er.....is.....
Awesome article Jude
Yayyy, Moggy, you're a GRITS!
Julie, my mom and her mom (didn't meet hers) made tea that would hold up the spoon by itself, add sugar, pour steamy hot tea over ice...add lemon slice usually...I'm sad that you missed it on a very hot summer's day with cicadas singing as the sun set...
..
U