I think that one of our failures as a society is to keep our leaders in check. This applies to Democrats, Republicans, Libertarians, Independents, etc.
I would say that here are some of our failures:
1) A lack of a properly informed population.
2) A tendency to back a candidate instead of to decide how we feel about issues.
3) A drop in personal responsibility to be informed.
4) A missing independent comparison of policies and issues.
5) An unwillingness to display displeasure in things we disagree with.
6) An apathetic approach to the world around us.
7) An isolationist approach to others.
8) A perception that what is right for us must be right for others.
9) A tendency to prefer to highlight another's failures rather than what the solutions would be.
10) Above all, a failure to hold the representatives who we support to a higher degree of scrutiny than for those who we do not support.
Potential solutions:
1) An informed public: I feel that we are a richer society when we make it a point to be exposed to a variety of ideas. We learn more from those we disagree with than from those who we agree with. If we are not challenged, we do not grow as individuals, as communities, or as a nation. Thus, I would promote the idea that we should make friends with those who have opinions contrary to our own and make it a point to sit down and talk. I think we'll find that the benefits far outweigh the costs. We will become aware of things we had never considered, we will be forced to confront our own fallacies and inadequacies, we will be made to look at issues and policies in a way that reflects not only how it affects us personally, but how it affects all groups of people, and if nothing else, we will be able to have a lively, intellectually-stimulating conversation full of passion. I want you to do just this within this next week.
2) I have noticed (for as long as I have been politically aware) that we tend to back a person and defend the candidate and not focus on the ideas and policies of this candidate. It should always be the ISSUE(S) and NOT THE CANDIDATE that we are voting for. Like it or not, no one candidate will EVER have exactly your same viewpoint. Further, a candidate who you are not supporting will have some policies which are more in line with your views of the world and how it should be. We are affected by (and must live with the decisions set by) the policies that are enacted by our elected officials, not the rhetoric. It doesn't matter how a party may "spin" an issue, it matters most to know how we will be affected by said issues.
3) We tend to get our views about the world from rather biased sources. A) News: The news that we tend to read or watch is what is written by individuals who are not us. We are subjected to whichever issues (and opinions about the issues) that the news organization chooses. B) We tend to allow our understanding about the world around us be shaped more by those who we agree with than by those we may not agree with. We derive our views based off of our friends, family, coworkers, religious organizations, etc. Being only exposed to a set of views skewed most towards our own tends to prevent us from being fully informed. Thus, when claims are made by anyone or any organization, ask for the sources, the proof, etc. Small claims need small proof. Large claims need large proof.
4) What has allowed for the polarizing of our country is a lack of independent comparisons. Each election, certain groups such as CNN and others put out a comparison of how the candidates stand on a variety of issues. What's difficult is to get an unbiased, direct comparison of policies/views so we can see which candidate is most aligned with our views. The best that we're often able to receive is a comparison on a variety of issues based upon the written press statements provided by each candidate's campaign. I would like to see more concise, accurate, and independent comparisons of each candidate's positions on a variety of issues.
5) We often say that freedom is not free and yet we forget that fighting for freedom must be stronger at home than it is abroad. When we disagree with the policies of our elected officials, it's not only our privilege, it's our responsibility to hold them accountable. We are fortunate to live in a country where protests, marches, and freedoms to publically disagree with our government are allowed. It is just as much your responsibility to fight for your rights and for the rights of others as it is anyone else's. We must remember that our greatest weapons to fight for our freedoms are not bombs and bullets, but rather our pens, our feet, and our voices.
6) Apathy. It should never be ok for us to feel that since we're not being affected by a bad policy, that the policy should not be challenged. Martin Luther King Jr., while sitting in a jail for his actions to help further human rights, wrote that the greater barrier to the freedom of all human beings was not from those who disagreed with him or who fought to deny other people rights, but from the masses of apathetic people who decided to do nothing and allow for injustices to remain unchallenged. It is important that you fight not only for your rights but for the rights of those who you disagree with as well.
7) Isolationism. We have a tendency to prefer stability and comfort over being faced with tough challenges. We prefer to keep candidates in power whose policies may be unjust or detrimental to others so long as it allows us to remain in the lifestyles and environments that we prefer. We tend to view problems as being something that someone somewhere else should handle and not us. We feel that since something isn't happening here, we shouldn't have to deal with it. We look at ourselves more from a nationalistic (I'm American) view than from an understanding that like all those around the world, we are one population, the human race. Whether we discuss genocide in Darfur, injustices in North Korea, human rights abuses in the Middle East, poverty in Central America, AIDS in Africa, and so forth, it should never be ok for us to turn our backs on tyranny, on starvation, on mutilation, on disease, and on tragedies which are not directly in our backyards.
8) We have a variety of polarizing issues in each election before our country and yet I think that we as a society tend to forget that it's most important to vote in a manner that supports the rights of those who we disagree with. We feel that others should be like us, think like us, live like us, and be forced to conform to our ideals. Yet, we do not take the moment to consider the effects. What would life be like if we were given no choice but to be forced to live, think, and conform to the ways of those we disagree with? Thus, we must always fight for the rights of others, especially for those who we completely 100% disagree with.
9) Anyone can whine and complain. Anyone can blame a person or group for their failures and inadequacies, and yet, it is much harder to supply solutions. It is more important to be for something than against something. This must start with us as individuals. It is important to be introspective and to look at our lives on a regular basis. If we are faced with problems, what can WE do as INDIVIDUALS to make a positive step towards solving the problem? It must be our responsibility to cause positive changes for ourselves and for others. Start small if necessary. The next time that you find yourself complaining about a situation, before you open your mouth to describe your displeasures, do what is needed to confront and tackle the problem. Make the difference. The change for a better life must start with you.
10) As I had mentioned previously, small claims need small proof and large claims need large proof. It is more important to hold our own views, opinions, candidates, and ideals accountable than those of which we disagree. We are more apt to dissect the faults and shortcomings of people, things, or ideas that we disagree with, and less inclined to see where our views, groups, and candidates may fall short. We prefer to back people or ideas and support them against all scrutiny, no matter how valid such challenges may be. Spin, rhetoric, and propaganda can't make an untruth be true. It is more important to hold our own views accountable, than those we disagree with, since we take the leap of holding them to be self truths. Be more vigilant to challenge who or what you support.
One last word, strive always to act and vote in a manner which is meant to make life better. Vote not from fear, but out of love, compassion, and hope.


Comments: 87
Pick a team, support that team over any other team, ignore any bad press of the team, defend the team no matter how poorly they perform and crush anyone who opposes the team.
Fairness and sportsmanlike conduct don't exist in sports or politics any more.
It's about time somebody said these things !
You said: We are fortunate to live in a country where protests, marches, and freedoms to publically disagree with our government are allowed.
Is that still true? Didn't they try to beef up the Patriot Act so that people could not protest? What ever happened to that?
Guess that means you stirred up my thinker. :-)
10
Peace --
So, although things may seem worse, keep in mind the BIG picture when seeing a war was a new thing, most women voted the same as their husbands because that was expected, people didn't have access to much information and so they voted party-line most of the time!
We can do better, but we sure have come a long way!
nationalism.
i actually find that to be a Good Idea. -now, i can't help not being built this way... but i can tell that clannalism (which is the same thought-process, only expanded) is key to the survival of Humans. closing ranks (especially in the face of Visible Threats) is obviously instinctual, and has merit.
that said: i've been inundated with enough We're All The Same, Man(-ness) to reflexively, say, desire change in Darfur.
even though that situation is probably best left to its own devices.
i have an ancient qualm with reaching beyond our own borders. it's gonna sound pretty redneck, so buckle in:
Sweep Around Your Own Front Door First.
i suspect that one is best suited to help another when one's OWN population is at its best-- when there are no more hungry, or uneducated, or terrorized, ad infinitum... in one's own neighborhood.
it's only logical.
that World's Watchdog mentality has engendered little more than hostility out there, anyhow.
why bother?
more; if you're GOING to bother... why bother NOW-- when Indiana is storm-struck, and New Orleans has become a creepy little frontier-town, and and and and and AND...
...like i said: ad infinitum.
it's just...not...logical.
and it sends a message, intended or not: "We care more about some poor village in Outer Nowhere than we do about some poor village right down the highway."
this is NOT a Christian sentiment. nor is it a "good" moral stance.
and it CAN be done--we CAN help our neighbors before crossing any of our own borders; we CAN insure all of the things we haven't as of yet--for silly, silly reasons.
to wit: if you can air-drop foodstuffs in Africa, you can air-drop foodstuffs in the very worst of American ghettos.
or trailer parks.
period.
Angel
Brittany is much more important to corporate/entertainment news than john McCain voting against veterans benefits or not voting at all on veteran bills since 2005.
#2--its pretty simple to get voting records and candidate positions, but again, you(in general) have to look: realclearpolitics.com; congress.org, factcheck.org. It ain't gonna be found on fox noise....
#3--I've been an activist since at least 14. I have marched/walked/volunteered for many causes including reproductive rights, animals, education, unions, elderly, health care...I know that all people can't be as passionate as me, but it doesn't take a lot to call your state representatives or write a letter.
Good article!
Very perceptive.
Now I'll read the rest.
Great Article
Heck I would love to pick and choose three candidates and mesh them into one great political machine. Unfortunately, that can not happen. 6,7, and 9 are the largest problems in my opinion- love the solutions. We are the answer to the government in this country.
Add to that the victims of Katrina and problems here at home and you have a leader that the world cringes every time he opens his mouth.
There has to be a change in the way government works for its people, not against it. If it means doing away with red tape so that new drugs can be created to save lives, then so be it. Let's also find a way to make the American dream a reality.
Most places you will not get a permit to protest anywhere near the real action.
You will not be allowed to be seen by visiting dignitaries, etc.
Things have changed for the worse when it comes to publicly gathering to express your opinions as part of a group.
Happy Triple Points!!! >^..^< Thank you so much for sharing.
I Would Really Appreciate It!!
Our country needs some serious help will policy, financial expenditures, and so much more. How can we truly be of help to others if we can't take even take care of our own?
I think that we can be apathetic at times because of how we have to struggle every day just to make ends meet.
How would you feel if you came home from fourty hours of work and then you're bombarded with all these complicated issues that you are not even sure you understand?
Well, it's obvious, after a while, you just stop caring.
I hope we all start caring again and like you said Dan, Start fighting for our rights.
The group: We Comment Back
This morning I decided that I am so worked up and disgusted with our government - predominantly the Bush/Cheney reign that I just can't watch the news for a few days. Of course the Dems - who are now in power - have failed miserably to take back their power and actually do something constructive.
WE MUST BE RESPONSIBLE! We must be sure we are informed and be prepared to act, in whatever way we deem appropriate to support or defeat legislation, elected officials, etc.,
I try not to get too terribly political here. I don't want to start an argument and have no intention of entering into a debate. If there is anyone left in this country who believes that McCain is the answer to anything other than more of what we've had for the last 8 years, well . . . they need to wake up!
Sorry . . . I just can't help it. We need to wake up and smell the coffee. We need to hold ourselves responsible for the terrible state of affairs of our country right now.
Unlike some who say things aren't "so bad," our family has experienced dramatic hit on our incomes due to the slowing of the economy, the increased gas and food prices. Things may not be "bad" right now for everyone, but we'll all be there before long if we keep on doing what we're doing.
Please don't try to start a tit-for-tat with me! I do respect the opinon of others and also believe in free speech.
Thanks for posting this importatant article, Dan.
Very concise and right on. I've always thought the real enemy is apathy. Time for a little personal responsibility.