For about the third or fourth time in just as many months, a security person ousted me from a public place.
Several months ago, I visited San Francisco. Mini-Madame and I strolled into a very expensive New-York-Big-Name department store.
Armed with only a purse full of credit cards and a camera, I attempted to get shots of some shoes for my friend, Ina. Mini-Madame stood nearby to hold off a couple of other shoppers when, virtually out of thin air, there appeared three large men in black suits.
My first thought was to run, that Men in Black was not really a movie but a reality. One of the men approached me while the others stood arms akimbo, ready to "take me down" if necessary. The man, the one with lengthy nose hairs, said, "Lady, you can't take photos here. What publications are with?"
Meekly, I said, "Umm, Gather?"
He said, "I'm going to have to ask to leave. Right now."
I guess writing on Gather doesn't give me any press credentials no matter how many words or photos I post here.
I turned to Mini-Madame, "Come on, baby, we don't want to waste our money here anyway."
We took our sweet time leaving the store, as if we were walking toward a long shaft of white light in a horror movie.
On a visit to Boston in November, security requested me to leave the subway tunnel at Porter Square. I shot about a hundred photos of my family in the subway car while we traversed the city. I shot some wall tiles. On my way out, I tried to capture a few shots of a pile of subway escalator steps in need of repair.
A uniformed guard grabbed me brusquely by the shoulder. I screamed, mostly because I thought a mugger wanted my camera, and then pushed the guard before my eyes clearly focused on him. I came close to being arrested for assaulting a public service officer when, in reality, he accosted me.
Apparently, the events of September 11 rescinded the opportunity for Americans to photograph underground transportation terminals.
Yes, I could have been arrested and accused of potentially being a terrorist threat. Who knew? There were no signs saying, "No photographs, no cameras, don't do it."
While at the Winter Fancy Foods Trade Show just a mere two weeks ago, a uniformed person asked me to put my camera away. In yet another instance, a security guard approached me and requested my "Press Pass."
I said, "I'm taking photos to print with an article I'm writing for Gather."
He said, looking at my badge identifying me as a Trade Affiliate, "you are not a member of The Press ma'am."
I said, "My name is Madame, and I know that."
He told me to either put the camera in my camera bag and leave it there-or leave the premises.
Today, I shopped at a new produce market. They had some beautiful fresh fruits and vegetables. I pulled out my camera and before it captured one photo, the manager said, from behind me, "Madam, you can't do that here."
Finally, someone got my name right: it's Madame! I'm not Lady or Ma'am; I'm not Hey You or Get Away From There. I'm not Stop That or I'm Asking You Nicely To Leave the Premises.
Nevertheless, please tell me, what the heck happened to America? I cannot take a photo in a department store of a simple shoe, nor at a subway station, a trade show or a grocery store!
Yet, Google can photograph my house with its address visible, my car with my license plate showing and me in my living room if I happen to be sitting there when they drive by!
Suffice to say, I went immediately to the train depot and shot these photos. I was happy as a clam in seawater when I realized the train car that stopped right in front of me was the Coach café car!
I am traveling again next week. If I do not return, please start a bail fund for me. Some of you have my phone number. Use it if you haven't heard from me in more than twelve days. If I do end up in theBig House, someone please make sure that Tonia gets to keep my camera.
Oh, and please could one of you send a cake with a file in it? Sandy?





Comments: 70
Obiously the only reasons people without press credentials would take pictures in stores would be for industrial espionage or a lawsuit. :) All industrial spies and private investigators have clearly visible cameras too.
It's probably personal though.
Should we start a campaign?
(and I'm not going to say a WORD about you being upset over people not wanting you to take pictures when you are the madame of no-pictures-of-me. Nope, my lips are sealed on that topic.)
charles, thank you. I'd almost forgotten that you could identify me in a lineup. I will phone you the minute they give me the one call I deserve. I have your number tatooed on my ankle.
Faith, you have a good point there. I'll see what strings I can pull with Tom. I'll be back in Beantown sometime this spring so I think I'll turn some screws and see what sort of passes I can wangle outta him. (Oh, and Tom, if you see this, wanna have dinner?)
elizabeth, believe me when I say I've been ousted from many other venues in my time. I've been dragged across pavement when I was protesting, but this is a bit absurd that no matter where I've been I can't take a simple photo to commemorate the moment, let alone write something about it with a photo.
Ivy, thanks for your help. I've been trying to avoid a mustache since I entered menopause. Maybe a nose with glasses would be a better fix?
Marianne, that's precisely one of my points. There are no signs indicating you are in the wrong yet you can be arrested for using a camera--in America!
Duckie, yes, start a campaign!
Sandy, it can't be worse than being linked to some of my real life relatives...believe me. Now, more than ever, I am keeping a low profile with no photos. Can you imagine if they actually knew what I look like at the Bureau? I'd be doomed.
Oh and that card? Hmmm, I should remember to never leave home without it..huh?
It's profiling -- you're green.
I used to work for a store that went all draconian about people taking pictures in it. After about the third year I started prefacing my please-don't-do-thats with "I realize this will sound insane, but..."
Kevin, that must be it! (By the way, I made your lamb shank recipe tonight and it was incredibly...ooops, sorry, seriously good!)
Kris, It pisses me off no matter how funny that person is trying to be with me. It's lunacy.
(I know, I've worked on fund raising for first responders. We can take 'em.)
The young (in)security guard informed me I was not allowed to take photos in the mall. Fine.
However, it was permissible (according to mall regulations) for some strange young man to grab my hand and begin buffing my thumbnail to a thin layer of dust before I could yank my hand free!
We live in unreasonable times.
Cindy, my camera does have a rather long and imposing lense but no trigger. I wear it like a necklace almost everywhere I go. I've done so since the 60's and never until recently ran into difficulty. Well, there was one time in Sri Lanka, but that was a long time ago.
They did stop me from taking pictures at the da Vinci exhibition over here (no real da Vincis, so it wasn't about protecting paintings from flash photography or anything). The guy's tone was somewhat sharp, so I assume there was a sign but I didn't see it. That happens when you're trying to get three people's audio tour thingie to work.
I know when we were at the port in San Pedro a couple of weeks ago, there were signs all over saying NO PHOTOGRAPHY. One Japanese tourist began to snap photos and before he could pose his party for the photo, out ran, LITERALLY RAN, four armed guards yelling at him to stop.
It's a shame we have to be so careful about this these days!
True. OK, you wear your wedding dress and have your husband take the photos.
Ivy, we are not secure at all. I live in an area with Navy, Marines and Air Force and they can't catch a drag racer on the freeway!
Janna, that's even more frightening. Let's just go ride a roller coaster. I'll leave my camera at home.
Sheesh, Madame, you'd think they' see the positive side of your photography, the good will and the good advertising! Our culture is getting nuttier and nuttier.
Now I'm scared to try it again. I have all kinds of essays in my head and I'm afraid they won't have anywhere to go. Maybe it helps that my camera is only about 4 inches long and 1/2 inch thick. I can slip it into my pocket between shots. Damn it! I'm still going for it. I'll not be denied!
I'm honored that you were first accosted while thinking of me, though!
You can see from my articles that I take my camera everywhere, and photos of everything I see. The only problem I had this past year was a guard in a Cathedral (in Spain) tried to stop me from taking pictures. I said I understood it was permissible with a permit, then pointed to the guide and said she's carrying them. Is there anything else?
He just looked at me, at her and left me alone.
But because Dorine is pictured above me I'm reminded that the host on the morning radio show on our local NPR station (WAMC) said he was stopped from taking pictures of the Liberty Bell last Summer by an armed guard. How'd you get that shot Dorine?
Madame - try to stay out of trouble, please. If you end up in jail your missives will be missed. The next time you get a subversive urge to photograph shoes, make sure they are on your feet.
I've never been thrown out of a place though. Wow. That is obnoxious. I've never tried taking pictures in a store before though.
Bongo, unfortunately many countries try to emulate ours as if it's a good thing.
Aniko, yep, that stuff is spreading all over the place.
Thanks, Dorine. This stuff is just too restrictive and I can't see where preventing me from photographing shoes is insuring anyone's safety.
Ina, I will not stop trying to capture the images I want. I'm almost hoping to get arrested for it to bring more attention to the ridiculous level of repression we are subjected to in America. Home of the free?
Richard, it is interesting where the limitations begin and end. I have a photo of my brother actually touching the Liberty Bell! I will try to behave, Richard, but no promises. A girl's gotta do what a girl's gotta do.
John.
Risa, these instances are definitely increasing. My awareness of it is heightened because I have always taken photos on a daily basis wherever I happen to be at the moment. I'm having more and more difficulty with it.
Karen, I've noticed that at some department stores. My gripe is especially at stores or places with no visible warning. The older I get, the more restrictive this society seems to be growing and I see it as a bad thing.
Tonia, Hah, you're quite the commenter today! Thanks, I want to hang around too. I guess I could come to Arkansas and click to my hearts content. (Adding that to this year's itinerary). Sandy sets a great example.
Aileen! Zowee! Great to see you again! Yep, born to be wild, just a coastal wild child! And you?
Cafes and eateries usually like you to take photos for the publicity but don't catch two people at a table in the corner...just like in casinos they want no cameras to protect the reputation of the players.
Or its because you Madame, look like a trouble maker and an excuse was needed to get you out the door!
Wurdz, letters would brighten my day! Thanks for the support.
That's just crazy.
What if you were a mystery shopper for that company?
I found what you need right here....
Flickr has a press badge
http://bighugelabs.com/flickr/badge.php
Gather.com I.D
A Downloadable Flyer Explaining Your Rights When Stopped or Confronted for Photography
The Photographer's Right is a downloadable guide that is loosely based on the Bust Card and the Know Your Rights pamphlet that used to be available on the ACLU website. It may be downloaded and printed out using Adobe Acrobat Reader. You may make copies and carry them your wallet, pocket, or camera bag to give you quick access to your rights and obligations concerning confrontations over photography. You may distribute the guide to others, provided that such distribution is not done for commercial gain and credit is given to the author.
http://www.krages.com/phoright.htm
Joy, thanks for the info. I downloaded the pamphlet and I'll read it later tonight.
This is potentially serious, I know, but do you see the humor too??