Do You Have Fibromyalgia? Respond to the NY Times Article!
by Marilyn Mackenzie
Â
Do you have fibro or know someone who does? I don't know about you, but I thought that having the Food and Drug Administration approve a drug specifically for fibromyalgia was a breakthrough in having this disorder recognized.
Today, I received a shocking email from The FMS Community.
Here's what the email said:
Controversial Article in the New York timesÂ
In the interest of fairness we included an article written by Alex Berenson that was published on the front page of the New York Times.
This controversial article has sparked discussion around the globe. The author insinuates that Fibromyalgia is not a valid condition. How many people have read his work and formed an opinion based on this one man's opinion?
Make your voice heard by sending us your thoughts on this controversial article. (posted below)
We will compile your comments into one document and send them to the New York Times in protest.
Please make sure all posts are free of profanity or other unsuitable content. These type of posts will be omitted from the mass mailing.
Send all comments to turn_ip@cox.net
Sign the posts with the name you want displayed in the final copy.Â
*****************
I have not included the entire front page article that appeared in the New York Times, as the FMS Community did in the email. Instead, I included a link to that page where you can read it for yourself.
Here are a few lines from the article, written by ALEX BERENSONÂ that appeared on the front page of the NY Times:
But doctors who are skeptical of fibromyalgia say vague complaints of chronic pain do not add up to a disease. No biological tests exist to diagnose fibromyalgia, and the condition cannot be linked to any environmental or biological causes.
The diagnosis of fibromyalgia itself worsens the condition by encouraging people to think of themselves as sick and catalog their pain, said Dr. Nortin Hadler, a rheumatologist and professor of medicine at the University of North Carolina who has written extensively about fibromyalgia.
"These people live under a cloud," he said. "And the more they seem to be around the medical establishment, the sicker they get."
Dr. Frederick Wolfe, the director of the National Databank for Rheumatic Diseases and the lead author of the 1990 paper that first defined the diagnostic guidelines for fibromyalgia, says he has become cynical and discouraged about the diagnosis. He now considers the condition a physical response to stress, depression, and economic and social anxiety.
"Some of us in those days thought that we had actually identified a disease, which this clearly is not," Dr. Wolfe said. "To make people ill, to give them an illness, was the wrong thing."
Here's the rest of the article:Â Drug Approved: Is Disease Real?
Â
If this makes you angry, please either write directly to the New York Times or direct your letter to Alex Berenson or send your response to the email address above so the FMS Community can respond in one document.
The FDA finally approved a drug specifically for fibro. We don't need to go backwards and have doctors, our families and the community at large wondering if what we suffer is real.
Â




Comments: 57
I have a fibro-something else, but not fibromyalgia.
I was Ill for eight months last yer, I kept going to specialists, no one could figure out what it was. My husband began to fear he was going to lose me over a mystery illness. I went to a rheumatologist who diagnosed me with Fibromyalgia and he began a treatment which included Lyrica. Within a week I was up and back to mysellf, full of energy and LIVING! My husband said the recovery was like a miracle. Is Fibromyalgia real ? I would have to say YES!!!!!!!
Fibromyalgia
Then I was diagnosed. Part of what they taught us at the Fibromyalgia Clinic at Mayo was to learn to recognize what symptoms are part of the Fibromyalgia and how to deal with them so you don't have to run to the doctor or freak out everytime you experience another scary pain or sensation. I have been much better, seen the doctor only for routine check-ups and been off cortisone and pain meds since I was diagnosed. Once my symptoms were given a name, I was able to stop fretting and worrying and to start dealing with it and getting better. The author of this article is way off base.
The people who do not believe, have NO idea!
Symptoms by any other name would feel the same. If someone Alex Berenson loves is stricken with this disease, he will feel responsible for having helped to cut off their access to treatment. I hope the researchers consider that possibility, too.
years or so. I have gone through every test imaginable and tried a little bit of everything. I was relieved when they finally diagnosed it. Now their was a name for it,
hurrah. So then we had to experimnet with all types of meds and physical therapies.
That took a while. Then one day I got a bright idea. I decided to see a massage therapist. I go every two weeks. She had to start out slowly with me she could barely touch me especially around my pressure points. I decide to go to a chyropractor who specialized in FMS and got a new GP. Between the three and my wonderful husbands
understanding I am so much better. (a couple of years now) Sure I have my days. But who doesn't?
This guy should have suffered what we have for five or six months and I bet he'll change his mind. I'll be glad to write the New York Times or anyone else that blatantly makes such comments. He apparently doesn't know what he's talking about. I would hope some of the MD's would let him have it over the head or right between the eyes. OH, GOD, THAT FELT GOOD!
10 4 u
Knowing didn't change my life but it helped me to understand what I was going through. I have never used it as an excuse or a reason to gain money or sympathy. It just is what it is.
And pardon my words but Alex Berenson is an ASS. A real journalist investigates a subject before he passes judgement on it. If I owned the paper he would be out of a job!
This article chapped my jaws. I have been dealing with fibro for years and struggle each day. I go to aqua therapy NOW at the U of M in MI. which seems to be helping with the pain thus less pain meds.
You can be assured I will be writing ALEX BERENSON and the New York Times for their flagrant disregard of people hurting both physically and mentally from this....... DISORDER is what I choose to call it, not a disease; although by all practical terms it is because Dis-ease is what we have.
I can't tell you how much this concerns me when we have an attack on people who have struggled sooooooooooo hard to be heard. It is my firm belief big money is behind the attack, as it usually is, more on this when I write again as, I need to go on with my everyday struggles to get something done today that needs to be done. Thanks and here is a 10**********! for looking out for hurting people.
I think there is still lots of work to be done with this disease. No one really knows what causes the pain. Some in the medical field don't deny we are in real pain but question why we have pain. I am ordering a book by Dr John Sarno about mind and body. He thinks emotions that our brain can't deal with become real pain elsewhere. His patients have had had great success using this theory. Hey, it's worth a try for me.
If you punch in his name on a search engine a Wickopedia article even has a video about him on 20/20 from 1999.
I did gain weight when I first took Lyrica, but had I been warned that could happen , I would have been more careful of what I was eating. The weight gain stopped and the side effect of feeling better for me was more activity, and now I have lost weight I am down to a size 12 from the size 18 I was previously. I noticed a big difference when I stopped taking Lyrica, the pain returned so I know its not in my head. I am back on these until my fibromyalgia recedes.
Vana, I'm with you. I'm wondering who paid this doctor to recant his story.
I hope that all of you who are angry will write to the NY Times yourself or will send your emails to the address above so they go in a mass mailing.
Angel
Aesop for Monday, January 21
The only reason my depression has increased is because it's discouraging not to be able to work or to have any income at all. And medical costs, even with insurance can be horrible.
Finally, my doc told me it was fibro. She offered me Lyrica, but not being one to take drugs unless they are practically forced down my throat, I opted to self-manage.
I can't say I'm all better, but I'm much better than I was. I finally have a reason for the pain, and am learning to manage.
I still work, full time, and you'd never know I was sick to look at me.
It's irresponsible, at the very least, to report on one side of any story like this. But, this is the New York Times so I don't know why anyone is surprised.
There have been days that I could not get out of my bed because of the pain that I have. The pain and fatigue interferes with living my life - my intimacy with my husband, my work, and my social live. How hard is it to live a life where your husband has to help you get out of the bathtub because you are too weak to do it? How bad is it that instead of having Christmas with your family, you're in bed because you'd rather rest and sleep than be around too much excitement? How terrible is it for a romantic relationship when you don't want to have sex with the man of your dreams because it hurts to be touched?
The pain and the fatigue of both diseases are VERY REAL! It angers me that some doctors still do not think that Fibro or CFS are "real" diseases.
I have been on Lyrica since November. Since then, my fatigue and pain has improved. No - the drug is not a cure-all. But it sure helps. I get a better night's sleep and can function better during the day at my full time job. I still have days that are bad, and probably always will. But Lyrica was an amazing breakthrough for me and my condition.
The author should get the facts and talk to "real people who suffer from the disease" before reporting lies!
I hope I don't forget, this is really too important. I guess I can put it on the calendar. :)
By the way, I don't mind at all getting mail about something like this. :)
Thanks again. I beat the brain fog tonight. I think I'll beat it tomorrow too. :)