She died at 39. Hit by a car at night while walking home from visiting with her mother. It was winter in Australia and she was wearing a black pea coat and dark pants. It was at the crest of a hill and the driver didn’t see her until it was too late.
The order of events is lost to me. She was in a coma at the hospital for a day, or two. She had no ID on her so the family wasn’t called until she had already died. My uncle, the oldest son of that family of seven siblings, went to the morgue to identify the body.
Here in the States, where I’d come to live with my father, it was the night of a block party when the phone call came. I’d happened to go back to the house to use the bathroom. When I walked in the phone was ringing. It was my paternal grandfather calling from Australia. He asked me to go and fetch my father, which I did.
“Go walk Caroline home” was the first thing he said to me after hanging up the phone. I’d had a friend at the party with me. I did as I was told though I knew something was terribly wrong.
“Sit down, Tonia.”
I chose to stand. I knew it was bad as my sister was sitting in an armchair in the living room with two rivers of black mascara running down her cheeks.
“I have some terrible news. There’s been an accident in Australia. Your mother has died.”
My first instinct was to laugh. And so I walked away as that seemed the most inappropriate reaction to have at that very moment. I went into the bathroom and just sat, and stared at the wall. I had no idea how to react. There was no instinctive surge of grief. I hadn’t seen my mother in over two years, and life with her had been horrific during the last seven years I had been with her.
Finally, a knock on the door beckoned me out. A hug from my stepmother, and then my father, and then goodnights all around as it was late and I was just 14.
I’m sure I spoke with family on the phone in the days that followed. There was a brief discussion about my sister and I going to Australia for the funeral but there was not enough money to afford such an expensive undertaking. All I remember is walking around in a fog. A few weeks after she was buried, two letters arrived. Each was from one of my mother’s closest friends. Sue wrote about the funeral, about the blue sky with puffy white clouds, and how cold it had been, and how the man who hit my mother had attended, and that he was a family man who was devastated by the accident. Yvonne, who did not go to the funeral, wrote more personal notes to both my sister and me, trying to steady us both.
And that was all. My mother was dead, and I had yet to cry.
Thus began a dance that has carried her with me through the years. As I moved forward in time, I pulled her back into her life, back into whatever moment in time at which I’d arrived, trying to see what it felt like to be there, what it may have been like for her.
At 19 she was married. At 25 she was the mother of two infant children, and was a world traveler, a nurse, and an actress. At 28 her marriage fell apart. She was back in Australia, living in a flat in Bondi Beach with her two daughters and a roommate. She attended acting classes, and worked as a nurse, and was having the time of her life. At 30 she was officially divorced and had met another man, and was living with him, descending slowly into a world of drugs and violence. At 33 she had a hysterectomy, and the loss of her self became complete. At 37 she lost both her children, first me and then my sister, sent to live with our father, but she kept her man. At 39 she was dead.
All through those years as I charted her course along with mine, I was able to keep her with me, to learn what it felt like to be standing at a particular place in life and to try to understand the choices that she made.
All through those years, I found her in funny ways. At first it was in fantasy, in thinking that perhaps she was not yet dead, that it had been a mistake and that she would some day just show up. Or seeing someone on the street from behind who could be mistaken for her and wanting to chase them down so that I could know.
Then it was in dreams, the most profound one being the night that the adult me met both my mother and the child I had once been in the same place and we visited. That was all. We just visited, and I awoke with a heart that was breaking open in a new way.
I did visit Australia, and her grave, when I was 22 and then again when I was 32. Both times I hungrily sought out stories of my mother, wanting everyone who had known her to give me their piece of her. And each one did in the ways that they could.
In 1997, when Princess Diana died, I watched her funeral on TV. Seeing those two children walking behind their mother’s casket finally allowed me to mourn, deeply and profoundly, the loss of my own mother.
Over the years, the dance has become less frantic, I could let her go for greater lengths of time. She was with me when I called, always, and yet my need for that lessened as I moved further into the adulthood of my own life.
And now I stand on the brink of 40. I must say goodbye to her in a new way as there are no more landmarks from her life that I can apply to my own. Our dance has changed for now I am the one who must take the lead.


Comments: 52
Sue - I will post a photo for you soon. And thank you as well. This was not an easy piece to write but felt so very important.
sarah - thank you for taking the time to read this.
Verie - coming from you, that really does mean a lot to me.
Kat - thanks, my friend. I do feel blessed.
It is so much more powerful for you to outlive your mother twice, in effect -- once when you were 14, and again now that you will turn an age she never achieved. But you do not walk alone, even as you move ahead of her, as you said it: you simply take the lead now. Do you imagine the decisions you make from here forward will feel different?
Dannielle - that is interesting to hear your perspective. I don't think that the decisions will really feel different but there is some thing coalescing inside me that is changing my perceptions of myself.
In this moving piece, you have used self revelation like a sculptor's tool..and revealed yourself, your mother, and our humanity.
When you talked about thinking that she would walk in any minute, I could so relate for that is what I thought, too, about my father... My mother, trying to "shield" me, kept me from his funeral and that of my paternal grandmother a few years later and, so, for me, they had never really died... They were there one day and then they were just gone for a long time... I remember entertaining all kinds of outrageous scenarios about my father when I was young: He died on active duty with the Army so I would think he was on some kind of "special assignment" where the government had "faked" his death; he had gone off with another woman and my mother had lied about his death to spare me; and many other things...
It wasn't until I stood over his grave, reading his name and the dates of his birth and death in the Presidio Cemetery in San Francisco that I cried... and cried... 48 YEARS had passed between his death and that cry by that time... But I felt better after that... considerably.
This is a beautifully written piece.
Jean - it is a journey, reconciling with such profound loss. I know how good, how healing that long overdue cry can feel.
Phoenix - you've put into words something I could not. Thank you.
Vicky - my mother died 25 years ago - it still astounds me that all that time has passed so quickly.
Aniko - thank you. Really.
Roy - sometimes the writing is necessary. Thanks for spending time with me here tonight.
Madame D - smiling - I'm glad you're home safely, my friend.
Thank you for trusting us enough to share you innermost thoughts and deepest feelings. We love you and hope you continue to heal and be strong. You are an amazing woman.
gonna go hug my mom now.
mona - yes, go hug your mom - it's important.
I'm lucky enough to still have my mother who turns 85 today. The road is rocky, but she is my mother and the only one I'll ever have.
I never had grandparents, and I'm familiar with the part about reaching the age when they died and passing them up. I stopped yearning for a grandmother when I hit 45, as she died at 44. I have my own journey as a grandmother to forge.
On a different level, I think this is an outstanding bit of writing. It is like a prize-winning short story. I am really impressed.
Ruth - I'm blown away by your comment. Thank you. And it seems you do understand what this dance has been like.
My mother died a very long and painful death of lung cancer.
I am comforted by the words of Carly Simon's "Like a River" about her mother after death.
..
U
I look at pictures of mama at my age and often wonder how I will look at 86 - in only 26 years - those years will pass so quickly but I will love every moment of them as mama did! Salud
My mother died when I was 29 - she, 59. No tears at her funeral - mixed feelings. It took my own motherhood to open the loss and grief - and then my spiritual awakening and shamanic training to allow me to get to know her on the other side. We've healed so much - and now she's my "thrift store angel" - a little joke we have about shopping - and also, she's my "good luck connector" in my library job - She was a librarian, and now that I work in a library I find I'm always having these fun good-luck things happening.
We never die. It's not possible to die. We just shed our physical bodies and move along in our development.