In a perfect library, the shelves would be lined with beautifully, well crafted tales, free from error and over wrought prose. News reports would be held to a strict code of conduct, and headlines wouldn't pop up with spelling errors in my news bar.
Since we're no where near perfect. And we are parading our favorite victim, er, em I mean best selling author for a third year. Let's examine what is forgivable.
Is it better to have a grammar perfect piece that had a good premise until the author hit it over the head with the boring stick?
Or can the rules be forgiven to some extent because we have been taken on an exciting ride where disbelief isn't a word, let alone a concept?
Honestly, I'm of the forgiving camp if the story is good enough. That's a big if though.
ing dripping, ly filled, that infected pieces start to grind after a very short time.
Let's examine the exceptions. The books that should suck, but lure us in anyway. Why do we forgive them? What is the special ingredient that caught the agent/editors attention and wouldn't let go?
How do they get published and sold, while other, seemingly 'better' writers don't?


Comments: 303
Actually, I think if the story itself grabs you and doesn't let you go, it has that spark, if you will, I can put away the editing witch and just enjoy the story. I'm might cringe now and then, skip over paragraphs, but if it doesn't interfere w/the flow and pace of the story, I'll read it. I've enjoyed a few that my reactions were as stated above.
Now if the story is only so-so, I'm not as patient.
I'll try to check in later at the hotel. Hugs all!
Yeah to Jill for her sane co-worker!
Example: (The opening paragraph-ish of a book I can NOT get into even though the premise sounds right up my ally.)
Given a Ph.D. in molecular biology from MIT that had been earned in close cooperation with Massachusetts General Hospital, Kevin Marshall found his squemishness regarding medical procedures a distinct embarassment. Although he'd never admitted it to anyone, just having a blood test or a vaccination was an ordeal for him. Needles were his specific bete noir. The sight of them caused his legs to go rubbery and a cold sweat to break out on his broad forehead. Once he'd even fainted in college after getting a measles shot.
At age thirty-four, after many years of postgraduate biomedical research, some of it involving animals, he'd expected to outgrow his phobia, but it hadn't happened. And for that reason he was not in operating room 1A or 1B at the moment.
From Chromosome 6, Robin Cook
Grammatically correct? Yeah, I guess. Execution? You be the judge.
Picking up from the last thread. Pat, we (the field) input everything we do into Citrix, but the employee database in Texas is in Oracle. It's my understanding the two programs don't communicate, so basically everything we do on our end, we have to send them a PTF (payroll transaction form) so they can then duplicate the info into Oracle. Now, I admit, I don't know much about programming, but is that the stupidest thing you've ever heard, or what? And, God forbid, they should give us access to the database in Oracle so we can just skip the middleman. So stoopid.
Wendy, the story is important, but I've been expecting writers to both entertain and be competent for a while now. Hence it's annoying when the writer indulges in massive saidisms or other offences are generally not acceptable.
Nonetheless, I do view some of today's "must have" as stylistic issues which very well may change over time. It does seem like the patience of readers is on the decline, so the leisurely, well executed literary romp of yesteryear will not do well in a period when ADD rules. But will adverbs always be considered passe? We the readers and writers will find out.
Please stop by if you get a chance.
I also got spoiled while reading the Science Fiction greats, some talented western writers and some great literary works. Now, if they can't give me good writing the least they can do is give me a good story. I'll forgive a lot for a good story.
That's the opening for Robin Cook? Straight telling right off the bat. Let's play with his openings...
After years of postgraduate biomedical research, after countless hours locked in labs with both human and animal subjects, and after being on both ends of ill-advised experiments of all stripes, Kevin Marshall had expected to outgrow his phobia regarding simple medical procedures.
But neither age—he was thirty-four—nor education—a doctorate from MIT—had cured him of his squeamishness at the sight of needles.
Thus he was not present in operating room 1A when it imploded on Monday afternoon, vaporizing two surgeons, three nurses, two techs, and the heir to the Bloomfield drug cartel.
This has been a crazed day. My life is at a point where all the cards are flipping at once. A lot of change, not all bad or good, but chaotic. I need to embrace some acceptance to weather it. So far, okay. Decompression is called for, so cue Pride and Prejudice with Keira Knightly, take 12. Only two in the past two days. I don't think my brain wants to manage much more than that presently.
Happy Anniversary James. Sorry I'm late. Enjoy.
Hope Sia is having fun.
And COUNTDOWN commences for Jill. Woohoo!
Hate Not Welcome
I don't read Grisham, Jamie, for this same reason. The stories should be good--the idea's good--but the execution has problems.
Having a good idea is not sufficient to make one a good writer. Maybe it makes a profitable one. But...
So I don't read Grisham because I can't stand the weak writing. However, I've found a romance writer I love for her stories and for her, I overlook the writing. Well, not so much the writing as the poor editing. She repeats herself and repeats herself and repeats. And yes, it does pull me out of the story when I get hit with word, phrase, and thought repetition.
So one author I'll read and one I won't. Perhaps it has to do with the types of errors in their books.
More impact when you show and thread details naturally. We don't need his credentials on the first page. The whole thing makes me cringe. Ick. And it doesn't get any better from there. At least the fifteen pages I forced myself to read.
It's easy to pick on the really bad stuff... but what bad stuff do you love? And why?
I adored the Harry Potter series, even though they are a tad beneath my reading level and I had to keep that in mind when things were too easy to figure out. Duh, it was written for a nine year old. smile All was forgiven because I really fell in love with the characters and their journey.
Over explaining can be scanned if I'm really, really into a story. Some authors look as if they can be scanned and then I get sacked. "What? I missed something. Drat!" Back I go to find the missing piece.
I can also respect an author and their body of work.. without liking to read them. I much rather watch Shakespeare than to read it. So kill me, I don't like getting tied into literary knots.
H.P. Love Craft comes to mind, he lures me in and by the time the story ends, I am sucker punched, and scratching my head, intuitively, on to the next chapter.
I apologize for disturbing the meditation of your highness.
My highpoints so far this week, I added 400 words to Elysia's story and lost another 2 pounds. Not much but then any loss is a good loss I always say. And I am glad to be writing anything so the word count is terrific. Now if I can quit trying to edit the words as I write them. Darn EW.....
Night all, sleep well and be refreshed come the morrow.
So, none of the above?
Jill, yes, those systems sound 100% stupid. And dangerously inefficient in these economic times.
And sorry, I know I'll go to romance hell for this, but for me, Nora Roberts is not all that and a bag of chips. And I used to love Mary Higgins Clark, but now that I know better, I can't make it past her first pages, and recognize that she tells the same story over and over.
Obviously, I'm a story-over-style person, but if the style is seriously bad, I just can't get past it. And it doesn't have to be actually clunky or anything, just not my style. Hence my current struggle to get thru Carol Goodman's The Sonnet Lover. Even though it's a great story, the first person POV present tense is driving me nuts. I don't mind first person POV, it's the present tense part that I loathe.
Apparently I'm not alone in this. In the Emily contest this year, they are making a real effort to target entries to judges. To do this, they ask a couple of questions on things that might "throw" a judge, so a judge won't get something they totally hate. Among these "modifiers" are language, violence/gore, graphic sex, 1st person POV, and present tense. I find it interesting that they recognize that those last two can be as much as a turn off as violence to a reader. I don't mind violence or graphic sex, but present tense sends the book straight into the recycle box.
Congrats on the two pounds lost, Wanda. That's how much I lost this week, too. I wanted to lose more, so I'll blame stooopid germs which interfered with my excercise schedule. They also made me eat two chocolate chip cookies. :-P
And there's a Wombatogether scheduled for today. How fun and exciting!
Wendy, I left a present in your off-gather inbox, and I'm already thinking of ways to improve it. There's a sentence of telling in there and it needs to be reworked. Heh.
Have a great Friday everyone.
I've already got my writing goals for this weekend.
Sed's Pariah: add 4,100 new words
Brian's Muse: Rework 25,000 words.... minimum.
I've read nearly all of Elizabeth Lowell's back list and sadly I discovered what you did with Clark, Pat, the new ones started to become the same story with different dressings. Sobbing!
Well written or not, formula stories drives me nutz, any genre.
I'm surprised you haven't spotted that plate before Ken. Our Masonic temple looks like something plucked out of Athens. Hot spot for rites of passage. Proms, Weddings and heaven only knows what. grin
Got my present Jamie and will be savoring it very soon.
Pat, don't wear yourself out before Sia gets there. And have fun!
*hyperventilates
I just sat down, dang it!
It's harder to read for pure pleasure once one has become a writer, I think.
Warning! Being an author often destroys your ability to relax and enjoy recreational reading.
And yeah, pretty much what Elizabeth said.
Here's the latest, and many local schools are on lockdown today. Geez
I read the new beginning Jamie, and now I want to reread the rest. Cocks brow. Do you have any idea how rare it is that I want to read something twice? I can think of like, one, yes, one other novel.
Off with me
All the police have to do is stake out other places around town:
Banks (applying for a loan)
Apartments (applying for a place to live)
Library (applying for a library card)
Gun shops (applying for a gun)
Greeting card shops (buying a greeting card to send to the prison and writing "Neener-neener" on it)
Post Office (filing a change of address)
The Fair itself (entering 10 years of doilies in the county embroidery contest)
And because I am worn out, I'm not wanting to get off this couch and go for my walk. I'd much rather take a nap. Like Sia. Yeah, I think she has the right idea.
Okay, I'm going. Or I'll hate myself in the morning.
Escape
Harry Potter and the Lost Wizard of Oz
Charlie Huston's Pulpnoir
I ate too much for dinner. Healthy, but still too much. Of course, after yesterday, I had to eat something decent today. I was a junk-food maniac yesterday.
Karma is balanced though, for every negative there has been a positive.
Don't know if I'll get caught up; I've got a blog to write. Pat and Sia must be having a blast right now, huh?
I'm going to bed early. I think my cold is relapsing. I've felt crappy all day. No work tomorrow so time for lots of sleep. Lots and lots of sleep. shhhhhh......
Off to be with me. Not feeling so terrific myself, allergies or a headcold, not sure, just feeling a bit puny.
Viv, I hope all settles soon. Things have a way of whirlwinding once in a while.
Peace to all those seeking such.
Goodnight Neverland
You do know LOST will end in May, yes? Guiding Light ended today after 72 years. Thoughts? I'd love not to need gloves and scarves. It'll post at 12:01 pacific time Sat am.
Off to Stinson Beach for the next 5+ days. Don't know yet if there's an Internet connection.
Perfect timing:
Forecast weather is a 90+ heat wave and Stinson will be 15 degrees cooler.
DB new novel arrived in the mail today.
Good chance to get off the Net and work on some of my fiction.
I'd wish Pat and Sia a great time, but that seems unnecessary.
Would wish Judi good luck getting words on paper this weekend, but that seems unnecessary.
And anything I'd wish Ken always seems unnecessary.
'Nite bats — see you on the other side.
I know I will have things thrown at me for saying this, but it's nice after 34 years of mowing my (sometimes small, sometimes very large) lawns to have someone else take care of it. One of the joys of living in a condo.
So my list for today is:
Number of strangers who mowed my lawn: 1
Number of strangers who blew the cut grass off my porch, patio, and sidewalk: 1
Number of times I had to fill the mower gas tank and yank on the cord: 0
Number of books I read in the time it would have taken me to mow the yard and blow the cut grass off my porch, patio, and sidewalk: 1/3
My parents live in a 55+ community and they don't have to cut their lawn, mulch, weed, shovel snow... AND they have a pool, a clubhouse with a gym and pool table and fireplace and big screen tv and kitchen with a fridge where they can have parties... I wanna move there.
Ken, we just put in our curved shower curtain rod and I love it! It's so roomy in the bath now. I bet Judi loves it too.
Night 'bats!
and Pat and Sia, wherever you are (and wherever you are, I'm sure you're still awake!)
It might be time for me to work on the creative writing and leave the formatting and print-prep to trained professionals. I'll take a look at Scribus, thanks for the tip, Mike.
It doesn't seem like it should be that hard...the stuff I want to do is uncomplicated. I want a blank page here so the new chapter starts on an odd page there. What, that's rocket science?
I didn't think the learning curve on it was too complicated especially since you have a technical background, it should be a breeze Ken.
The Lost Secret