How many times have you seen a film and it resonates within you? I’m not talking about getting all breathless over star, or even getting jazzed by the plot or action or whatever. No, what I am talking about is a film making connection to your real life.
Michael Moore’s Sicko does that for me.
Moore's film is hitting the DVD shelves this week. Like his other films, Sicko is a populist, uneven slam. Previously, he lobbed Molotov cocktails of invective, honesty and over statements at General Motors, the NRA and the Bush Presidency. His films are as outsized as his girth. Yet no matter WHETHER you like or detest the man, his films are comedic and thought provoking.
In Sicko the object of his scorn is one of the largest, basest business' in this country, the inaptly named Health Care industry. Moore assails this regrettably necessary monolith as avaricious, callous, manipulative, and a supreme marketer OF half truths. They are not concerned about health. They are not concerned about care. They are a profit driven industry trading in the well being of humanity.
In Sicko, Moore details how everyday folks face incredibly hard medical decisions. Which finger should be saved? What medicine to forego? In one compelling sequence, 9/11 workers suffer and have no recourse, even though they are true American heroes.
I have not been in that position, nor have I had any major illness, but my dealings with my insurance company ARE as distasteful. My wife nor I work for a large company. We’re independents. You know, the folks who, according to the American mythology, are this country’s backbone, but as such, we are not eligible for group rates. We are at the mercy of health insurance providers.
This past year our insurance rates WERE raised by Anthem Blue Cross of New Hampshire by over 50%. We had no hospital visits. We don’t have any expensive medications. You can count on one hand the number of times we have been to see a doctor. So why has our alleged ‘provider’ jacked the rates so high in one year?
Simple, they don’t like me. When you raise rates that high, they are sending a message. We don’t want you. Why? Probably because they’d rather deal with large corporations. It’s easier. The other part of the equation is also simple. They mismanaged their business. I have fallen into a demographic profile they have found to be unprofitable. So rather than be caring, they respond by making it onerous and difficult. Of course, if they are questioned, a pat answer about rising costs, responsibilities to stock holders, or some other equally inane response will roll off their tongues.
So Michael Moore’s Sicko, splashes cold water into the soulless face of heath care. Some of it maybe a bit much, but you will see health insurance companies as they are. Their bottom lines and the executives well paid jobs are their concerns. You are not.
Remember this, it’s not about those who have and those who don’t. These days its about the haves and the been had. Sicko makes that quite clear.
Garen has been sitting in the dark for over 30 years as an film exhibitor, consultant and reviewer. You may have seen him on NE Cable or some other Boston station. More likely you heard him pontificating about films on NPR, TKK, RKO, New Hampshire Public Radio, or any number of other stations he's been on, but one thing is certain, he loves, and knows, film.


Comments: 30
this is my documentation of what laxxed medical care has done.
Whos really profiting
As a nurse, who has dealt with the issues being raised in "Sicko", I can't wait to see(and review) it. My job for the last hundred or so years has been determining, and submitting for payment, services covered by Medicare, Medicaid and various insurance companies.
Believe it or not, it is infinitely easier to get the Gov't to cover certain treatments, than the major insurance companies.
Insurance companies have a vested interest in not paying. That alone is a good reason for universal health care.
I find your personal story very interesting; specifically the fact that your rates have been raised even though you haven't incurred any medical costs. People like you are supposed to be the true life's blood of the health insurance industry; you pay your premiums and file no claims. You'd think they would greatly appreciate you. Apparently they do not. 10
And Donna F, there is a huge fallacy in this country which states the government is inefficient and business is efficient. Let's see Dick Cheney and Donald Rumsfield are from the business sector. Their prosecution of the Iraq war is rife with billions and billions of dollars of corruption, inefficiency and waste. Hmm, I wonder what that really says? Think if just some of that money went to health care?
My blood pressure will go up and I'll have an anxiety attack. I'll be rushed to the hospital where I'll endure an EKG, and EEG, an MRI and all the other alphabet soup tests that will prove I'm not having a heart attack. I'll be released the following morning so I can go home. I'll rest up for a couple of days to muster up the strength to wrestle with the red tape I'll get from my insurance "provider"......right after I meet the $6,000 deductible. Nope. I don't want to see MM's film; I've lived it.
I believe that a high deductible, low premium insurance with an HSA is going to be the way to go.
Medical care is fuled by greed and eventually greed will cause the medical industry to collapse. How many companies or individuals can afford a double digit increase in health insurance premiums every year or the sky rocketing cost of prescription medicines? Not many. The best thing to do is to address the issue of affordable insurance here and now while we can.
> independents. You know, the folks who, according
> to the American mythology, are this country's
> backbone, but as such, we are not eligible for
> group rates. We are at the mercy of health
> insurance providers.
This group rate scam is the most insidious evil
arbitray BS I can believe. You hit the nail on the
head, as did Michael Moore, and I usually do not
care for Michael Moore's stuff very much.
Why we put up with this BS system is because
most people do not know about what the problems
are until it is too late and as long as you keep the
total number of screwed over people just low
enough nothing can be done ... there is democracy
US style for you.
Another thing I enjoyed about the movie was the
Brit talking about democracy ... funny, a Brit
lecturing the US about democracy, but the world
has changed, and the US need to change to keep
up.
I have to stay home and take care of her because she can't walk and can barely move because of her hips. I can't work. I had no health insurance at all. The pharmacist kept telling me "Don't get sick, don't get sick." I was terrified. I had no money, no job and a very sick sister that I had to take care of.
Finally I had to beg to get some Public Assistance not for money because I don't get one cent from them but so that I would have some medical coverage. After probing into my personal life, coming to the house to make sure that my sister was really sick, sending forms from all her doctors saying that she could not be left alone, Public Assistance finally agreed to give me Medicaid, some food stamps, and they pay $192 towards my over $800 rent each month.
There is something very wrong with this country where I worked my whole life, paid taxes and used up my IRA that now I have to beg for health care.
I didn't see "Sicko" but I would like to because Moore hit the nail on the heard. Health care in this country for the insured and non insured alike is disgusting.
My mother was thinking of seeing the movie in San Diego as it had been reviewed as Michael Moore's "funniest yet" (sic)
and can you pay it and not go into bankruptcy?
Michael Moore is not a God, but in the case of SickO he does
highlight some really important ideas. I do not really care for
Michael Moore that much as a moviemaker or as a person.
If I was as successful as he is I would spend whatever I
needed to to lose weight and get into shape to stay alive.
But you attack Moore, and I'm wondering on what basis?
You just do not like his style, or you disagree with his
solution, or you do not believe there is a problem ... ?????
When he visited Cuba, he did not go to the hospital where the 'real Cubans' have to go. He visited a hospital where they take in foreigners.... the Cubans have to make do with subpar clinics and hospitals, lack of sanitation and medicines. We have childhood friends who still live there (I was born there) who ask us for aspirins, tampons, Alka-Seltzer, even vitamins....we send them 'care' packages when we can and hope they are not opened by customs and the contents stolen....
Most people have no idea of the situation there....
Michael Moore is a director who is sloppy with his facts and gears his films to suit his own agenda, but he is far better than the insurance companies who spend millions on soft focus, warm and fuzzy ads about how great they are. Then once they get your premiums, stick it to you. The insurance companies are sticking it to far too many people and they are not being held accountable. Where are the politicians? Oh, I forgot, they are taking campaign contributions from these guys. Gee, do you think there is a conflict of interest?
Meanwhile too many people get distracted from the real issue and tear Michael Moore down. They miss the point. The point is simple. We are the greatest, wealthiest and most powerful country in the world, but kids go hungry, people lack basic health, our college kids are broke by the time they graduate and our troops don't have the right equipment to do what they are asked. Meanwhile, the Halliburtons, the Exxons and all the other big corporations rake in billions of dollars at our expense. Our priorities are way out of whack.
Bruce K. was right. We fear the government, but they should fear us. As I said in my article, it is no longer a question of the haves and the have nots. It is a question of the haves and the been hads.
I loved the part of the film in...was if France?...where the doctors were given bonuses for actually helping people get or stay well. Wellness care. Like we're going to see that here.
I really think that the problem is that in the good ol' US of A, we've become a selfish lot. If we're not directly affected by something, we really don't take an interest in it. Health care is one of those issues. For the persons who have great health care, or adequate care even who have not had to beg for coverage or treatments that are still called experimental in the US but have been used successfully all over the world for years, then it just doesn't hit home.
Then...when something does happen, when a person or family is forced to deal with an insurance company's horrible decisions or when someone looses a job and insurance coverage and discovers that we really don't have a magical "parachute" for folks here just because they have worked and been productive for 20 or 30 years, it comes as a surprise.
I think people think I'm lying when I tell about the county where I lived in Texas. The county medical assistance consisted of seeing tele-doctors for anything not too serious, and driving 45 miles away to another county's medical center for serious maladies.
Think about both of those.
If you had a sore throat, you stood in front of web cam and said, "Ahhh." Not so bad, but a bit strange. If you had a rash on your (adult) butt? You had to moon the camera. Sound like fun?
Then, if you were seriously ill, you had to find money for gas and a car and drive yourself (or get someone to drive you) 45 miles away? Even so, I was turned away because - even though I had the medical card from my county - I didn't appear "poor enough." The receptionist told me to come back clothes that were not ironed. Seriously.
Folks think they'll never be in that position. The downtrodden must have done something to cause or earn the horrible financial and medical situations in which they find themselves.
Nope. Sometimes they just capped the lifetime total available on their "wonderful" group health insurance policies.
Jerzy, gee, I hope you don't have a major medical problem. Being uninsured is risky. I will keep you in my thoughts to stay healthy.
And...haven't we tried that with doctors? It seems to me that one of the news/entertainment shows did an expose about doctors whose college loans were going to be fully or partially forgiven if they worked in certain areas - inner city hosptials and such. Most didn't do that and also didn't pay back their student loans.
My good friend pays $2800 a month for her, her husband and their 6 year old.
HALF of her pay.
welcome to America...
My book 'A Nation of Expendables', due out in 2008 explores this issue. It's true to life fiction describing the unfortunate, mental, emotional and financial devastation many face when becoming ill and permanently disabled.
For more information, please see: www.vanaroth.com