I was nearly in tears when I read this article:
RUSHVILLE, Neb. (AP) - At dusk, after all the fancy horses had been auctioned, Doug Barnes settled into a seat at the sale barn and got down to business. Three, four, five or more horses ambled into the ring at a time.
The auctioneer stopped making sales pitches. He looked straight ahead at the familiar visitor from Fort Collins, Colo., waiting for him to tip his hand. Barnes didn't disappoint.
In about 30 minutes, Barnes bought 25 so-called "killer horses." Their new owner would subject them to what animal rights groups say is a growing type of abuse: trucking them nearly 700 miles to Canada for slaughter, circumventing a U.S. ban on the practice. Much of the meat is eventually exported to countries in Europe and Asia for human consumption.
Stacy Segal, a horse specialist at the Humane Society of the United States, and other animal rights activists want a ban on exporting U.S. horses for slaughter abroad.
"They're jammed onto trailers with no regard for breed, size, age, temperament or sex and get no feed or rest," Segal said.
Last year, when state-imposed bans closed the last three U.S. horse slaughterhouses, a record 78,000 horses were exported to Canada and Mexico for slaughter, according to U.S. Department of Agriculture statistics compiled by the Humane Society. That's a 138 percent increase from 2006.
Statistics show that 76,100 horses have been slaughtered in Canada and Mexico so far this year. But the actual figure is likely higher because Canada hasn't yet reported two months' worth of slaughter numbers.
Barnes and others acknowledge that the long trip is stressful on the animals, but they blame animal rights activists who successfully pushed for all U.S. horse slaughterhouses to shut down. They say the increased exportation of horses is better than the alternative: horses being neglected and abused by owners who don't want them or can't afford to take care of them.
"In ranch country, people look at this as a necessary evil," Barnes said one late September day after buying five older horses for $135 apiece.
His boss, Charles Carter, is considered one of the largest buyers of killer horses in the country. Barnes, who scours sale barns in Nebraska, Colorado, South Dakota, Montana and Texas for Carter, estimates he has bought more than 1,000 horses for him this year alone.
Carter didn't return phone messages from The Associated Press seeking comment.
"We're doing them a favor by buying horses that might otherwise be neglected," Barnes said. "The big misconception animal rights people have is that all horses that go to slaughter are good, useable horses or pets ... when actually they're animals you can't do much with."
Slaughter opponents got a hopeful sign from Congress when a proposed export-for-slaughter ban was approved by the House Judiciary Committee in late September. But the bill got hung up in the Agriculture Committee during the final days of the session and will have to be reintroduced next year.
The long trip to slaughterhouses where the U.S. has no oversight isn't the only stress on horses destined for Canada and Mexico. They often spend days in feedlots, where they have blood drawn for tests necessary to get the health approval required for exportation.
Many of the horses are being bought at prices unheard of just a couple years ago. The U.S. slaughter ban, combined with overbreeding, a slack economy and high feed prices, have helped to create a glut of unwanted horses that has dampened the market. The last horse population census, in 2005, showed 9 million horses in the United States, up from about 5.5 million in the mid-1990s, Segal said.
Killer horses that used to sell for about 40 cents to 50 cents per pound before U.S. horse slaughterhouses closed now sell for about half that. At sale barns where Barnes used to compete with several other buyers, he's sometimes the only bidder.
Supporters of a ban on exporting horses for slaughter say the solution to the oversupply is to euthanize unwanted horses or take them to rescue organizations.
But capacity is a problem.
"Typically they're full," said Stephen Rei, president of the National Equine Rescue Coalition, which claims about 200 horse rescue groups as members.
That's the case at Valerie Hinderlider's horse rescue operation near Minden, Neb., Break Heart Ranch, which has 45 horses.
Hinderlider recently was forced to make a grim choice: She bought two horses so she could euthanize them rather than allow the previous owner to sell them for slaughter.
The price to kill and bury - anywhere from $100 to $250 - isn't one everyone can afford or is willing to pay. Nor is there room to bury all of the horses.
"What would you do with all these thousands of head of horses?" Rushville veterinarian Jeff Erquiaga asked, pointing to a trench outside the sale barn that has become a graveyard for euthanized horses.
Erquiaga said he's euthanizing about 25 percent more horses now than in the past. Still, the number he's put down so far this year - about 70 - is a small fraction of all the horses people want to get rid of.
Hinderlider suggested that horse owners seek out other buyers before turning to kill buyers. Many potential buyers have been scared away from sale barns because they've learned they can't compete with the likes of Barnes, she said.
"I've seen kids walk away crying because they got outbid by kill buyers," she said.
Michael O'Connell, of Mobridge, S.D., who has been buying killer horses for 40 years, isn't proud of his occupation but figures he fills a needed niche.
He said he buys thousands of horses annually, about half of them for a large Canadian supplier of horse meat.
"When I first started I hated it," he said while sitting in the sale barn. "I still don't like doing it. But if I didn't, somebody else would."





Comments: 35
I guess I don't understand.
In my eyes the difference between a pig, cow, or chicken compared to slaughtering a horse is the fact that horses, like dogs are loyal animals willing to serve us. Whats sickening to me is - that we go as far as domesticating these creatures, for pleasure, work, or pets and then we turn around a slaughter them or throw them away like garbage ... yes, i guess your right, this is completely fine scince they are of no use to you anymore.
Sorry for the venting - it just sickens me to hear that some people are okay with the idea of slaughtering a majustic, graceful, and beautiful creature .... and say that slaughter is better than putting it down - right so i guess when ol fido gets to old i will skin him and eat him for dinner .... hey kids! Fido taste great .....
:)
It is horrible how people can always justify the way an animal is treated.
If the animals are going to be used for human consumption - aren't there any rules in place for how they should be treated, transported, slaughtered?
I know there are rules in that regard for chickens, cows & pigs.
If they truly believe that they want to continue transporting horses to Mexico & Canada for slaughtering - then they should put rules in place for their safe handeling.
Now I do not condone eating horse meat - and am upset that anyone eats it. I'm glad that they do not slaughter them in the US anymore for food. I do wish the US would come up with a solution that makes it easier to put a horse down if that is the only option available - besides slaughtering & eating the poor animal.
I have a friend who eats cats. Doesn't it bother me? No. Would I ever eat cat? No. But I also never eat anything at their house iether to make sure I don't.
happy thanksgiving!
BTW everyone - Fido was delicious, for christmas i think Rover and Sassy will be next -
the last comment i did direct towards you and i probably shouldnt have, but i was beside myself with your comment right before it. Yes, i dont understand it from your point of view - so i apologize ... i understand your being upset with me as i would as well - i just dont understand how some people see this as okay ... thanks for helping me to be more humble about it .... but i still think its wrong.
Thanks for posting to Points Blitz!! Happy Holidays!!
This is to let you know that your content has reached at least 20 comments and therefore has been removed from I want it All
Please be sure and post all of your photos, posts and videos to the group and don't forget to stop by and comment on group content!