Back in 1938, the German people were sick and tired of being sick and tired. They had had their traditional monarchical government forcibly removed and replaced with what appeared to them to be an impractical, innefficient, and cumbersome joke: the Weimar Republic. They had endured the Great Depression and economically stifling war reparations payments. They had also listened for years to the rhetoric of politicians who pledged to end the republic and bring back the glory days of Germany.
Soon, an Austrian with some rather extreme ideas would take hold of the German chancellorship and turn the built-up rage of the German people to accomplish the unimaginable. The truth is that it could have been anyone with a gift for public speaking. The rage of the Germans could have been turned to almost anything, but it wasn't. The situation and the time combined to make it possible to vicitmize an entire people, while the world looked on.
The United States has endured a great deal over the last 40 years. We were tired of Viet Nam and of being held up at the gas pump, having our consulate occupied in Iran, and generally not having the respect of the rest of the world back in 1984 when we elected Ronald Reagan president. We had become sick and tired of being sick and tired.
Reagan, who also had a gift for public speaking, had some rather extreme ideas about how to run the government, which included running it out of town, shutting it down, and basically abolishing the parts of it that were not of personal benefit to himself and his friends, the idle rich class. Reagan went to work on undoing every bit of domestic policy of the previous 25 years that benefitted ordinary people. His tactics were more or less transparent: appointing people whose interests were inimical to the departments they were to lead, cutting funding for schools and nutrition programs and the infamous "trickle-down" economic theory, which posited that cutting taxes for the rich would benefit the poor by stimulating business and creating jobs.
Reagan had a cadre of followers who believed fervently that he had the right idea, much in the same way that Adolf Hitler's followers did, but after Reagan was no longer in public life, his followers continued to put his ideas into practice. Former House Speaker Tom DeLay has said publicly many times that it was his plan to abolish government. It sounds extreme, but taken together,the actions of the conservatives in power are clearly aimed at exactly that.
Hitler needed help to get ans stay in power, so his cronies organized a crew of ruffians, the S.A., or brownshirts, whose mission it was to disrupt the other parties' meetings. The brownshirts were murderous and ruthless. Hitler was often heard to say that "terror is salutary." Arguably, our government agrees with him.
Once Hitler came to power, he set about doing everything he had always said he would do, and to do so within the law. The promises he made included abolishing the republic and returning Germany to its former glory. They also included ridding Germany of its scapegoat group, the Jews.
So far, the United States has followed the pattern of pre-World-War II Germany with minor variations. We have found our situation intolerable and followed leaders who promised to abolish the alleged sources of our discomfort and return us to glory. We have experienced the "threat of terrorism" and have been induced to support an open-ended war against an ambiguous enemy, which is beginning to look like an expeditionary conquest.
Like the Germans, we have been given "reasonable" grounds for our foreign policy and bombarded with propaganda (now called spin) that aims to garner support for government policy. Like the Germans, our civil liberties have been curtailed. Now, also like the Germans, we have been given a scapegoat group, the illegal immigrants, on whom to focus our collective rage.
The question remains of whether or not we are willing to continue to follow the path the Germans took in the first half of the Twentieth Century to full-blown genocide. We lack only the right leader.
About Gather |
Engagement Marketing |
Make New Friends |
Gather Points |
Advertise on Gather |
Gather Press |
Privacy |
Terms of Service |
Community Guidelines
Books | Celebs | Entertainment | Family | Food | Health | Moms | Money | News | Politics | Spirituality | Sports | Travel | Writing
Books | Celebs | Entertainment | Family | Food | Health | Moms | Money | News | Politics | Spirituality | Sports | Travel | Writing
Version 16961, "Pacino"; Copyright © 2009 Gather Inc. All rights reserved.


Comments: 27
There's no parallel, eerie or otherwise, to early 20th century Germany and the 21st century U.S.
Americans are unique in that we are millions of people from thousands of places. We all bring culture, heritage, and customs to the melting pot.
We share one common thread. An abiding and deep love of freedom on a personal level. Our very Constitution guarantees us that freedom, and there's no leader that could ever take it away all by his (or her) lonesome.
Just look at what happened during the recent illegal immigration bill debate. WE the people - and yes, that includes you - beat that puppy into submission. Why? Because it was wrong, wrong, wrong.
Do you honestly believe that a charismatic leader could just take us all down a genocidal garden path, and we'd follow along like lost sheep????
Get over your fear-mongering. It's pathetic.
C.A., I respect your opinion, but I do not appreciate your attacks. Are you unable to disagree civilly?
Beverly, Please give specifics regarding your questions on accuracy. I am fairly certain I can document everything in this article, and I will retract or correct any inaccuracies.
Pax vobiscum.
Hitler started by taking down the "liberals" the "trade unions," the "communists," and the incapacitated. He did not start with the Jews, or the Gypsies, or even forced labor camps.
He did not do it alone, and he did not do it with only government. He had a "Ministry of Propaganda." He also had the sideline support of newspapers and radio and motion picture producers. He had the support of a large portion of the German population, and his opposition was shouted down. Sometimes lynched, and eventually confined in concentration camps.
Hitler KILLED over 12 million people, above and beyond the multiple millions who died in World War Two. Half, perhaps more than half of his victims were non Jews. They were liberals and trade unionists, and handicapped, and Gypsies, and Russians and Poles, and Hungarians, and anyone else deemed "unfit."
BWAHAHAHAHAHAHA!!!!!
There are many parallels between the propaganda we are receiving today and any facist government. Media corporations, which only number a small handful, are in bed with our politicians of both parties. Sensationalism is the journalism today. Real stories are buried or reported very briefly. Control the spin and you control the nation.
American patriotism is taking on a scary feel. If you're not for the current President, then you must be a terrorist or at least a threat. Unlike Germany of the 1930s, we don't have a strong ethnicity bond, but we do have a strong cultural bond, and it still is more likely to be white and of Western European descent. I've had people tell me that because Shrub hasn't cheated on his wife he's a better President than Clinton. That's their reason, and I do NOT want to debate who was better, just observing that to use this reasoning is not responsible citizenship. Who asked the question, "Are you better off today than you were before they took office?" That is how we should rate our Presidents and other elected officials.
Also C.A....the Constitution is being whittled away as we speak. I hope we don't wake up too late. I have never, in all my 43 years, seen Americans so scared of what is happening. I arrived at the end of the Vietnam War scandal, but my memory does not find the disregard for American citizens which we see today. It's all about big business and big powerful military machines. Oh, and our oil buddies.
This one was warranted, Ann...you started it. You attacked my country. You imply I'm too weak and stupid to stop a Hitler. Yes you did. Think about it.
You're also wrong, as are all the rest who follow along with their "Yep, it's true" posts.
And, may I point out I didn't call anyone a name.
That said, I'm done. Post away your attacks. I won't respond.
Besides, Ann will get the points and that's a good thing. :-)
I never said anyone was too weak or stupid to stop a Hitler. Please use some of your righteous indignation to contact your representatives in Washington.
Pax.
You poor dear, CA. You just said something that is completely the opposite of what is actually happening. The trouble is, you represent at least half of the American population. I think you had better stay away from corporate owned news.
They believed that everyone had rights, and despite the seemingly "patriotism" of our current leader, we are losing ours with every Presidential Directive he decrees from his throne.
Germany after WWI was saddled with crushing war reparations. Inflation was so rapid that the value of the mark dropped significantly every day. The German economy was in the toilet. Germany was ripe for any kind of snake oil salesman who could provide a scapegoat and false promises of recovery.
We're not at that stage here, *pregnant pause, yet.
The voices that try to stop dissent are those that scream "RACIST" at me when I demonstrate for a halt to illegal immigration. The parallel with Hitler is when the President of AMexico declares that Mexico is wherever there are Mexicans. THere are many who claim the Southwest is Mexican, Aztlan, and they want it back. Sound like Hitler and the Sudetenland just before Hitler marched into Czechoslovakia? Nah, today is nothing like Weimar Republic Germany. Too many guys like me to stop a tyranny.