Note: This is an entry in the Writing Wombat Slushpile Simulator Contest. I am posting it to maintain the author's anonymity. All rights to this content remain the author's as does all responsibility for the content.
"They killed like men." Janine Hart didn't move from the fetal position. She didn't look up. I looked down at her, huddled under a cot in the one partially intact building in what had been a small Ugandan town whose name I couldn't pronounce.
"Concrete walls six inches thick but they still nearly got her." Jake Smith, the translator touched the portion of the wall where the door had been.
"You know this wasn't really elephants, right?" I said.
"Elephants rampage and kill people," Jake said.
"That they do. It happens more in India than over here, but yes they do," I said. How many people?"
"At least one hundred and fifty," Jake said. "Maybe more."
"And one survivor," I said. "If they really thought it was elephants I wouldn't be here."
Jake made a gesture that took in a panorama of smashed huts and more substantial houses. "No shell holes. No shell casings. No tracks from trucks or tanks. Lots of elephant tracks up to the town and to the smashed buildings. Elephants could smash things up like that. Nothing else short of a bulldozer of a tank could."
I wandered around the wrecked town, looking for patterns. "The Ugandan army's been in a lot of these buildings."
"They looked for survivors and got the rifles and pistols out before looters got them," Jake said. "And the ivory."
"How many guns?"
Jake shrugged. "A dozen—maybe fifteen."
"And one person got a shot off," I said. "They might have hesitated because of the laws against shooting elephants, but enough of them were poachers that I can't see that stopping them. So why only one shot?"
Jake said, "It might have happened too fast. Might have happened at night."
"It happened within a two hour window around dawn yesterday," I said. "See if you get me a map of where they found the guns."
As Jake walked over to the Ugandan army detachment, I tried to make sense of the scene. I've got to admit that I was baffled. That got worse as I correlated where the guns were with the positions of the bodies. "Just like the other three," I said.
Jake said, "Three of them, huh?"
"I'm not sure if you're supposed to know that," I said. "Oh well."
"Any survivors?"
I said, "Not until now. And she hasn't said anything else."
"How is this like the other three?"
I thought about how much to tell him, then shrugged and said, "If there were guns in the houses everybody died in bed or at most barely got out of them. Not guns meant they got some warning—maybe five minutes based on the positions of the bodies. This was systematic. Planned. Everybody dead inside of fifteen minutes—probably less."
"Elephants aren't dumb. Maybe this bunch got tired of people shooting at them," Jake said.
"So they studied the town, pinpointed where the guns were, came in at dawn and got into position. Then they charged in from five locations simultaneously, bypassing houses without guns until the ones with guns were taken care of."
Jake thought about that. "That doesn't sound likely, does it?"
"A human army couldn't have taken this place down any faster or more efficiently," I said.
"Well, they say elephants are smart—"
I shook my head. "This would take so many cognitive leaps that—well bigger than man versus baboon."
"So someone trained them?" Jake shook his head. "Why? Why not just go in and shoot everyone?"
"If they're trying to scare people this is more effective," I said. "But the resources it would take for this level of training—and African elephants aren't as easy to train as Indian ones—"
A helicopter had been making ever wider circles as I looked over the town. I didn't any sign that they had found anything. I said, "Tracks converge on town and appear to


Comments: 21
A bit confused as to why I need to know the witnesses name immediately, especially since a translator is needed. Leads to confusion about Janine Hart, I thought she was the investigator not the women under the cot.
If the two, Jake and the investigator are viewing the scene and noting the lack of tracks from trucks and tanks and the Ugandan army had been there already, wouldn't it mess up the scene?
One problem is the shift in questioning goes from the investigator to Jake after the gun locations are revealed. This is an odd and awkward shift. It confused me. The investigator should be leading with the questions, not providing the answers.
"of a tank could."- should be or a tank.
"See if you get me a map- add "can", if you can get me a map
"I didn't any sign"- add "see", didn't see any sign
This is a great suspense-thriller set up with exotic location, death, and possible romance with Jake and the investigator- if female. Or maybe witness and investigator. Since I got confused when reading the first line I pegged the investigator as a female for the remainder of the story.. I like this premise a lot, but the change in questioning really messed with my head making the scene less clear. Not great advice, sorry, but that was a stumbling point for me.
I am curious, but confused with the story in its present state.
I do like this story and I can see it being billed as a great beach read, summer thriller. I also like the mystery of: did elephants do it or is someone attacking making it look like elephants and why?
Okay, so I think this may have been edited already, I'm not getting confused by who Janine is. Though I do agree that it seems odd that she would have such a Western name and live in a small Ugandan town AND need a translator.
I agree with Viv that its odd that the investigator is giving out more information than he's receiving. Just doesn't sit right.
Definatelt caught my eye however.
Well Done!
Don't really have much more to add to the comments already made.
All in all, though, with a little work this could be a great read. It's certainly an interesting scenario. :-)
I really like this and wasn't bothered or confused.
Great opening line. Intriguing premise. good clues. Makes my mind work and sift through the information. good sense of logic employed here to make it plausible. I'm not sure if "I said", is Janine Hart or someone else. And why is she in a fetal position? Some clarification is need here.
I don't have a problem with the dialog used to show the situation, --it drops us right into the action---but it needs to be tightened.
"This would take so many cognitive leaps that—well bigger than man versus baboon." I love that line.
Pare it a bit so you can set the ending hook to pull us forward.
I, for one, would enjoy reading this whole story--if you need a beta reader? Well done.
I did run into confusion right away, however, not knowing who spoke the first words. Either Janine or "I" could be the speaker. I'm guessing it was Janine because "she hasn't said anything else." But I didn't know that until several paragraphs later. Consider letting the dialogue stand alone as a paragraph and then indicate in that second that the narrator heard her speak or that it was her speaking.
Is Janine alert, then? Why aren't they trying to get more out of her? Why aren't they tending her? They might have already done that, but if so, it's not clear that they have.
Some technical stuff...
"I looked down at her, huddled under a cot..." This implies he was huddled under the cot. Removing the comma would work, though then the sentence sound longer than you intend.
Jake Smith, the translator[,] touched
["]How many people?"
"If they really thought it was elephants[,] I wouldn't
"I've got to admit that I was baffled." Need to cut words? Consider, I was baffled or I admit I was baffled.
"If there were guns in the houses[,] everybody died in bed or at most barely got out of them." Without a comma, this reads, if there were guns in the houses everybody died in... Rather than, if there were guns in the houses, everybody died in bed... (I had to read the sentence several times for meaning.)
"If they're trying to scare people[,] this is more effective,"
--------------
I absolutely love this--"So they studied the town, pinpointed where the guns were, came in at dawn and got into position. Then they charged in from five locations simultaneously, bypassing houses without guns until the ones with guns were taken care of." It lays out the absurdity of the other guy's idea and the rhythm hits well. Just a paragraph that serves its purpose well.
I have the feeling this one could go places. Good luck with it.
Elaine C.
I'm going to concur with Vivian and Beth on this one. I would like to be brought in a bit slower so we don't get lost. It might be due to the dialogue, but slow the pacing just a bit to let us experience it - I had to concentrate so much to see what you wanted me to, whereas I'd like to have it evolve for me as I read. When submitting, end on a hook, don't just trail off at word count. But this has great promise and could definitely garner an ed/agt's interest with some work. good luck!