In the course of researching various things I came across something on getting the feel of the flow of a story, finding the bones of a story and by doing so, find out how a popular book on the market is presented and outlined. It was very similar to an exercise I had to do in a college writing course, years ago on the anatomy of a best seller. A simple plotting exercise, if you will.
The suggestion was to pick a current book, about a month or two old in the genre you want to write. Keep in mind even the current books were bought close to two years ago. It was suggested using a book of debuting or newer author since established authors have a lot more leeway with stories than an aspiring author.
Next take a notebook or use a computer spreadsheet—whatever is easiest—and go through the book and mark down the number of chapters. Under each chapter number, count the number of scenes per chapter and mark them on your spreadsheet or notebook. Chapter 2, scene 1, scene 2, scene 3, etc, and once you’ve done that, then treat each scene as a short story and write a one sentence blurb for each scene. As you do this for each chapter, you should be able to see the pattern of conflict and the plot. You can also include a sentence describing the internal/external conflict. If there are subplots these can also be included as a sentence within that chapter. Black moment can also be done that way. You’ll quickly see that the black moment does not happen with in the first 4 or 5 chapters. Once you’ve completed this exercise then write a 15-25-word blurb that describes the story.
What this exercise does is show the bones of the story. It identifies what storylines are working for your target audience and how they’re presented. You can take your own WIP and see if your story’s turning points roughly match up with the outline you have created. It won’t match exactly but it helps you have a visual clue if your MS visually fits your target audience. It also visually helps you to see whether your story is too long or too short, or too simple or complicated. Do you have enough conflict and is the internal/external conflict clear. Where is your black moment?
Even if you are a pantzer, as I am, this exercise helps find the plot, conflicts, flow and pace of a story that fits your target audience and how your story matches up—or doesn’t. It gives you an analytic tool to go back and look at your WIP with critical eyes with the view of making yours better. It also helps in creating a synopsis of your WIP and find the pitch point. Which, as I recently found out is an important part of the process.
One of the things this exercise does is give you and outline, which in turn, theoretically help with a synopsis. I’ve not tried it for that purpose as yet, but I can see where it would help a writer keep the focus.
Have any of you ever done this? If so, what were the results?


Comments: 310
This sounds like a good way to write a synopsis, Sia. And no, I've never tried it before.
And I DO have OneNote on my home computer. Hoozah! I'm already playing around with it.
Utilities suffer from CFLs’ poor power factor
I've got the next thread ready... or it can sit in waiting for an emergency should someone get a wild hair and want to jump in.
Off to read Sia's article.
Anymore the ultimate thrill is to pick up a great story.. so great my edit witch has to be quiet, and falling head first into it. Life don't get much better. lopsided grin
My day? Stupid should hurt. Perhaps then so many people wouldn't settle for it, rather than competent. Rant off. Off to figure out dinner.
I could settle for that.
Sia--I've never tried breaking down a book like this. I don't think I have the patience. I have a friend who did a similar thing--she highlighted dialogue in one color, narrative in another, etc.
The Most Unexpected Truth About Writing
*dancing* Happy weekend! Oh, just me? Sorry. I'm still gonna dance, though. *Shake, shake, shake. Shake, shake, shake. Shake your booty. Shake your booty* LOL Gosh, sometimes you don't realize how really stupid some lyrics are until you type them.
Since I'm dancing and singing anyway, "Happy birthday to you. Happy birthday to you. Happy birthday, Dear Pat. Happy birthday to you." Now blow out the candles, and wish for a virus-free PC.
Glitterfy.com - Glitter Graphics
And YAY, I have my laptop back! It's still missing a finger or toe here and there, and is looking somewhat sticky, broken and confused, it's eyebrows are a bit singed, and I'm at a loss to explain that lipstick stain, but at least it's lost that crazed gleam in its eye! I've slathered it up in every spyware program known to man and we're all wearing surgical masks for a few days, but at least it's back. Paint missing from half the keys,and worn off the wrist rest area, and the slightly murky screen and all. I just wanna hug the poor little thing!
Yes, IT people tend to feel that way about computers. What? You never named one of yours?
Mike, I'm so sorry to hear about the funerals. Those are never easy. Is it rude of me to ask? And I read about the job hunt as well. Sounds as if you are thinking of getting out on your own somewhere. I do hope that doesn't mean anything happened to your mom. I'm sending lots of hugs and well wishes in your direction.
And on the upside, how very, very cool to get a note from Nathan Bransford! WOW! If I'm ever pubbed, I am SO going to beg to be on your blog!
Something cheerful
I'll come back and answer the questions later!
Mom is the same I guess though there has been some small continual cognitive degradation. The hardest part about it is that she now has a realization of how much it has progressed. Bigger concern for me lately has been dad's spinal problem showing advancement. Every so often he has to bend way over to stretch it out because his legs have gone somewhat numb. So far it works but there's that nagging voice that continually goes what if, when if.
At least I was able to put my medically induced cash crunch behind me. Don't care for the personal cost but you do what you have to do.
Gina, that's way too complicated, lolol! But I do like how this exercise can show up some problems in a MS. We had to do something like this in a course i took.
Pat, happy birthday. Turn it into birthday long weekend -- why not?
Sia, on the topic, sounds very methodical. Even though I do outlines, this sounds like a more analytical approach than I'm accustomed to taking. But I can see that it would reveal the bones and story arc. BTW, very cool about getting a note from Nathan. I'm very impressed by his blog and he seems to have a great attitude.
(hold the hoopla for a second) *sigh* sorry about the letter, Pat. Was it on a query, or one of your full requests?
Okay, proceed with hoopla :-)
Sorry life keeps heaping crap on you, Mike. Hang in there.
I think OneNote is a newer version of Notebook. I like the tabs along the sides and top. It's fairly intuiative to use. (unlike Word 2007. who designed that piece of tripe?)
Mike, echoing Jamie on the hang in there thing.
Sia, laughing at you. Well, hopefully, with you. I love Maxine.
(That flash mob video was awesome, BTW.)
mmmmm.... cake...
That nasty demanding "market". Hmmph.
Good point Jill.
Yay, I found an article I can use tomorrow. It was one of my half finished articles. Not as much work as doing it from scratch with burnt out gray matter for a brain tonight.
Jamie, can I say ewww. I'm just dragging butt, not sick, just tired and sorta blah.
Pat!!! I'm so sorry. On to the next one.
Mike, sorry to hear about the deaths. Each one affects us. To endure several at the same time is draining and akin to several blows. Sending peace to you.
end rant. for now.
I have a headache now and my eyes are burning. Maybe it is allergies.
Pat, the rejections do sting, but you've got irons in the fire, so as others have said, on to the next one.
Sherrie, it took me a couple of months to get accustomed to Office 2007, but I've figured out how to do everything I used to with the new GUI. So far, OneNote has been the biggest plus I've seen. Word is over-featured and I've been using Word 2003 at home. I'll have to see how it feels to use it for writing here.
Jamie, sending you hicken soup over the ether. Lots of Vitamin C and other liquids also might help.
Jamie, I've heard that about Word 2007. Those in the office forced to switch have been in tears (I hear Excel 2007 is even worse). They'll make me upgrade someday, but thankfully not yet (the way my life is going, I expect they'll do that next week!) Honestly, I really thought this year couldn't suck any worse than last year. I'm well on the way to being proven wrong. And yes, Sherrie, I'm drowning. Thank goodness for my wombat "life preservers"!
And Jill, the first thing I did tonight was send a thank you to the editor for at least making the request.
Off to see if there's anything I can touch without it turning to crap in my hands. Later my dears.
Aw, shucks. Thanks, Sherrie.
Also, last we heard Sy was suffering a cold. Do you suppose he's still withering?
One more: Does anyone ever hear from Brenda?
And, of course, no list of long-time-no-see Wombats would be complete without a shout out to Junie B!
Okay, I'm done. Let Dana come in and do her own Dana! LOL
Hola Sia . .
Later on . . .
Another one Jill. Um don't you have 3 that need attention first? lol!
Got my article written and scheduled to hit after mid-night. I even have a nice fairy godmother in purple with a wand scattering sparkles everywhere.
Well people, I'm going to bed. Carry on and all that. I'll talk to you all tomorrow.
Happy Birthday, woman! A birthday week is the ONLY way to celebrate (unless, of course, you're GOING TO PARIS)
Jamie, re: Word 2007. Two words: Change Defaults.
It now opens every word doc in perfect Sourcebooks publishing format (except I use TNR 14, instead of TNR12 b/c I'm used to pacing at 14. I switch it to 12 when I'm ready to send it in.)
Jill - I heard from Brenda. Talked to her even!
Oooh! Purple and sparkles!
I'm going to bed. Viv, I checked out your "diva" article - the Wombats have got your back. It's all good. Please don't delete.
Happy Good Friday, everyone.
I can do a Dana!
I have managed to archive a bit more than half of the phantasmagoria stories (with coments) and will do the rest tomorrow.
Great article Sia.
I apparently don't have OneNote. What can you do with it that you can't do with other programs?
My nose is still running, but I'm not coughing. I have a long, crappy day ahead of me, so staying in bed is not an option.
I won't say that you should have at least 7 WIPs at all times, then, Jill. But I only say that because that's what you want to hear.
Feel better, Sy. That bronchitis stuff SUCKS. My lungs still don't have the capacity they had before that horrible case of brochitis I had last year. I can really feel it when I exercise, my lungs say "uh, no".
Off to work. *blows nose
Jamie - defaults. There's no one set place. I right click on a blank page, format paragraph then click on Defaults in that box. Ditto with page set up and font.
Beth - you can do the same thing in Word as OneNote, but it's easier to retrieve. My laptop has it loaded in the bar on the bottom right and when I click on it, it automatically opens to the last one I had opened. Also, I uploaded a map of Florida and the Atlantic Ocean then could use the powerpoint tools (for lack of a better term, but that's what they remind me of) to mark where the hero's house was, where they found the mermaid, where the sea monster's house is, etc. so I don't have to keep reinventing the wheel every time to make sure I get my directions, right, etc. It's like powerpoint in that you can put anything anywhere on the page and move it around easily. And when you copy and paste a picture it automatically brings the web location with it.
Judi, I'm thinking I need a Survivors night. Of Course that entails traveling a bit because, squirrels and bunnies don't do well on champagne.
I have a choice of using my friend Alex's newest word she bought just this year or the one I have that is marked 2006. Now, I do not want hassles when I'm trying to write. I'm wondering about the 2006 version...
Wanda, I do a form of my exercise, nothing as complicated as this. Like I said we did something very much like this in the anatomy of a best seller--we did mmm, I thinking 4 of them and different genres and since then, lot of this type of thing is done mentally when I'm reading.
Bringing Back The Spark—Writing Three-Dimensional
Hicken soup on the the stove and hugs to everyone who needs them. Off with me.
a) Figure that if it was under the "File" menu it is now probably under the little office logo thing at the top left.
b) Understand that what look like menus aren't anymore. They're tabs, with each tab giving a different set of icons
c) Most of the Word 2003 dialog boxes are still there, usually as options on the bottom row of the ribbon. Just click on the diagonal-downward arrow by "Paragraph" or whatever and you'll get the old options
d) Some tabs are context sensitive. For example most of the picture formatting options aren't available unless you have a picture selected.
e) The good new stuff is for the most part not available if you save in Word 97-2003 format, but there is a lot of good new functionality, including some ways of mixing text and graphics that I think open a lot of new doors for page design. Some of the graphics handling stuff is also very useful.
All that being said, the program has been a PITA to switch over to, and I still find myself spending too much time searching for some options.
Got to admit that the title caught my eye.
Luckily, the romance is with zombie hunters, not the actual zombies...
Sia, loved your blog article, and the clip art! And Wendy, sounds as if you are going to have a fun day! And Sy, sorry to hear about the postponed trip. Hope you are feeling better.
I'm all caught up on my email, at last, and am once more going to try to get back to Anne Bonny and see what happens. I read on Nathan Bransford's blog that the first posthumous book coming out from Michael Crichton is going to be about pirates in the 17th century, with sea battles and everything. I have little actual pirate stuff in mine, but it's nice to know pirates never really lose their allure in the marketplace!