In many cultures, the talk of death in conversation is considered taboo. Of course, people do talk about it in hushed voices, but usually use a metaphor to describe it. I think almost everyone knows what pushing up the daisies, bought the farm, or met the Grim Reaper means. Many people, including me, fear death, but it sure does not stop us from enjoying it through literature and the arts. It seems rather odd that something we fear so much would be a topic for entertainment. Ancient Sagas, stories by Dickens, Emily Dickinson's beautiful poems, the Sherlock Holmes and Agatha Christie mysteries and much of that we watch in TV and movies are just a few examples of our insatiable thirst for. well, you know, buying the farm where someone is pushing up daisies. You often hear people complaining there is too much violence and death in our modern literature and media, but seem not to notice it has been a constant theme from the dawn of history. I mean the story of Cain and Abel is not exactly a tale of brotherly love. This is one of the first stories I learned in Sunday School as a very young child. Most every American child knows the story of Bambi by the first grade, and no, not the story of the pole dancer. I don't recall that being taught in school.
Although few would come out a say it, unless they are insane, we love to be entertained by stories about death. People loved Alfred Hitchcock movies so much that there was a rush to install showers in bathrooms in the early 1960's. Gunsmoke was the longest running TV show in history. Although the same opening scene was repeated 12 straight years, Matt Dillon killing the bad guy to start the show all had us holding our collective breath. What if he missed? He never did and we all felt so happy to see the bad guy dead in the street. Our parents bought us toy guns so we could practice shooting bad guys in the streets. Then there was the TV show 'Combat' starring Vic Morrow and we got to see our soldiers sneaking up on a German to slit his throat with a huge knife. I know I wanted a huge knife as a child, but thankfully there were laws to keep these out of the hands of children. As I grew older, I always wondered what the German people thought of such shows. It was the 60's and there were lots of protest marches, but I never saw any German groups out protesting, but maybe they should have when Hogan's Heroes showed us bombing their trains causing untold death and mayhem. Thankfully, we had Sgt. Schultz and Colonel Klink to show us the softer side of being a Nazi.
I guess the memories of war caused a rash of movies and TV shows showing us brutally killing our past enemies who we now called friends. Well, you can't continually tell another culture that we love to see you dying and in the same breath say, 'Hey, why don't we have a nice Summer barbecue together.' I guess we had enjoyed seeing our new friends die enough and feared they would be put on the endangered species list. The theme of death did not go away. It found a new venue, which was Black Comedy. It seems strange now to see some of the early Monty Python skits making fun of Nazis. Most of these skits were very Black comedy as they often had death in the skit. There were a lot of anti-Nazi and anti- Japanese comedy skits that lasted well into the 70's on shows such as 'Laugh In' and Belushi's Samurai Swordsman character on Saturday Night Live. Many of these skits dealt with death in a softer Black comedy. Most Black comedies focused on Nazis and death was constant theme. This is especially true of Mel Brooks movies and the hilarious classic, 'The XYZ Murders.
Our taste for being entertained by death themes continues and I would estimate that 80% of the most popular TV shows is centered around someone who has bought the farm. Many of the legal and medical shows continuously use death as a central element to the story. In some shows, like CSI, NCIS and Monk, the whole format of the show is based on discovering who the killer is. We are fascinated and glued to our TV sets because we want to know about a death. These shows are very graphic, but none more so than some very famous past movies and literature. In almost every instance of all the above forms of 'death' entertainment I've mentioned, we are an outsider looking in. Often we are a dispassionate outsider looking in. That there is a death is the theme does not touch our feelings or seem in any way connected to our real life. We can be entertained without feeling any sense of loss or sorrow. There are very few TV shows or movies with death as a theme that clutch at our heart and affect our emotions. The TV show Cold Case can affect us and make us us look death squarely in the eye with sorrow. One movie stands out as one of the must gut wrenching looks at death I've ever seen. It is 'What Dreams May Come' starring Robin Williams. If you watch this movie, don't expect comedy. It is not a comedy. It is a serious look at life and the possibilities in an afterlife. If it doesn't make you cry, then you must be pushing up daisies.




Comments: 30
It used to be when someone died, their bodies were washed and dressed by their family, and they were placed in their coffin in the family's main living area-- the parlor, or central room if they didn't have a parlor. People would visit, they'd view the deceased, they'd smell the smell that comes with death and see the way the body almost seems to turn to wax. There was no preserving the corpse, not many options to pretty it up. Sometimes these viewings would go for days.
Now a body is whisked away, cleaned, embalmed, dressed, made up. These things are done by other people. We see the sterile product, the -unoffensive- product. It creates a separation between us and death, and maybe that's a comfort to people, but I think it leads to a lot of fear too. By making it a part of our entertainment, the act of death, the process of it, the more graphic and clever it is... we're desensitizing ourselves to our fears.
I also am the one to call the funeral home to notify them of a patient's death. So many times when I call, I almost say something like , "Mr Jones has passed away and wants to come to your place." What really comes out though, is "Mr Jones has passed away and his family requests your funeral home."
The hard call to make is when the family is not at the bedside at the time of the death. I don't like telling people, "your loved one has taken a turn for the worse," so they rush up there and find out they were already dead. If it were me at home, I would want to be told the truth.
Don't actually think this comment relates to your article, but that's what you get sometimes!!
I was quite young when I went to my first funeral. As I think back on it, that was probably around the same time that I wrote the poem entitled "The Ultimate Goal".
Today most of my longer prose is murder/mystery.
I'm not sure if all of this reflects badly on me but it's just the way it has always been for me so I don't think of it as abnormal.
Today's children don't experience death. Many have never had a live pet. Food is something sanitized that comes from a store. Children don't know what to expect from death. They often expect people the shoot to get up again. Even our wars are sanitized; we don't even see bodies return from wars. In the Vietnam War we saw men fighting on the 6 o'clock news every night.
Stories on death don't necessarily upset me. Movies that are graphic and show lots of blood and guts, actually, just a touch of blood and guts, lose me quickly. I just can't take it. Never could. So I might listen to a Hitchcock movie when I was young, but as I even do now, I listen from another room. And some I still can't even do that with. On the other hand it seems I am surrounded by people who can watch anything.
We also knew the Movie Stars went home to huge Mansions in Hollywood. It didnt make us mentally deranged to watch that.
Now the kids literally take those shows that they see to heart, because they are so close to real life. That is why we have to monitor what they watch.
My mom's uncle served in Vietnam. One night they were sitting around looking at old photos and he had one of dead bodies lined up, side by side on the street, with people going about their business like it wasn't a big deal. I asked about that, and he said when people have to see this every day of their lives, they become numb to it. It no longer affects them.
I just watched Blood Diamond on HBO the other night, about little boys kidnapped and forced to fight and kill. The main character's son was one of the boys. He was so brainwashed and transformed into a killing machine that he would have killed his own father. Something changes in the brain and makes us go into survival mode. Movies like that one are educational, depicting real life. Not just entertainment. The old war movies about WWII and Japan, bring out several aspects of human nature, and the horrors of war. I don't think it's a "bad" thing to see and understand what it was like for them. In some documentaries I've seen recently, the old war vets couldn't even talk about what happened, even into old age.
Man has always been brutal. There was a time when it wasn't just a passive action, like watching a movie. Boys practiced war. Killing was the rite of passage into manhood.
The military wants guys who know how to play video games. We can kill an entire city with a switch of a button, maneuver aircraft and missiles from behind a computer screen and never see the gory bodies. I don't know which is worse.
It would be great if the bad guy was always caught but in reality they are not. Do we really know who lives in our communities? Are we any safer then those that experience war everyday? I think we live in a false state of security.
Blessings
I have to confess, with three sons, I've watched more than my fair share of violence on TV and in movies. Sometimes I think it's a fascination with something we don't understand - or even an acknowledgement that we don't understand what comes next, so we explore the parts we can see. Like a kid treading as close to the edge as he dares. (See, we choose our violent programs carefully - only the tasteful stuff:)
And being English, I've watched more than my fair share of Monty Python and other black humor too.
I enjoyed What Dreams may come (and cried, so not pushing up daisies yet).
I see no sense in all the money being spent on expensive funerals.
When I go, I am going like Elsie - in a plastic bag full of ashes - only I want to be spinkled in a place I've loved.
When my father died 3 years ago, my sister paid over $10,000 for his funeral. I just did the cremation for my estranged husband. $1494. His family planned a private memorial between themselves. Some of his friends requested a few of the ashes to put in memorials they made for him. He is still in his plastic bag in a plastic box in a chair at my kitchen table, awaiting his family to come for him. I still talk to him. Sometimes I almost think he answers.
Ashes to ashes and dust to dust - whether cremation or in the ground - the end result is the same. And you can't take it with you.
Most interesting article William. I loved it.
happen sooner or later and that's it!! I am already set
for I have my arrangements all paid for so my kids will
not have to pay for anything. I too will be in a plastic
bag my ashes to be strewn on the mountain I went to
hike on quite often. I don't watch any of programs on
TV that you mentioned but I do watch Wild Kingdom an
things of that nature. Thank you William.
Unfortunately, my mother's ashes are still in my father's house. He plans to have them put in his coffin at his feet when he's buried. That's just sick.
After my sister (46) died last year, all I thought about was her death. I'm glad that has passed. I like living right here, right now. Again thanks.
I have watched "What Dreams May Come" at several different stages of my life.
I find it interesting in that, how I react to this movie, depends on what I am living through at that point in time. Still, I mostly love the idea of being THAT connected to someone, and I especially love the scenes with Robin's character and his children.
but I want to have my children right there with me when I do. It
would probably be a good thing for all of us I think.
You said it beautifully