Beryl Singleton Bissel's book "The Scent of God: a Memoir" is the story of a cloistered nun, a wife, a widow, a single mom, a divorcee and a happily married woman. The lyrical prose and the simple and the easy flowing style of the book effectively disguises the enormous amount of time, the effort and the emotional energy involved in the making of this memoir. Beryl was distressed and thus spurred to write the memoir on overhearing her school-going son's seething remark to a friend that, as an offspring of an ex-priest and an ex-nun, his life was going to be doomed. In order to tell in all sincerity the inevitable sequence of events that determined the course of her life, she took a class in memoir writing. According to Beryl she spent ten years learning how to write and another ten years writing the book, all the while honing her skills as a feature writer and a newspaper columnist. Once the first draft of the memoir was ready and submitted to the agent, it was immediately evident to the agent and the publisher that Beryl had a unique story of great human interest to tell. From that point on it was an endless job of editing and re-editing the draft, constantly pushed, perhaps a little vicariously, by her agent and publisher to bring out the whole story in all its intimate details. Finally, after eight thoroughly revised drafts, and when Beryl was 66 years old, the book was published by a well-known literary publisher, Counterpoint NY. The entire exercise proves Beryl's grit, single-minded dedication and a stubbornness of purpose, which has also been her characteristic throughout her life. It is no wonder that, after such a painstaking refinement of her work, the Minneapolis Star Tribune named Beryl as the "Best of 2006 Minnesota Authors."
Beryl's conscientiousness in telling the whole truth is reflected in the fact that she revisited the old places several times, interviewed the living people involved, and took every care not to fall into a memoir writer's usual trap of unintentionally fictionalizing the events recalled from memory. She mentions that telling the story 30 years later, incorporating all the development of mind and heart that has taken place during those 30 years, will be the very thing that "creates" the memoir-- the fuller story. In respect of its candor, cadence and penetrating self-analysis Beryl's memoir is comparable with none other than "My Experiments with Truth", an autobiography of Mahatma Gandhi.
Beryl's memoir has the quality of a thorough brief, unsparing in the minutest of details having any bearing on the overall case. The author's powerful video-graphic memory dating back to her earliest childhood aids her in telling her story with unfaltering credibility and realism. Yet the tone is very personal and confessional, confiding the heart's utmost confidences to a trusted friend and a patient and understanding listener in order to purge the heart of whatever residual feelings of guilt or regret.
Contrary to the expectations of this work to be a theological or philosophical treatise, it actually reads like a passionate romantic novel. It is the story of star-struck love which happens accidentally like a lightening strike between two Godly persons separated by a generational gap and both committed to the holy vows of lifelong celibacy. The element of forbidden love makes it loaded with scandalous material of gossipy value with the likelihood of inviting societal recriminations and stigma.
The tumultuous love affair continues, albeit discreetly, amidst picturesque landscapes and adventurous driveways of Puerto Rico and Italy. It gushes forth like a barrage burst with a curious mix of abstinence and abandon, intensity and inexperience. It is a profound discovery of wild ecstasies of physical intimacy between two loving persons.
The characteristic dignity and an immaculate sense of form that is resplendent in this love affair, although besotted with human vulnerability and tragic flaws from the very beginning, makes it the most fascinating and lovable. There is desperation to give it matrimonial sanctity in spite of great uncertainties in obtaining proper dispensation from conflicting sacramental vows, a creeping cancerous ailment and penurious circumstances with no means in sight to support the aspirations of a stable and secure family.
Finally, the God who reveals Himself to Beryl at her darkest hour is a boisterous ‘laughing God' - a past-master in pulling a series of synchronistic strings in extricating the enmeshed lives of His guileless faithful. And, one of his laughing minions is the good Bishop Ahr of Trent, who was once a spiritual director of Beryl, a privy to her confidences and who stood by her through most of her travails.
The death-defying love eventually does find its blessed consummation in matrimony, overcoming all obstacles in its path. For the two, who once dedicated their entire lives to serve God, it is another kind of transcendental experience filled with joys and sorrows, and pleasures and pains; the struggles, the frustrations and the triumphs of partaking in the divine miracle of bringing fresh and new life into this world.
Towards the end, the tone of the memoir becomes increasingly pensive and sad as it details the grim visitation of masked death into the unsuspectingly playful parlor of intimately interwoven life.
In spite of the hurts and misunderstandings received in life the author remains placidly unembittered. The following questions to the author are to gauge the other side the impact of the author's work and not to stir those hurt feelings.
Question: Did any aspect of your life blow up into scandalous proportions big enough to cause you mental turmoil any time?
Answer: I have endured much mental torment in my life but most of it has come from my own moral and spiritual dilemmas and not because of public repercussions. Vittorio was the one who suffered from slanderous accusations and condemnation. These caused him incredible anguish and I believe these accusations and slanders were what triggered the cancer that would eventually take his life.
I have found it difficult to forgive the Catholic hierarchy for the suffering it caused Vittorio, who was one of it's most dedicated and loving sons. I see this Church (whom I love nonetheless and despite its all too human flaws) continuing to silence and condemn those who seek to serve according to their consciences rather than dogma. Jesus' message was one of compassion and openness and he was put to death as a heretic so I should not be surprised that this should also be the fate of those who preach a similar message of love and acceptance. Nonetheless this condemnation troubles me
greatly.
Question: Did you experience any adverse reaction, especially of intolerant and hateful kind, from any segment of the society after the publication of the memoir?
Answer: I expected much more adverse reactions than I actually received which totaled two letters telling me that I was flagrantly promoting my fall from grace and leading others astray and two negative reader reviews on Amazon -- one proclaiming the book scandalous and another saying that I was just another dysfunctional author.
I knew that once the book left my hands and made its way into the world, that it was no longer mine to protect -- that readers would interpret it according to their own insights. A wonderful writing friend wrote me that I should not take these attacks personally. I am going to quote her directly as most of us writers and many of us Gatherers have at one time suffered such attacks and her words are strengthening.
"One thing I want to stress as you get feedback from people on your book. This is an important lesson that I did not learn until much too late. The feedback is not about you; it is about them. It tells you much about the person who gives it, but nothing at all about you. It is not about you . . . if they read something else into the writing, it is not because you put it there. It is what they have put there for unconscious reasons they do not know. It is easier to face the anger and the criticism when you understand that, and actually, to stay grounded and not get big headed when you understand that. To think it is about you or that you caused it, gives you a far greater role in people's lives than you have. I don't believe God likes that competition."
Web site : http://www.berylsingletonbissell.com/
Gather blog: http://www.beryl.gather.com/
Journey blog: http://www.berylsingletonbissell.livedigital.com/
Purchase books: http://www.perseusbookspromos.com/buy.php?ISBN=1582433488


Comments: 104
excellent review, Dolphi!
Great job, and I'm looking forward to reading the story.
Ouystanding re-view of a book.
wonderful. amazing job you have done.
God Bless
Thanks for sharing this with us.
dee-dee
I was quite taken by the words of advice given to Beryl at the end of your review, the fact that reviews should not be taken personally. I have always felt that way about ratings as well in that drive-by ones reflect on the rater, not on me.
Thank you for posting such a moving testimonial to this intriguing work! It was absolutely marvelous.
Thanks again to Kathryn for drawing my attention to an article I might otherwise have missed.
Thank you one and all for connecting here and for ordering or considering ordering Scent. It is one of the messier details of an author's life that they must hope for book sales. My hubby throws up his hands when well-situated contacts (with money) tell him they are waiting for their turn at the book which has been circulating among friends. "Why do they wait?" he asks. "They could buy it."
this marvelous story and I think I shall have
to come back and reread this. I am right in
the middle of something. Thank you.
Beautifully written, Dolphi! Bravo!
Robert H.
I believe I have to leave the current scandalous state of the Catholic hierarchy at the door so to speak; as it does reflect an ominous grey cloud over their human flaws that was not seen in years pass.
Blessings
So well written. Congratulations.
Also, I have heard of the book but not read it - another oversight. This sounds like the sort of story that, not only begs to be read, but *needs* to be read. The conflict between a persons faith and their heart is one that hat occurred in my family and, I suspect, many others throughout time.
Thank you for the excellent review, Dolphi.
thank you for letting me know
That is the way it has been with me:The Scent of God has become a part of my life.
Love is an amazing and powerful thing.
This is one that tears at the heart and senses. Being pulled in several directions, questions still invade my psyche concerning taking the holy vows of lifelong celibacy, yet surrendering to the overwhelming desire for forbidden love.
Can our Catholic church survive if our Priests and Nuns can say, "I was just kidding when I took my vows?" Can it survive if those Priests and Nuns decide to serve according to their own individual conscience, as opposed to the original structure?
Should it survive under it's current structure with Pope John II remaining firm on celibacy?
I struggle for answers to these and more, and Beryl brings them all to the forefront with her touching story.
Books like these when written honestly serve to understand people and complex situations and evaluate human values.
In response to the "why do people wait to read a shared book, when they are very capable to purchase them....." I know it to be very expensive to purchase every book I read. I have myself on a monthly book budget, because I was spending more on books than food. I have to purchase most of my books, because I don`t know anyone with my particular flair in reading and I gave up shop lifting years ago.I also run into a problem when I`m finished reading I want to save the good ones to read them again and I end up with thousands of books and no place to put them. We use to have a book exchange and I could trade the books I wasn`t so fond of, now I donate them. I am retired therefor on a fixed income, I have other hobbies than reading, and in order for me to do them, I have to stick faithfully to my budget .
Dolphi - beautiful beautiful interview and goes to the heart of the Book and Beryl. I loved this book very much and read it as I sat on the front porch facing the cemetery and thinking of mama - a woman who spent everyday in the big Cathedrals - and who was by far one of the most beautiful and simply elegant women I'd ever met - why does one realize so much after a mother has passed. Her quiet dignity charmed me - and yet when she married a divorced man - she was basically - and I don't have the details - but in the day - she was ex-communicated...yes, the Church can be viscious...however God was always in her heart and surrounded her with the pure joy of knowing that as a woman thinketh she is...
I just threw that in - and I'm sure you'll understand why....
Regarding what Doria said - I ordered the book from my library and it came in about a week from Baton Rouge so you may want to go to the library. Also, I think the book would make a fine memorial gift and I may do that and purchase it for my own town library when it's befitting for the passing of a friend. I'm a writer myself and am so lucky that the library generously buys copies of my books for each of its six branches. Again, Dolphi - thank you for this excellent review of Beryl's fabulous book - it enriched my life in so very many ways. My thoughts toward Beryl are like tiny white flowers filled with the morning dew...and I cherish that I have gotten to know her a bit through the various reviews, interviews and of course by my reading of her book, The Scent of God. Bayou Blessings to all. Salud.
This book is and will be shared but I'm keeping tabs on who has it as I want it back....besides, it has Beryl's name plate on it with her signature and dedicated to me......I would not want to lose this book and it is one I plan to re-read.
I am sorry Beryl that you got the negative letters you did. It is your story, you lived it and you told it well!
As someone who had to deal with the requirements of celibacy during a period of Priestly training I will devour this for certain.
Thank you.
Getting to know and respect Beryl through Gather has been very rewarding. She is a wonderful person and a talented writer. I, too, think "The Scent of God" would make a fascinating movie. The old saying, truth is stranger than fiction, shows it is true from the first sentence of the book to its finale. It took great courage to write a story that needed to be told.
Thank you Beryl, and Dolphi, I am proud to call you both "friend".
what I already liked about Beryl is the fact that she spend 10 years learning to write memoir and 10 years in writing the book ...20 years of your time on something that is special and true from the heart ...I admire her by the way she has faced the world and come out as a winner ....thanks for introducing me to such a great person ..
I love books that touch the soul and this one sounds just right for me!
Thanks so much for sharing your thoughtful re-view...it is EXCELLENT!!
Carla, you are ON -- August 3rd for your event.
Dave, I love that word "smashing!"
James, if you are right then cha-ching ... I've written book reviews on Amazon for books I haven't bought on Amazon but purchased through my lovely local independent bookseller. Your idea is a good one though ... it would keep people from reading the title and description and drawing their own conclusions without reading the book ... the one minute sound bite commentator.
I can easily see that all those who read and responded to this article are discriminating and perceptive readers. Some have frankly admitted that book reviews are not normally of their type. I agree that book reviews are pale shadows of the complexity and beauty of original works. However, great works react deeply and organically in different ways with different readers. Sharing those reactions with other interested readers do have a place in the sceme of things.
Like everyone else I feel overawed by published authors. So, when an award-winning writer like Beryl approached me, without my proven writing ability or credentials, out of thousands of Gatherers to write a review for her book, I felt intrigued as well as honored. I readily accepted the challenge.
Now that some more authors have suggested that I do reviews for their books I feel like grabbing those offers. How nice it would be, if I could eventually settle down in the comfort of my home and do book reviews for a living, instead of taking up a lousy job in a foreign country!
Thanks to everyone for your genuine support!
I really enjoyed this review. I attempted to read it once before but got distracted - happens a lot lately. The 20 year time span is very interesting and you pose very interesting questions regarding the memoir itself - does one feel more enlightened with age? To me this book exemplifies God's timing. Regarding critisism, I think it shows the book has made a mark. I have to find time to read this book - you have stirred my interest - thank you.
Beryl you may correct me if I am wrong but I do believe you have a higher advisor then the institution of the Catholic chruch and I truely believe what your late husband states when he said the chruch IS the people. You are so right when you tell us Jesus weaved the chruch; it is the people that he weaved not organized chruch.
Blessings
Blessings