A Story From War/Full Contact in Afghanistan
Greetings,
This supposed "low intensity" war is high intensity for the handful on the burning end. While London and Washington waffle over troop levels, Afghanistan is on course to surpass anything we ever saw in Iraq. We can still turn this war around but at the current rate surely the war will be lost. Indecision on a troop increase is a decision to lose the war. The required information has been presented to leaders in Washington and London. They have all the information needed to make a decision on troop levels. Weak civilian leadership is sabotaging the war effort.
Please see "A Story From War".
--
Very Respectfully,
Michael Yon
* * * * *

Sangin, Afghanistan
Published: 08 October 2009
“In April this year it became 2 Rifles’ dubious fortune to be sent to Sangin on a six-month tour. By mid-August their battle group, a composite force from various units built around a core of several hundred riflemen and fusiliers, had the worst casualties of any British brigade sent to Helmand, with just over 100 soldiers killed or wounded: a fifth of their total patrol troops. The trend suggested that by the time the battle group’s tour ends this month as many as one in four of these infantrymen will have been slain or injured, a figure that compares with British infantry casualty ratios in Europe during the later stages of the Second World War.” ~Anthony Lloyd
Anthony Lloyd, the famed British war correspondent and author has seen much in war. Years ago, when I read his book My War Gone By, I Miss It So, the idea of taking up the pen and going to war had never been in the question. After reading Anthony’s book it was definitely out of the question. War correspondence is a horrible profession. Taking inventory of battlefields, psyches and body parts is an inevitable, recurring theme. The horrors are too many to remember or attempt to recount, if there were desire. And there was Anthony, one of the most experienced war correspondents, and he was going to the same British unit that I was embedded with. Though Anthony’s journey with British 2 Rifles partially coincided with my own, mostly we were at different bases. From FOB Inkerman or during missions in the area, I could sometimes hear the fighting over at “his” base on FOB Jackson because, for instance, soldiers at Inkerman would fire the Howitzers in support of combat taking place around Jackson. Or bombs would drop and noises carry, or sometimes the Apaches would be churning up the enemy with rockets and 30mm cannons. Modern combat can be loud.
As years roll by and more soldiers have done two, three, four or even five long tours, writing about war has changed. In the early years most of the soldiers and correspondents were green to war and were on equal footing, but these days only a handful of correspondents remain who keep going back and their numbers are diminishing, while the concentration of highly experienced soldiers is increasing. The increasing and probably irreversible imbalance means that fewer correspondents will share common experiences with current veterans of Iraq and Afghanistan, and very few writers will possess the experience to render so fundamentally accurately what Anthony Lloyd captures in this story from war.
Comments:
http://www.thunderrun.us/2009/10/from-front-10082009.html
Right now, the lies being stated and claimed by Western Governments are abysmal, and the press is guilty of not even coming close to pressing the democratic governments on this. We are not winning this war. We are not developing the country. We are not achiving any single aim, there is no actual plan, there is no viable battle plan, there is no viable peace plan, no viable development plan, and the enemy has a clearer definition of its mission, and its aims than our own side.
Our troops are some of our finest people, they deserve leadership, resource, and committed support. If the political and international will is not there to both win, then develop, then this is not worth one life, not one troopers wrecked life.
As it stands at this time, no one is willing to step up, and everyone is saying its someone else's job. Its no one else's job, YOU put our troops, or the troops of your own country there, ITS no one else's job to look after them. If they don't have what they need, and NATO will not supply, then you don't leave them hanging in the wind. Right now, its a disaster. NATO is not stopping Al-Quida, or the Taleban. Its a shooting range and a massive propaganda coup, and the lack of leadership is utterly pathetic.
Could you take a guess at how many US troops are needed in Afghanistan? I severely doubtit is just another 45K. There is a rumor that there is a classified report saying 400-500K over 5 years are required. What is your take?
Also what is the realistic feasibility of 400-500K afghan troops under our pay and training over a similar period?
As always, this dispatch has been reprinted with permission from the author, Michael Yon.
Please support this mission by making a direct contribution. Without your support, the mission will end. Thank you for helping me tell the full story of the struggle for Iraq and Afghanistan.


Comments: 17
From the comments: Our troops are some of our finest people, they deserve leadership, resource, and committed support. If the political and international will is not there to both win, then develop, then this is not worth one life, not one troopers wrecked life.
I was touching base with some of my Army moms today. Do you realize how many men and women, sons and daughters, I now know with PTSD? Actual diagnosed cases. How many don't we know?
Then there's the stories of undermanned, undersupplied outposts attacked by hordes of Taleban. This country, our country, has to wake up and force our leaders into making some decisions here.
In the battle for Combat Outpost Keating, the men of Bravo Troop 361 Cavalry lost every possession they had, save for the clothes on their backs. Following this blog posting is information on how to donate to the Combat Outpost Keating Relief Fund. These men havelost friends, their outpost, and all their belongings. One soldier who made it out wrote that "most people back home dont even know, no one gives a shit". Well, many of us do. And you can prove it by giving whatever you can. These guys need things like running shoes, and other essentials, as well as some comfort items like iPods and DVD players. The American Legion has kicked in $1000 to start the fund, and your humble blogger will be the first to donate $100. I intend to get these items out by the end of next week. ANY amount you can give, no matter how small will help us prove that we care.
The Battle for COP Keating
It is obvious who goes to Washington solely for the personal adulation because they are the ones who dawdle over meaningful decision that risk loosing them the praise of those who are risking nothing sitting at home in their quiet comfort.
We Lost in Nam. Why? Politicians that have no business trying to run our military
We quit in the Gulf War. Why? Politicans that have no business trying to run our military.
What politicians am I talking about. Our own and those in the UN. Iraq was purely an American war, although illegal. Afghanistan is another one we will lose. Why? Politicians who have no business trying to run our military, Both at home and the UN.
There have been others and they were all affected by politicians in both our country and the UN who have no business trying to run our military.
When it becomes necessary to go to war because some other nation attacked us our government should get out of the way and let the military do thier job. They are very good at it and don't need the help of some jankenapes in DC or the UN.
Ok so jackenapes isn't a word, sue me.
Well, depends, do you have money? ;)
Both Mr Bush and Tony Bliar should face criminal charges - but the soldiers and their families need our support and donations.
Bring the troops home.
I'm with you Ishbel. Bring the troops home.