In publishing, a false dichotomy has developed between "character-driven novels," often called literary, which means likely to be nominated for prestigious prizes and reviewed in The New York Times; and "plot-driven novels," which may be dismissed as commercial by reviewers. However, they frequently get their revenge as satisfied readers lift them onto the bestsellers' list.
But the truth is that any novel worth the trees that were hewn to print it--whether literary or commercial-- is driven by strong characterization. The most dynamic plot in the world is the frame for an empty house if real "people"--people the reader cares about--don't live inside it.
The real question is but how the author turns words on a page into characters so compelling that readers--maybe even millions of them--will willingly suspend several hours of their own life to lose themselves in their story.
In the stunning epic, A Thousand Splendid Suns, Khaled Hosseini's characters are buffeted by nearly every trial the human spirit can suffer. When we first meet the main character, Maryam, she is living in poverty and shame as a "harami"--a child born out of wedlock. However, the misfortunes Hosseini will heap upon her have only begun. As the novel develops, Maryam endures war, marriage to an older, brutal man, hunger, unimaginable loss and violence. She also experiences deep abiding friendship and genuine love. As we see her respond to the circumstances of her life--in other words, through action, the reader comes to know the truly noble soul that has emerged from Maryam's harsh life.
The characters in Kate Christenson's new novel, The Great Man, hook the reader in a different way--through the power of their voices. Abigail, Teddy and Maxine are three women in their seventies who are connected through their love of Oscar Feldman, the "great man" of the title. Oscar is known for both his paintings of nudes and his seduction of models. When two biographers appear wanting to write Oscar's story, his wife, his long time mistress, and the sister who was both an artistic rival and his staunchest defender are forced to consider the ways in which he consumed their lives, and who they are without him.
Though the most dramatic action in these characters lives is largely (but not totally) in the past, their voices kept me as engrossed as any action-packed page turner. Through dialogue--both inner and outer, the reader comes to know Oscar's wife Abigail as compassionate and forgiving--and deeply pragmatic. Teddy, the mistress who bore Oscar two children has retained the flair, independence and sensuality of her bohemian lifestyle well into her seventies.
But it's the whiskey guzzling Maxine, blunt and cranky and wryly observant who I loved most. Her eviscerating descriptions of the pretentious Manhattan art scene and her own aging face in the mirror are worth the price of the novel. Maxine calls things as she sees them--whether she's pondering her own mortality, the indignity of still harboring secret "crushes" at her advanced age, or the strange ingredients in the kibbles she feeds her dog. Spending time in her company was both edifying and delightful.
Of course, every good novel uses both action and dialogue to illuminate character--and these two are no exception. The only difference is what the author emplys as a primary tool.
Whether you write, or you're just an avid reader, there's an element of mystery and magic in our relationship to the imaginary people who live between the covers of book. If they are well-drawn enough, we cry over their fates as I wept for Maryam at the end of A Thousand Splendid Suns or we miss the loss of their company when we read the final chapters as I did when I closed The Great Man.
Who is a fictional character you particularly affected or inspired you; and how did the author convince you they were real?
Patry Francis, Books Correspondent:
Patry's column, Reading as a Writer, published bi-weekly to Gather Essentials: Books, alternating with Diary of a First Novelist.
To learn more about Patry and her debut novel, The Liar's Diary, visit her Website,
You can find all of Patry's articles, Diary of a First Novelist, and Reading as a Writer at www.gather.com/patryfrancis
Keep up with Patry’s other postings and Gather activity by joining her Gather network -- just click here and select the orange “Connect” button on the left-hand side of the page
You’ll find Patry and other Book Correspondents, plus celebrity author content and plenty of other bibliophiles at Books.gather.com


Comments: 68
There was no set thing that convinced me.
Glad to see you mentioned this author.
An excellent review, Patry.
Of late, I have been doing much thinking about memorable characters.
Support Group: To Be or Not to Be, Do I Have a Choice?
I love scarlet o Hara ..and totally agree that strong characters carry a good story
The most recent examples for me are actually posts of a fellow Gatherer: Greg Schiller
(gregs.gather.com) wrote a couple of short stories - Role Model and You're Hot - that were purely conversations that captured the characters perfectly.
And Chris Carlisle's (chriscarlisle.gather.com) description of the devil in his Breakfast With The Devil was pretty damn good as well.
Lear and Iago, Hamlet and his wife, among many, many others. His plotting likewise is masterful.
and such. Tolkien is a master at his craft.
I will have to give a try to the other book you mention.
Ron: It's been many years since I read The Grapes of WRath, but you're so right. Tom Joad's quiet dignity and simmering anger remain with me.
Kathryn: It seems to be something we writers are always contemplating, doesn't it? Thanks for featuring me!
Beverly: Thank you for such a lovely comment. I mean to check out your support group.
Debbie: Thank you!
Matthew: You make a good point. What we are really looking for is a character who completely engages us, one who fascinates--even if the fascination is a dark one.
cw: Thank you--
Amarpreet: Great example. Gone With the Wind has a terrific plot, but probably would have been long forgotten without Scarlett.
more later...
Elizabeth and Mr. Darcy. Austen shows us their flaws and their heart. But both's pride gets in the way.
Philip in THE ODD SEA. Reinkin has him feeling guilty about Ethan's disappearence and
keeps seaching through the days, months and years for his brother or the Odd Sea.
My current favorite character is Detective Sonchai Jitplecheep in three of John Burdett's novels set in Bangkok. He is everything I am not yet I identify with him!
Enjoyed your website also, and look forward to reading your book.
Paul G.: Shakespeare is an excellent example. Nothing endures and becomes a classic unless it offers both an engaging story, and a cast of rounded characters.
tamara: Thank you! It's great to break away from my novel in progress, and interact with the community.
Laurun: "Idiosyncrasies" go a long way to define character, and Tolkein was definitely a master at creating unique ones. He also knew how to plot a riveting tale.
flit: You will enjoy both these novels!
John: I love your analogy about the holiday meal. So true!
Lydia: I've never read Dick Francis, but after reading your description, I will. I love the idea of "mad Alexander who messes around with paints." Kind of reminds me of mad Patry who messes around with words...
G.M. Lupo: This afternoon my daughter (a college student) casually picked up the novel and took it in her room. We haven't seen her since...
Ann B. Grote: I read The Magic Mountain when I was about eighteen. I enjoyed it then, but I think it's one of those novels that is enhanced by life experience. Maybe it's time to read it again?
Zoe, Betty: Thank you both--
Chris W: So you're a librarian! Now I know why you're on top of all the best new books. As far as Hosseini goes, I think you nailed it. His "deep and compassionate heart" has enthralled a world of readers.
Pamela: Me, too!
Judi: Hope you enjoy them--
Anne M: Elizabeth and Mr. Darcy are two who immediately came to my mind, too. Both are indelible. I was also haunted by The Odd Sea, which I read several years ago.
Natalie: Your wonderful comment left me smiling all day. If there is such a thing as an ideal reader, one who truly "gets" what I hoped to accomplish, you are mine! Thank you!
Emma: As a writer, I think I would prefer that to a lukewarm response.
Corina: What a wonderful description of Scout and her enduring power over readers. In fact, all of the characters in Mockingbird are quite marvelous, don't you think?
Casey: "He is everything I am not yet I identify with him!" Now THAT'S the power of fiction!
Patricia: After we both finish The Kite Runner, we'll have to "talk."
Elizabeth: It will come to you...In fact, I suspect that as you think of it, ALL the characters you've loved will come. Hope you return when they do!
Jan M: Thanks so much for checking out the Website! I've read a few of Jodi Picoult's novels--but not My Sister's Keeper, which several people say is her best.
Michelle K: I agree. There are so many powerful relationships and emotions woven throughout the novel, but the bond between Maryam and Laila was its heart.
Angella: Thank you. Haven't the comments been great? The only problem is that I've now found several more novels I absolutely must read!
Rona: The Secret Life of Bees is in my pile now--right after I finish Water for Elephants.
Super post. Thanks!
Good job
whenever I used to see your icon,you impressed me always and when I saw you on my page believe me It was like an honor ..comments from such great writers ..I loved it all..
Thanks and thank you for all your sprinkled love on my article...
Lea: Glad you enjoyed it.
Bhawana: Thank you for your lovely comments; they make ME feel honored. I've enjoyed reading your articles.
Antoine: Interesting choice. I think I've read all of the Rabbit novels, but Janice stuck with me longer than Rabbit...must be the female perspective. In any case, Updike is a master wordsmith.
Louis: True, though some actions can be more revealing of character than others.
Lisa: Does that mean you're writing a novel? I hope so!
There are so many, my brain is swirling with them suddenly.
Once I was told by a playwriting instructor that a good character is one who you would want to talk with at a party and would come home talking about.
But I can't answer your question. So many characters in so many books that I have walked alongside. I fill my shelves with their memories so I can revisit them when the mood takes me.
Thanks for these reviews - you've made me want to check out these books.
Good article.
The Great Man sounds very good, too.
I've already added A Thousand Splendid Suns to my list, now I am going to add The Great Man. I enjoyed reading your reviews of them. Thank you!
Z'
I also love the writing of Ann Patchett (thanks for stopping by my review of her latest book, "Run") which has some great, very lovable characters in it. I also love her characters in "The Patron Saint of Liars," the story of a married woman who runs half way across the country to join a home for unwed mothers (the home has no idea she is married).
The other memorable characters I love are those in "Accidental Tourist." They are wonderfully eccentric yet delightfully human and very good at hiding their pain.
Finally, I have to mention Amy Tan's writing. She is an amazing creator of interesting characters, even as she focuses on Chinese-American mothers and daughters in so many of her stories. She seems to grasp the distance between parent and child better than anyone I can think of.
Ten unsolicited points from the world's worst connection. Merry whatever you celebrate!