Before Father and I left for Iran I told myself I would not post about politics. I'm still very hesitant to do so, mostly because people will think I have 'gone native' if I do. But sometimes it's just more important to report what I see, no matter how far away it is from the Western media portrayal of Iran. In Iran's case the reality of life could not be any farther away from the American perception of the Islamic Republic of Iran.
But let's dispense with the obvious first.
The hejab: I find this a horrible, odious practice. Countless times I've felt like as if Iran is a black and white version of Margaret Atwood's "The Handmaid's Tale." I don't get it. I don't understand it. And I certainly do not approve of it.
Nor, for that matter do I approve of how women are, in very real ways, treated as second-class citizens. I don't know if they are forced to ride at the back of the bus or not. I've asked and had different people tell me different things. (I do think the contradictions I get from different people says something, however.) And I do know that women are only allowed to watch soccer matches in special sections in the stadium.
But there is progress: several weeks ago about 100 women went to a soccer match, actually forced their way into it, and sat where they pleased. No one stopped them.
And who did they find their inspiration from? In their quest for equal treatment in the eyes of their fellow citizens, Iranian women invoked the name of the patron saint of the American civil rights movement: Rosa Parks. In their struggle to put an end to the constant stream of slights and indignities thrust upon them by the clerical establishment they looked to us, to America. They looked to our soft power, our ideas, our values, or as Lincoln would say, "our better angels."
But that's just the negative side of the ledger, so let's take a look at the positive. Women can drive. Women can vote. Women can work. Women can smoke. They have free and unfettered access (at least in the big cities) to contraception and this is legal and tolerated by the theocratic establishment! Women hold 30 seats in the Iranian parliament, more than the full total in America. And the huge population bulge of 30 something's and younger are forcing changes on the country as I type.
Did you know that men and women are living with each for years at a time without getting married? To many people in America this is still scandalous behavior. (Personally I think it unwise, but I believe in people making their own choices.) Did you know that when people are inside the home what is done there is considered inviolable? The Iranians have parties, they dance, they drink and they smoke, all without the onerous hejab restrictions.
But let's talk about politics at large. The voting age here in Iran is 16. The country is on the verge of a secular-pluralistic evolution unlike any we have seen in the region. But how do I explain this to Americans who already have their minds made up about the country? How to explain that issues like personal choice, freedom of conscience and individual dignity are rallying cries of the youth bulge that is even now changing the country, turning it into something much closer to a real, functioning democracy than our experiment next door? Of course, it is a democracy in an Islamic, but more so a Persian context. I think this is what drives policymakers in the US nuts. Perhaps this is what keeps them up at night. They cannot accept that a country can do it on their own without our help.
Iran is largely self-sufficient. They design and build their own cars; they make their own TVs, some of which are flat screen! They export wheat and will soon export rice. Of course, they have a great deal of oil, but it is mandated by the Iranian government that cars be fuel efficient and rare is the large SUV cruising the streets of Tehran, much less Isfahan and Shiraz in a country bursting at the seams with oil.
Do I sound like I have gone native? Perhaps. Trust me, I haven't. Iran has a great deal of problems still to work out. And I am certain many of the hopes the youth bulge of this country has will be squashed. But in time they will be fulfilled simply because there are too many of them. Too many of them have studied abroad, too many of them have studied the practical sciences and few of them are searching out a theocratic education as opposed to a rational-reason based one. This, more than anything else is reason for hope.
If you don't believe me, come see Iran for yourself. You'll be welcomed with open arms. Trust me, I know.


Comments: 56
And also: "And I am certain many of the hopes the youth bulge of this country has will be squashed. But in time they will be fulfilled simply because there are too many of them. Too many of them have studied abroad, too many of them have studied the practical sciences and few of them are searching out a theocratic education as opposed to a rational-reason based one."
I see in your picture you have a guide, can you explain about that. I did not have one and moved around by myself without much problem in the communication area. It seemed there was usually someone around that spoke English and went to school here.
As far as democracy, the country has a way to go, as does women's rights. I believe the young there have hopes of more choice in the future. Take care and post some pictures if you can, I would love to see them. By the way, did you try any of that bread cooked in pits in the ground yet? (hint, hint for pix) I loved the stuff......
Later.
I worry so much that the nuclear develpment thing is going to turn into a huge disaster because of our not giving Iran credit for having some kind of intelligence, quality and reserve. I really believe that is all they are asking for. From what I understand, the prime minister of Iraq is asking for a freer hand too. Maybe America is just making trouble for itself (and the rest of the world) needlessly in some ways. I don't deny that we have a threat from the extremists, but that is no reason to go in and annihilate a whole nation along with its civilian population. No wonder so many hate us. I think everyone should go visit Iran. Such understanding is the only hope this world will ever have of finding peace.
Thank you for this post.
I hope that, while you are there, you will also have the opportunity to dispel some myths your Iranian hosts may have about Americans -- we are not as TV and movies portray us to the rest of the world, either.
I look forward to hearing more.
I'm wondering now: What on earth are our MSM doing with themselves as our administration keeps up their stream of inhuman caricatures about these people? I know all people are basically similar, but it sounds as though these folks are downright REAL.
Thank you for taking the time to share a different way of life with us, although it doesn't sound too different. Keep safe.
And also thanks for pointing me in this direction as well. Unlike some people, I appreciate emails. :-)
You're painting a picture of "tolerance in diversity", in Iran.
This is -very- good news, especially in an Islamic (albeit Persian) country.
The Western World needs to ackowledge this social "progress", in one way or another.
I saw a program a while back on how Iran was becoming very secular. Our government like to paint them as religeous lunatics. I guess that is like thinking that everyone is lying when you are the lier.
Thank you for making them human.
It is this group of westernized, educated, young adults that will indeed be Iran's salvation. It is unfortunate that our administration is so uneducated as to how to use them. These young adults want expanded freedoms and a more "diversified" democracy. They are culturally, politically, and socially more savvy than most westerners in the same age group. If properly motivated, they can and will stand up to take back their country from the president they view as illegitimate.
Iran, and many other countries in the middle east have been around for thousands of years, and have at one time or another over the ages been leaders in science, literature, architecture, business/trade, war, music and philosophy. It has only been in the recent past that westerners have decided (American and Europeans) we knew what would be good for them.
I applaud the young Iranians who are willing to stand up for their themselves, and hope they will be the saving grace in that country. They can and should be our greatest ally.
Once again we find that "real life" has multiple dimensions to it , not simply the one dimension the media and politics offers up for sale. The more we get exposed to the dimensions of life other than those the media and politics manipulate for their own benefit, the better the chances are that we might actually understand each other someday.
PS: I hope you're dispelling some of the one dimensional myths about Americans while you're there.
I was beginning to get a bit concerned with not hearing from you. It sounds like you are really getting into whom and what the people are about rather than than the White House propaganda about what a terrified society the Iranians are, hehehe.
If the Dems win next Tuesday you might see the "cannonball" Karl Rove fired overhead as the Republicans finally get he isn't John the Baptist. Hope you enjoy the sight!
Thank you.
By the way, Arabs (Muslims) conquered Persia, about 1,400 years ago, and forced the Persians who are not Arabians, to switch to Islam. But the ancient Persians used to believe in Zoroastrianism.
The zorastians used to believe in 3 simple principals, and their national motto was:
Think Good Thoughts, Speak Good words and Do Good Deeds! That's basically sums up their belief system.
Actually, for the first three hundred years of Islam, the Arabs preferred NOT to convert non-Arabs, but for them to stay as Christians, Jews, Zoroastrians etc. They employed them to administer and provide knowledge of the sciences and philosophy (mostly ancient Greek). The vast majority of those who converted to Islam, throughout the world - from China and India to Turkey and Africa- were converted by non- Arabs. Within 100 years after the Arab conquest of Iran, most Iranians had successfully "translated" much of their traditions into "Islamic" ones, and preserved their native institutions and multi-class system, which is until today very different from that of the Arab countries. The society today is highly secular and Western-oriented. As I recall , the literacy is 96%. The majority of university students are women.
I have a few Iranian friends so I know that what you're saying about Iranian culture is true. As one friend says, the Iranian people are crazy about Americans. The government, not so much. We need to align ourselves politically with the Iranian PEOPLE any way we can, rather than all the sabre rattling.
That is the stupidest question anyone has ever asked me. Let me ask you this: why are you so afraid of different people and why are you so cowardly and reluctant to reach and try to build bridges instead of bombing them? Stupid. Feckless. Cowardly.
And for the record: the people of this country love us. You couldn't be more wrong. But I expect you will live in your ignorance and deny the truth of what I have literally seen with my own eyes. Yeah, you are brilliant, aren'ty you? .
He did answer your question. You're just to obviously blind to see. Read the article and get enlightened. The answers to your singularly inane question are numerous.
Peace
Please write more about your experiences with the Persians. I know I will never get there - so I'm counting on you to help me get these people. I've always been fascinated with them ever since I read about Mossedegh (sp) from the 1950s.
The Shah's son lives here in the states (I think Texas) and wrote a book suggesting that he has a birthrite to be the leader of Iran again. What do you think about that?
I'll answer your question. Countries are geographically bounded areas of the planet Earth. They cannot feel anything at all. The people within those boundaries can, and what they feel is not shared by all universally. No doubt some small number of people that live in the country we call Iran feel hatred for Americans, but of course that would make them kinda silly. Perhaps they think America is like what you think Iran is, a great big person which feels things...
Thanks for sharing this wonderfully refreshing article! I look forward to more.
Perfect.
Peace
Thank you for your reports.
"Stupid. Feckless. Cowardly. "
This is pretty much the calling card of the GOP these days.
It is so vitally important that we are receiving a true report rather then Bush & Co.
propaganda. You & your Dad have a great time. Keep on writing and sending more us articles. Peace & YOU ROCK my friend!! Mo-zy
While Iranian citizens may like Americans, they have even less influence over their government than we do. There may indeed be reason for optimism, as your post shows, but here we are, a generation and a half beyond the upheavals of the Iranian revolution, and the younger people apparently have no more influence over their autocratic government than they had 25 years ago.
It would be interesting to hear from you how your Iranian contacts feel about politics in their country.
Given all the sabre-rattling going on in Washington (and our occupation of Iraq), how easy was it for you to get a visa to Iran? Did you go as a tourist, or have another visa method? Did you get flak from the US State Dept. in an attempt to keep you from going there?
Also, it would be interesting to hear your thoughts on a comparison between Iran and Saudi Arabia. From my readings, it seems that the Arabian kingdom is much more oppressive to women and much less democratic, yet Washington is in bed with them. And we still haven't forgiven Iran for 1979. That was great to hear that people there know about Rosa Parks!
Glad you enjoyed your trip, I'll give it an 8.
Iranian Jews are free to visit Israel and those Iranians who have emigrated to Israel regularly visit Iran to see their relatives. Relations with Israel were good during the Shah's time.
Many of the leading clergy, including Ayatollahs, are opposed to the hardliners . Some have been jailed recently. I spent several years in Iran during the Shah's time, and I have lost many friends there who were tortured and murdered during the first decade of the revolution - and some of those who did it are still in positions of power.
For the past decade Iran has sought to be recognized as a responsible member of the community of nations in order to develop its economy and not acted as a "terrorist" state . The regime wants to hold on to its power and have had to allow the people much more freedom in the public space. Most Iranians have always been independent, strongly secular and pro-Western, and they still are in private. They resent the regime, but are strongly nationalistic when it comes to any foreign interference. They have long memories. They are more interested in jobs and the development of the economy than in challenging their government. Khatami was a good man, and his failure to achieve the reforms he hoped to as president disappointed many and they aren't prepared to challenge the regime any time soon. Outside interference would be counterproductive, because Iranians would unite against it. They feel threatened by the US and Israeli rhetoric. It is Iran's official policy to attack no nation except in self-defense. The notion that they would attack Israel unless the US or Israel attacked them is ridiculous. It would be suicidal. What the US and Israel don't like is Iran's being a power in its region. It is a power in its region, but none of the Arab states are its allies, rather they are traditional enemies. We removed two of their chief enemies, Saddam and the Taliban. The neocon idea to "change the regime" of Iran is crazy. It would threaten the stability of the governments of our allies in the region, and China and Russia would not support it. China depends on Iran for 80% of its oil. An attack on Iran would strengthen its position.
Lauren, your questions are proof of contempt prior to investigation. Silly, lizard brain inanities. Are you enjoying spitting your cowardly spit balls from the comfort of your living room while I am out here really seeing the world? I imagine a part of you is jealous too.
Of course, I don't expect you, or your ilk, to believe me, perhaps the photos will change your mind. I'll post them when I return. Not enough bandwidth here in Iran.
As to the rest of you: it is very hard to post while I am here, but I will answer all of your questions and will post more. A post on Persepolis is coming up shortly. .
Our friend, who was one of the Embassy Guards, is actually quite upset by all of the posturing that is going on over the supposed nuclear ambitions of of Amadinajhad (?). His view is, we should have done what we were going to do then..and that now it is too many years gone by. He definitely has some PTSD from the situation.
My own feelings are that innocent people should not have to die because of the mental illness or incapability of their leaders. I know that it happens, but diplomacy often does help keep a lid on major acts of aggression.
As for the Lizard Brains....I don't know. The world is not a black and white place, and there is much that the average person doesn't understand about foreign policy, history or geography. I think the answer is better schools with more civics and less teaching to the test.
Good work SP. Keep the news coming.