( originally a persuasive speech I wrote about seven years ago and just dug up today! If you don't know what a roleplaying game is, it is a game that involves participants taking on the roles of fictional characters and telling a collaborative story according to a set of pre-established rules. See this wikipedia article for more information)
Are these simple dice the tools of the devil?
Some fundamentalist Christians believe so. Roleplaying games (which often use dice like these) have been denounced by several popular evangelists and debunked by religious groups for over two decades for being "evil and satanic" , harmful influences on youth. This is far from the truth! Roleplaying games are not only non harmful to a young person's development, they are also beneficial in many ways.
The biggest stigma attached to roleplaying games involves the occult. Some Christians believe that because characters in the game can cast spells, the players themselves are being drawn into a world of dark magic rituals and demon worship. According to GAMA (the game manufacturing organization), this misconception is primarily due to the fact that roleplaying games first appeared in the early seventies, and many religious and social leaders are not young enough to have experienced playing these games firsthand in high school or college. This unfamiliarity gives them an outsider's point of view, and not an actual familiarity with the game.
GAMA goes on to state that likelihood of a person learning to cast a magic spell from playing a roleplaying game is about the same as a person learning to pilot a fighter jet by watching the movie Top Gun. Many roleplaying games do not involve magic at all, and take place in settings such as SciFi universes and the Wild West. There is even a Christian roleplaying game called Dragon Raid which features Christian themed adventures, and is supported by several churches as an excellent tool for youth ministries and bible schools.
Another argument that fundamentalists use to support their claims of roleplaying being satanic and harmful is that it causes disturbed behavior in youth that can often lead to suicide. According to a case study done by the center for disease control, there was no evidence linking roleplaying to increased suicide rates. Many other studies done by such prestigious institutions as the Albert Einstein College of Medicine, collaborate this result. There is no link between mental illness and roleplaying.
Roleplaying can be a rewarding and educational experience. Psychologists use therapeutic roleplaying to help patients work through their mental issues in a safe environment. Teachers can use roleplaying in the classroom to stimulate creativity and a more avid interest in the subject material. In one classroom taught by David Millans of Atlanta Georgia, live action roleplay allows the students to act out important events in history in creative ways.
Roleplaying teaches skills that are valuable to life- cause and effect, teamwork, and logical thinking. According to the GAMA pamphlet "Questions and Answers about Roleplaying Games" published in 1991, roleplaying games even aid in the development of mathematical skills as gamers need to calculate to-hit totals, percentages, and even statistics in some cases. Roleplaying involves many areas of the brain at once in a dynamic learning environment that is found in very few other sources.
Roleplaying is also, by its very nature, a social activity. Whether it is
played in a chat room online, a classroom, or around a dinner table on a Friday night, players must interact with each other in a social manner. They also learn respect for authority figures; the game is almost always overseen by some form of GM, or game master, who tells the players what they see and encounter. It teaches the players to follow rules, and the rewards of completing a task that they have begun.
Fortunately, much is being done to remove the social stigma of roleplaying as more people are coming to realize its benefits. A mainstream movie, Dungeons and Dragons, is currently playing in theaters. This movie is based on the very first roleplaying game, and is sure to do much to bridge the gap between roleplayers and society.
It is important to educate those who do not know the true nature of roleplaying games so that this persecution and hysteria involving them will be as dead as a dragon felled by a well-rolled sword swing. Remember that each and everyone one of you is a roleplayer.
If you played a turnip in the fifth grade, dressed up as a princess, read a book and imagined yourself as the hero, watched a movie and acted along with some of the parts, sang in the shower and imagined you were a rock star - you too, are a roleplayer.
Roleplaying isn't about Satanism or rebelling from society's norm. It is embracing the beautiful, creative part of us all that wants to "make pretend" and explore the limits of our imagination. The true magic is when we open ourselves to possibility, and allow all men to be free to pursue their hobbies without persecution.


Comments: 31
Yes, Gandalf casts spells, and your wizard in the game might cast spells, but do you fall into the occult because you watch LotR on TV? No. Same is true in playing a Gandalf-like character. The game is just that--a game. The dice you roll tell you what toughness of armor you hit and what damage you do while fighting, among other things. But there is NO teachings of incantations or anything like that.
It's just like playing in a big fantasy novel where YOU'RE the characters. DH and I are devout Christians as well. :)
~~Becka
I myself am a true enthusiast of RPG, I played WOW, Titans Quest, Baldur's
Gate and many more.
Yes, you said well that it was not about satanism. That's all about falling in imaginations of deep magical worlds.
Thanks
Shah
This seems to also open the door to extreme though.
On CNN's special on "God's Warriors". There was much talk about the sacredness/holiness of Jerusalem to Judaism, Christianity and Islam. However, the way the people seem to show their respect at this holy site is to murder each other, foment warfare and hate, and generally act much more as I would
assume worshippers of an evil deity than a good one.
While some seem to believe they are called on by a great, good, merciful god to destroy, murder and foment hatred, it is the simple acts of appreciation that show the true meaning of living a holy life of grace. It is holiness that is in the details of a well-lived life; the devils prey on the hubris of those who would be instruments of horror and revenge.
I personally loved Magic The Gathering, I never thought I would get into it but at one point it was a true passion for me...nowadays it is difficult to find anybody to play!
Well done!
Thankfully, the anti-roleplaying hysteria of the '80s is long gone. Some of the stories and claims that were paraded around back then were really beyond belief.
Nice article, Laura!
Oddly enough, before I signed onto Gather tonight I was on my favorite play-by-post roleplaying site. I am in four games. I have the human fighter, a human adventuress, and a halfling healer, and now will be an archeologist in Call of Cthulu.
I've been role-playing for over 25 years, and am still a Presbyterian!
Having said that, I do believe that some games 'desensitize' our youth to killing. I think some of the violent games are contributing to the increase in violence in our society. I'm not saying that everyone who roleplays will become a killer. I just think that some kids have the potential and some games encourage them to violence.
;0
These fundamentalist Christiians are the same people that think kids shouldn't read Harry Potter because it's got witches casting spells, so that must be satanic.
What they don't understand is that Harry Potter, just like D&D, is about so much more than the gods and the magic. It's about self-sacrifice, putting your friends before your self, fighting for what you believe in, creativity, and teamwork. Plus, in both cases, we're talking about getting kids to read, which everybody says they don't do enough of.
The sad truth is that all religions have members who take themselves WAY too seriously, and need to lighten up and enjoy the life that their god has given them. Judge not, lest ye be judged, right? Let he who is without blemish cast the first stone? Remove the plank from your own eye before pointing out the speck in anothers? Any of that sound familiar? They should if you're Christian - they're the words of Christ.
Anyway, thanks again for the quality article!
Thanks for hitting the nail on the head. It's all about working together. Loyalty, dedication to a common goal, overcoming individual limitations on the road. learning to work together.