.
.
.
This article is written in response to a poignant story by Kate C., the remarkable journalist, regional historian, and raconteur who sometimes wears a wedding dress.
Kate's story recalls an episode in her teen-age life in which she provided in home assistance for an elderly neighbor. Resenting the demanding ways in which the lady ran her house, Kate never took an opportunity to encounter her or her history.
In responding to this well-written tale, I was reminded of my own "missed opportunities".
My parents knew, and were distantly related to, the minister of a large church in a nearby town. The clergyman came from an ancient and prosperous family, members of which had endowed a museum that came to be very improtant to the region. He was well-known for his learned and tedious arguments on any subject that might arise.
While not hated or despised, he was the sort of person that was often discussed with a roll of the eyes as an obsessive, long-winded speaker. He was also known to be very opinionated, and somewhat "prickly" about many subjects in which he had invested considerable study.
When I was a child, my parents seldom visited this man because he tended to explain his position on every issue with precison and detail that exceeded everyone's desire to know. My mother, who attended his church in her youth, was more tolerant of the old cleric, while my father quickly tired of the one-sided arguments.
The clergyman and his wive inhabited a large country house, immaculately kept, which contained a Study, a Library, and an Office, all shelved high with books. I liked visiting this man because of the books.
The minister was remarkably tolerant of me, because I loved his books, and he would draw my attention to treasures of his collection. He had examples of the earliest books published in the region and the state, and several pamphlets, monographs, and topical discussions that were privately printed and circulated in long-running public or church-related controversies.
These meant very little to me, and I would find a secluded corner of the Study and read from the collection of very old children's books and grammar school "readers".
I avoided talking to him, partly because of the reactions of the adults around me, partly because I was scared of him, and mostly because I would rather read than talk.
Years later, when I was keenly interested in the history of the old families, the charming villages, the wonderful feuds, church controversies (complete with pamphlet wars, doctrinal investigations, rival churches), and the development of the region, every person to whom I spoke would mention the name of the old minister who had since died.
"It's a shame you can't ask Pastor (Blank)", they would say, " he had interviewed old (local magnate) before he died in 1929". Or, "Pastor (Blank) always told the story about how the highway curves around Charming Village because Judge Worthy threatened the County Commissioners if they ran the road too close to his prized sheep."
My first published work was a chapter I contributed to a collection of essays about the development of a local institution. At the time, I was employed by this organization, and accompanied the venerable CEO as we visited the homes or offices of the founding Board Members to record their recollections and to examine their memorabilia.
I discovered that Pastor (Blank) had already claimed this ground. He had encouraged these men (they were all men) to create a written account of their deliberations and decision-making and to save all their correspondance. Apart from the the sketchy Board minutes, these documents were the most important sources that an author could find.
Pastor Blank had died, in his ninetieth year, while I was away at University. He left his entire collection of books (the whole house-full) to a local Historical Society.
I met socially with some of the curators and researchers who worked with this Historical association. They told me that the collection of Pastor (Blank) had been annotated with marginalia in his own hand. In some books, he had inserted typed notes and cross references, in some he noted his personal recollections or interview notes.
The historians revered him as a "god".
I mentioned, once, that I had known him, and achieved minor celebrity on the spot.
For months afterward, individuals would ask hopefully, "You never heard Pastor (Blank) mention why the Rev. Stalwart refused to allow the Seminary to be built, did you?". Or, "You don't recall Pastor (Blank) saying anything about the incident that caused SleepyTown to close the Colonial Tavern, do you?"
No, I never heard why the Prominents and the Plutocrats had feuded so long over the tiny property in Dullsville, why the BlueJackets had refused communion to the Greenjackets, why the locals were convinced there was a scandal behind the trolley line going bankrupt in 1937, or what had happened to the dashing Italian that had attracted the attention of the lonely heiress before he mysteriously disappeared.
I was in the corner, reading.


Comments: 33
Long before my mother was born, her parents lived in Rhode Island and owned their own restaurant in Providence. My Uncle is the last member of the family who was alive during those times, and he used to cook the steaks they served -- he has always been a superb cook.
He is the only person who knows the name of Gramma & Grampa's restaurant. I have just called my mother and asked her to ask her brother for that bit of information.
Dannielle, how nice to recover this bit of historical information. It can lead you to other discoveries.
Thanks flit, and Marilee.
I had an incident when I was about 20 in which I identified the opportunity and someone else ruined it for me. My first wife's grandfather had been a medic in WWII. This is not uncommon but from passing references he made I realized that the man had taken part in every major amphibious invasion in European theater. North Africa, Italy, Normandy, he was at them all. This man help first-person accounts within him of some of the greatest military actions in human history but he would NOT talk about it. As much as I made it obvious that I would listen to him for however long it took, he just didn't want to talk about it.
About a year after I found this information out, my first wife's grandmother became terminally ill. My ex-wife and I went to see her so that she could say goodbye. One evening, about sunset, I was sitting outside the house with my ex-wife's grandfather (the one who had been in WWII) and her brother. The grandfather was watching the sunset and began talking about a documentray on the Normandy invasion he had seen and how strange it was to see beaches he remembered, even people in the pictures he knew. I just sat in rapt silence, finally able to hear the incredible memories this man had. Right at that moment, my ex-wife's brother (18 yrs old at the time) spoke up and changed the subject. I wanted to punch him in the face. The old man later died and as far as I know, no one ever got him to document or record everything he saw. Such a waste to history.
Dannielle, Fiume is also the Italian (and Hungarian) name of the city and port of Rijeka, in present-day Croatia. "Rijeka" means river in Croatian, just like "fiume" (from Latin "flumen") means river in Italian.
This remembrance of my childhood was inspired by your story, Kate.
AC, your experience is frustrating.
One never knows which meeting is the "last opportunity" to gain first-hand information from a source.
I think that many vets feel some reluctance to re-live their wartime experiences.
Matt, I don't know any family historians who have not expressed similar disappointment at the loss of primary recollections or "connections".
Aniko, while Pastor Blank was eager to share his knowledge, he would NOT have been an easy person to interview.
I love the multi-lingual word lessons in your posts!
If anyone can't decipher it, let me know and I'll redo it.
In response to Aniko's fascinating comment, I can only say that my grandparents came from Italy, so I'm confident that they were using the Italian word; I just don't know why they chose it, since I have no idea where the restaurant stood.
My uncle gave this explanation: "I was six years old when we [opened? built?] the restaurant, and that day we had a huge rainstorm. As the water flowed past, I said to my father, "That looks like a river!" and that's why they chose that name." When asked if this was a true story, the answer was "That's for you to decide."
Stephanie, i can understand the meanings of the one-handed typing. Hope that you and Roxanna are thriving.
Your attention to the details of the story leads to important conclusions:
Tthere are many potential sources for any story, the pastor's importance was because, like every good amateur historian, he collected information and wrote it down.
Adults generally remembered the Pastor more fondly after he was dead than they did while his lofty manner and verbose speech was constantly irritating them.
Dannielle, the question about the meaningfulness or reliability of first-hand information is one that requires an exercise of judgement. Plausibility, other evidence, motivation to fabricate, contradictory assertions, these are the things that make the historian's task interesting.
That might be a factor in naming the restaurant, too, Dannielle.
When I was a child, I loved to listen to the older folks in my life, as I never had grandparents and always felt I was missing something. As I've aged, as I said in Kate's thread, my patience has worn a little thin. I'm glad to see all of these stories published here. I need this kick in the seat to make me a little more tolerant. I may be in over my head with octogenarians right now, but it won't last. I have to remember my blessing.
Working with geriatrics can be frustrating. People do not generally become "nicer" with age unless they were nice people in earlier years.
When I worked intensely with geriatrics, one of the things that stuck with me from my training was that "People become more of themselves, whatever they are, as they age".
So, if you want to know what you will be like at 80, take a good look at what your are like at 50.
Age does not change, as much as it reveals.
Sorry to start preaching; Pastor Blank must have rubbed off on me in some ways after all.
Glad that the story helps you feel more tolerant!
My mother was difficult at 50; she's even more so, now. My MIL, according to my husband, was spoiled rotten. This truly shows. My father has always been sweet and gentle and he remains this way. My FIL was certainly a wonderful man at 50, because he is now, and he raised my husband to be the kindest of souls.
So, when I'm 80 I'll be a fairly nice woman who still collects shoes.
"when I'm 80 I'll be a fairly nice woman who still collects shoes."
That is likely to be true, Ina.
That's not what I remember best - he used to read to me when I had insomnia or watch movies with me late into the night - but it was a good indication of his nature. He was a landscape architect and he always had flowers growing for his girls, too. He'd cut off a gardenia when I came to visit and put it in my hair. I still associate the smell of gardenias with him.
I was the opposite kid. I wanted to know everything about everybody. When the other kids went out to play, I often stayed behind to hear the stories or play music with the old people. Consequently, my memories of one grandmother are not like those of the other grandchildren. I might be the only one who liked her.
Do you know where in Italy your grandparents came from? I don't think it's likely that they would have come from Fiume and called it Italy, but it might not be impossible either. Italians considered Fiume an Italian town, and large number of Italian speakers went into exile at the time of the Yugoslav takeover.
(I have several friends here in the US who are ethnic Hungarians from Transylvania [Romania]. If they're asked where they are from , the short answer is usually "from Hungary". The long answer, given on a need-to-know basis, is how I described them above. "We're from Romania" is not something they're likely to say.
My grandfather was born in what is now Serbia but was Hungary at the time of his birth. He was a Hungarian citizen by birth, then a Yugoslav citizen by peace treaty, and then a Hungarian citizen by naturalization. Things can get pretty crazy in that part of the world....)
Thanks for making this point, Sandy.
While I regret the missed opportunity, I am glad to have had the connection that I did.
Aniko, you illustrate very clearly the enormous difficulty we have in understanding the bits and pieces of family history that come down to us.
An excellent enterprise, Marilee!