I have lost my older brother. He has been slipping away for a couple of years now, but now it's done. It's over. My feelings are so jumbled right now. Half of me mourns, half of me is relieved. These last two years have been increasingly painful for my entire family as he sunk deeper and deeper into his illness and became less and less like himself.
He was, or rather is, 58. I don't mean to confuse. The fact is that in technical terms, he is still breathing. He still holds a job, he still cuts his grass, he still goes to church every week. But, regardless, my brother has died. It all started a couple of years back when he started making rather strange remarks at family gatherings, while sitting around the dining room table discussing issues of interests.
You see, my family is from Massachusetts and my parents have always been educated, Kennedy-loving, church-going Democrats. They raised my brothers and me to believe that it is our responsibility in life to 'Do Unto Others', and to take care of those who are less fortunate. If I had a nickle for every time my mother said, "There but for the grace of God go I", I could have retired long ago and be writing this from my Caribbean villa, dripping from my morning dive. So, you get the picture - real Christian, empathetic, 'concerned citizen of the world', liberal Democrats.
At first, we thought my brother was simply exhibiting stress. He had lost a couple of jobs in his life during the era of downsizing and low military budgets, and has never been one to handle change. These losses, although he always ended up finding another job, took their toll on his sense of security and self-esteem. And I think it was these feelings that drove him to the pusher on the corner radio - Rush Limbaugh.
At first he would share some of Limbaugh's comments with a laugh, making them out to be a joke. When the rest of the family told him they didn't think that it passed for 'humor' and was actually pretty twisted, he would simply shrug. Then, he started taking these ideas seriously, but still offering them up in discussions as 'alternative ways of looking at things'. Being an open, liberal-minded group, we would discuss the merits and veracity of such 'views', probably giving him a little too much confidence to pursue them further.
We didn't realize that this was becoming a serious illness until the Spring of 2008. At our Easter family gathering, it really hit the fan. My brother 'came out'. He took over the discussion as if he was in the pulpit, preaching to the almost-damned. It was shocking and, although we tried to change the subject, he was bent on telling us that the world would end if a Democratic President was elected. Afterwards, his teenage children seemed quite embarassed and one of them sidled over to me and said, "Aunt Sheryl, dad sits out in the car in the garage when he comes home from somewhere, just listening to that guy on the radio finish his program. He's like a stranger now." That nearly broke my heart. My brother - the one I had always looked up to, who always had a quick joke or comment, and an easy laugh. He used to be so likable, so kind. Now, his own son didn't know recognize him.
From that time on, anyone in the family with a working email address started receiving the forwards. They were nauseating, they were full of hate, they were full of lies and twisted exaggerations. When Obama won the Democratic nomination, they exploded. At first, I would occassionally open one and try to respond with some facts and a few counter-points. That was futile, and exhausted me no end since I had to fight the bile coming up my throat into my mouth while reading these hate-filled diatribes. My next tact was to delete them, but that got to be tiresome, too. I finally asked him nicely to cease and desist. It took a couple of nice requests, but it finally got through. Unfortunately, my grown children were also on his recipient list, but were technically savvy enough to create a separate folder to which my brothers' emails would automatically drop, which they could periodically delete without having to even read the subject lines.
Thanksgiving came and my brother decided not to come to my parents' home for dinner, making up some lame excuse. We all knew he was in a deep depression that Obama had won the Presidency. Christmas came - no show. Easter came - no show. And he stopped calling my parents (both in their 80's and not too long for the world) and stopped coming to any other family functions. To say my parents are heart-broken is an understatement. My kids have tried to engage him via email, to no avail. I recently asked him and his family to our Labor Day weekend party to celebrate our son's graduation from college. I got a brief email from the 'other side' stating that he was going to spend the day covering his pool, and that he would keep me in his prayers.
I didn't know whether to be angry or weep. I wanted to do both. I still feel that way. He is lost - to everyone. Rush Limbaugh has killed him. Murder in the first degree. Or perhaps a kidnapping charge should be added - that seemed to come before the actual demise. The brother I knew and loved, the eldest child, the funny, kind, intelligent guy I adored is gone. And I don't even have the consideration of a wake and funeral with which to mourn his passing.
When will this end? How many lives have been rined like this? How many have suffered this epidemic of hate sweeping the nation? How many more families will be torn apart?


Comments: 107
HUGS
I'm in a state of depression as it is, with the whole "let's pit half the US against the other half" technique of divide and conquer, but just about when I think it won't get worse, it does!
I'm sorry about your brother. My younger brother is largely in the same state as your older brother. My brother has become a recluse, bitter and vindictive, refusing to even listen to anything I might have to say. This kind of hatred brings out the worst in people and magnifies it, imo. My brother didn't go the way yours did ... mine had a family tragedy and used that pain to magnify issues and paint the rest of the world with a veneer of distrust and hatred. My brother includes God, since God killed his daughter in a car accident. God took his beloved mother (It's so nice that he had a nice mother. MY mother beat the crap out of me for 16 years), who was such a saint that the church should be canonizing her any day now.
And now my brother has flipped all the way over and turned into my mother ... almost. He's just enough there to make me think that there might be hope, then I talk to him.
I hope your brother wakes up some day and notices the company he's keeping. Hugs.
As a minister, he's chosen to assault my inbox with torrents of "Obama is the antiChrist" propaganda.
It's so sad that they can't find a cure for this.
Hopefully he will realize that politicians come and go, family is forever!
My daughter becomes heartbroken when her father "attacks" her and corners her on political issues. He becomes hateful, mean and irate... something he never does otherwise! He's so bent on being right that nothing you can say or do will change his mind.
When he starts in on me... I just let him rant. I won't engage in his one sided "conversation".
New Rule: don't discuss politics with those you love unless you're in agreement!
I just feel sorry for those who ascribe to conspiracy theories, lies, BS, and propaganda.
Sheryl, he's not hurting me when he rants... he's hurting himself. He's going to cause his own heart attack some day. If my daughter chooses to argue with him, against my good advice... she will just have to learn the hard way, I suppose.
I remember some heated debates at the dinner table when I was growing up, between my Aunts, Uncles, Grand Parents, etc. Even then I knew politics ruined a perfect supper!
I certainly hope your husband sees the light and comes around before he does experience a life-altering or -ending medical attack.
My husband is the exact opposite. He is a socialist liberal from Quebec.
The two of them are extreme opposites and I don't ascribe to either of their stances 100%. My husband is tolerable and much more reasonable.
I'm somewhere left of the middle. Social liberal. (have all the abortions your little heart desires, keep your religion out of my politics) Fiscal conservative (don't make me pay for your stupidity and screw-ups)
As far as being left of the middle, I think we're both in the same place, for the same reasons.
When someone close to you suffers a long time its always much harder and sometimes its a big relief for it to be over for the person, family, and close friends.
My oldest brother was recently born to me. Our youth and early adulthood were fine, then he became a John Bircher - we became estranged. Then after 8 years of Bush's policies, he reconnected to his liberal boyhood friends (one of whom is the most liberal Congressman) and embraced Obama. His explanation - I thought the Republicans could do no wrong - then they did everything wrong until I had to believe that the Democrats have to be right. I'm a believer now. He's back as the great brother I knew and loved. I hope yours has a similar transformation. Thank goodness he is young enough to have time to let his brain mature. I hope you have the patience to wait.
meanwhile - my thoughts are with you.
"I once was lost but now am found, was blind but now I see." I'm so happy for you - getting your brother back. It gives me hope that there is a possibility that it could actually happen.
I grew up in a small southern town that was ruled by the Southern Baptist Church. I was part of the so-called "freak" crowd, the ones that listened to Marilyn Manson and painted their fingernails black and were in drama club. If you went to our high school and weren't part of the Fellowship of Christian Athletes or the Abstinence Club and didn't go to the church activities, well your peers were sure to make your life miserable, the same peers who claimed to be members of the body of Christ and walked around with their "Jesus Saves" shirts on.
My family has had no problem 'disagreeing' with each other in the past. We discuss things, we debate things, we agree to disagree. As I mentioned above, my family members were always church-goers and strong Catholics, although social liberals disagreeing with many dictates of the Catholic Church. That did not stop them from being practicing members, active in religious education, Boy and Girl scouting, on the church committee.
This altered state my brother finds himself in is definitely more like a demonic possession. For some reason, there IS no middle ground. Either you totally agree with his extreme and hateful views, quoted directly from Rush's mouth to our ears, or you are worthless.
I am truly sorry that your family has these issues (primarily as regards the views of your brother) but it is clearly not appropriate to claim that Rush has possessed your brother in some way. There is another explanation - let's take a little example.
What is the Constitutional authority for Obama-Care? Seriously - no fooling! Whatever Constitutional justification you come up with, the same reasoning could be applied to the government doing whatever it wants , taking over whatever it wants. Following this reasoning the Constitution fails to have any power to inhibit government action at all (which was it's original purpose) and becomes effectively null and void!. This reasoning therefore invalidates national health care. If I have this wrong please correct me. Such reasoning may perhaps have influenced your brother. Deal with the reasoning instead of just vilifying Rush.
At the end of the day, when these haters are at the end of their lives, I wonder if they will take comfort in their solitary hate, having pushed everyone who loves them away. I wonder if they will die with a smile on their faces, clutching their bibles and a copy of the Constitution. How pathetically sad - what a tragic way to live one's life. It's exactly like a drug addict.
I am truly sorry for the loss of your brother. Maybe there's hope for him someday, like Richard mentioned above.
I truly wish people could put their political and whatever differences into the right context. We're on this earth for a short time. If you really think about it, there are very few people that truly know us, share our life experiences with us, especially those growing up that play such a large part in shaping who we are. Why can't we cherish those who love us and be grateful for their love? Enjoy that relationship while we are here? What can be so damned more important than that?
Politicians come and go - things change in our lives. The love of our family and friends should be the thing we cherish most and count on most to stay constant. I fear that he will pull so far away, that if he does ever need someone in the future, he will feel alone and alienated unnecessarily. I'm sure Rush will not come to his aid then.
Mind you we are a working class family deep in the union movement. My kids started going to demos with me when they were in training pants. Basically I raised pink diaper babies.
My aunt told her son that if he opened his mouth with his stupid shit one more time, she would disown him.
He's back now. His crazed homeschooling wife left him and he's still trying to get his kids in order. He's sorry now that he went along with everything.
There's hope yet for your brother. The blinders may come off one day. Until that time, continue being the shining example to him that you already are.
Blessings my friend.
I live a long way away from my family and love seeing them when I get the chance. A long time ago I made an conscience decision that my family is more important to me than politics and when I happily was waving good bye to Bush I realized my family and I were standing on opposite sides. When the arguments started I just help up my hand and said you are not going to change my mind and I guess I'm not changing yours so lets not talk politics - I love you.
I know how some of my siblings voted and assume I know the ones on my side too and that was that. My husband and I traditionally have voted on different sides and now he admits he made a mistake by sending his vote to McCain.
However, none of us can stomach the Limbaughs of this day and age on Fox news or on the radio so we don't hear most of the garbage being spewed around bouncing off of people stupid enough to believe that crap.
I'm sorry for you loss
Thanks for posting this to Obama YES! Palin ~ NO!
I almost experienced this with my brother. We live in different parts of the country and haven't talked a lot over the last few years. A couple of years ago he told me he, not only was a Bush supporter and admirer, but he prays for Bush every day. Although I was appalled and confused, I suggested that we not talk politics (or rather I said I wouldn't try to convert him [to sanity]) and since then we've gotten along very well. We talk more often than we used to, and somehow I actually have gained respect for him as a human being, in a lot of ways (that probably wouldn't be the case if I knew more about his political views). I guess I'm lucky he's a survivor.
I have lived for many years without family because of the lack of acceptance. Brothers, sisters, aunts, uncles always fought and refused to speak to each other- or let us speak to our cousins. Holidays were done in shifts so no one would have to see who they didn't like.
I left them all. They're a bunch of hypocrites and haters. I've got friends who are family to me.
Rush really is a mental illness, and people who are immersed in his sewer really are being poisoned. It is IMPOSSIBLE to talk to anyone who has been pulled into his cult. They have lost complete touch with reality, and refuse to listen to anything which could refute Rush's opinions. They respond with anger and violence to anything at all different from what Rush preaches. They have their buzzwords which they use as an assault on anything Rush does not want them to hear.
I would not have believed it possible if I had not actually seen it.
It's not even close to a disagreement, or being on the opposite sides of the fence on an issue. It really, really is a sickness.
i have my days where i smile & nod. i have my days where i send them emails from "the other side" to see the reaction.
i am sorry for your loss....i fear we may lose a few in my family as well!!
He is selfish now - his language is filled with hate about 'have-nots' and lazy SOBs and takers and people who just want to mooch off society. He does NOTHING except give money to his church. He doesn't volunteer, he would never help people directly in need of food, as he considers them lazy takers. I can't listen to his hate talk anymore. It's like poison in the air.
There is a real disconnect in this country between the citizens and what we once stood for. The "pull yourself up by your bootstraps" has become muddled. The American Dream has become the American nightmare having gone from one of idealistic goodness to taking it all at any cost, away from others, fraudulently with the biggest pot being the goal.
Why do these people spread hatred ... the Limbaughs? Why do they wish to foment trouble and facilitate misery ... what do they receive for their efforts?
I found this article to be so sad, Sheryl. In our family, we have both liberals and conservatives, Democrats, Republicans and Independents. We're family, so we can discuss things rationally. Sometimes a person might even be swayed a bit from one side to the other, at least about a particular item.
I guess I thought that's how all people acted. At other forums where I've been over the years, that's the way it was.
Here at Gather, I have found more close minded liberals than I have in my entire lifetime.
The fact that I believe in fiscal responsibility, free markets and limited government does not make me a bad person. But here at Gather, that is the attitude.
There are many conservatives here at Gather who are closet conservatives. They write to me and tell me how brave I am to put my opinions out here because they immediately get attacked. They won't do that, and so they silently pray for me and for the hate filled liberals who attack anyone who doesn't believe as they do.
I'm talking about the REAL world of families and friends. Again, I have not know anybody other than Rush-followers who have experienced such a gross immersion and conversion of their lives that they are willing to give up relationships with their loved ones because of a difference in policitical views.
As you have seen on this comment thread, many family members recognize that someone has extremely opposing political and social opinions from their's, but they come to agreement that they will simply not discuss politics - that maintaining family and friend ties is more important than what some dumb-ass radio entertainer says, or what the latest political football in DC is.
If people truly WERE what they say they are - that is, caring Christians, like my brother seems to see himself as - then they should be able to get past the political differences and realize that they are a small part of our total lives. Again, representatives come and go, social feelings sway from one end of the spectrum to another, but love should remain.
For instance, I have an aunt who is in her 80's. She still uses the n-word when referring to blacks at times. The first time I heard it come out of her lady-like mouth, I was totally shocked. But, she is a good person and my aunt and I continue to have contact with her and try to avoid unpleasant subjects when together. I'm not going to change her mind at 85 - that's how she was raised. It pains me, and I have spoken to my children many times while growing up about it - they are as appalled as I am when we hear it.
I guess we have to take the good with the bad, as long as we can live with it. We just need to retain perspective on what is truly important in life.
I feel so sorry for your loss. I have a conservative brother but he is open to President Obama because he respects the fact that the POTUS was elected and is now the Commander.
My brother doesn't fall for Hannity or Limbaugh or any of those hot air balloons. He listens for the real stuff, not the hate rhetoric in disguise.
Maybe, maybe your brother can rise from the dead one day and if he does, I will raise a glass to his return from hell.
My entire life I have looked up to and admired this sister.
The good thing is that they don't vote. :-)
My sympathies to you.
I do not know your family but it seems that there is much more going on here than a rift caused by political and religious differences. That being said, my brothers disagree strongly over politics. One worked for Obama's campaign as a state field director and the other was a fundraiser for McCain. During the holidays they fight and debate over politics and issues all the time. They agree to disagree and that doesn't stop them from from a lively debate once in awhile. They never are condescending to each others views and neither of them puts the other one down when disagreeing. A difference of opinion is just that. It's not smarter or better, it's just different. However, they are still brothers who love each other and each other's family and children.
Regardless of how liberal you say your upbringing was I am willing to bet that it was an atmosphere that was very critical, opinionated and intolerant of others who were different from you. In all due respect, I would have to suspect that your family is not very close at all, can't tolerate each others individuality and differences because you were never taught how to do so.
You only speak of the loss for yourself. You say you were raised in a devout Catholic family. Apparently your brother is still a practicing Catholic. Did it ever occur to you that maybe he feels he lost a sister? After all, you say you are now an atheist. Don't you think that it might be as hard for him to accept the change in you? How can you only see a loss for yourself?
It's always easy to blame others for a behavior with siblings we are unhappy with, e.g. husband/ex-husband, wife/ex-wife, the job etc. etc. and in this case Rush Limbaugh!
It reminds me of a guy my daughter works with in her university lab - they are both Ph.D candidates. He came up to her one day, totally perplexed, and said that he could not understand how she could be so nice, so close to her family, come from such a family of close-knit, loving individuals and BE A LIBERAL.
Are you sure you don't work in a university lab, Jonathan? Your comment sound as inane as his was.
No, I don't mention my atheism at all during family conversations. I still play the organ in churches occasionally and get along quite well with religious folk. If my brother has a problem with my atheism, then IT IS HIS PROBLEM, not mine with his still being a Catholic. The problem I have with his going to church regularly is that he is a hypocrite - claims to follow Jesus' teachings, but acts in the opposite fashion.