When I entered high school, there was a war going on. Every night the local paper printed the addresses of soldiers who wanted to get mail. I wrote to every name on the list, and used my babysitting money to send them small gifts.
In most cases, I only sent one letter or package, but one Marine and I became close friends. We wrote sporadically, then weekly, and finally almost daily. I sent him a photograph, which he taped inside his helmet. He told people I was his girlfriend, though we both knew I would never be that. He was twenty-one and serving a second tour; I was fifteen and had never been away from my home or parents for more than a week.
He told me things that people who knew and loved him could not bear to hear. I related the small stories that arose in the life of a bookish high schooler, and he seemed to draw comfort from their dailiness. We shared jokes, and filled sheets of pale blue airmail stationery with the lyrics of songs that we loved. I can still remember sitting at the kitchen table as I transcribed the words to "Blowin in the Wind." When he wrote back to say that the song had come on the radio as he read my letter, I learned the meaning of serendipity.
He believed the war was for a "just cause." I was already participating in local protests, but our differing viewpoints never affected our friendship.
My father was drinking coffee in the kitchen and I was in my bedroom getting ready for school when my grandfather came in with the paper. The screen door slammed behind him.
"Patry's friend is on the front page--" he announced. "Killed in action."
Even now, I can hear the sound of the door that door slamming, a kind of punctuation mark to my grandfather's statement. I can feel the claustrophobia of my tiny bedroom with the roses on the wallpaper, and see my open bureau before me, my shirts piled in neat stacks. The one on top was as pink as those wallpaper roses.
The mail from that distant country was sometimes slow and unreliable. My friend had been dead for six months when the last letter arrived. I kept it for many years, but eventually, during one of life's transitions, it was lost.
No matter. I not only remember every word, I remember how they looked on the page. Small, and slanted downward, all huddled at the top, the rest of the paper filled with emptiness. An odd phrase, I suppose, but the only way I can describe it.
The letter was totally unlike any I had received from him before. There was no date or salutation, no stories or song lyrics, no noting the number of days till he'd be home. Just a question:
Did you ever think that maybe you were just a figment of your own imagination?
It was so many years ago now. My grandfather is dead-- my father, who jumped up from the kitchen table when he heard the news--dead, too. And the room with the pink flowered wallpaper where I spent my childhood is a kingdom I can never re-enter, except through memory.
Only the question--cryptic, strangely prescient, and still utterly mysterious-- remains.
Note: I don't usually cross post, but for Memorial day, I made an exception. This also appears on my blog.


Comments: 73
Surreal.
Very poignant story, thank you, Patry.
I am wondering how hard it hit you to get that letter as you were still grieving the recent loss?
Tracey: All too relevent. Thank you.
Tomi: Yes it can. Thanks for your comment.
Debbie G.: I guess that's what Memorial Day is all about--taking a moment to hear that silence. Thank you.
Anne: Thank you. I felt that way while writing it too. It was cathartic to share the experience, and especially to read the comments.
Flit, Loretta: Thank you
Mary Beth: Some time I would like to hear more about those experiences...
Deb J: It's always felt unearthly to me.
Melanie: Thank you.
Enoch: It has never stopped feeling that way to me.
Lisa: Somehow I always found the question oddly comforting.
Heather: Yes, but as I wrote this today, I had the distinct feeling that he was still with me; that in some way, the people we care about always are.
Alison: Interesting thoughts. He seemed like a very resilient person to me, but in those circumstances, probably anyone would question how long they might live.
Shawnee: The loss was very hard for me because I was used to "talking" to him every day in letters; and I found myself hoarding up things to share, only to realize there was no longer anyone there to receive my stories. But for me, there was something quite hopeful about receiving the letter--one final communication after months of silence. It almost felt as if he was telling me he was all right--if that makes any sense.
Beryl: I've never thought about my grandfather's role in the story; he must have been so stunned by the news that he just blurted it out--or maybe he wasn't aware that I could hear him?
I've often wondered if the letter was written on the day the soldier died, and what his state of mind might have been. Your question about a presentiment has haunted me. He had seen and experienced so much; and yet the message in the letter feels positive and transcendent to me.
Amy: Sometimes the only response we have is to never forget.
More later...
(They often knew when they received orders that they were going into a bad situation.)
Tiny nitpicking remark: "never affected our friendship".
Cheers
Hajo
Wonderfully written, P.
Karolyn, Kris: Thank you.
Anne: Never.
Michele: Thank you.
Ron: You make a powerful statement.
Laurie: It is something that's never left me, but my life trajectory was unchanged. As you say, for the parents, wives, husbands, and children, it is not so easy.
Janet: So true! It is a practice I took up again during the Gulf War, and again now.
Jean: "...become part of who we are." Perhaps that is a partial answer to his question.
Debra: Thank you. I'm grateful to be able to keep him alive in this small way; and someday, SOME DAY I'm going to get to that wall.
Dawn: Your last sentence struck me like a revelation. I've always believed--or at least, most often believed--that the letter was not a premonition, just a coincidence, a kind of post script to some of our philosophical discussions. But your rationale is far more likely. He was an officer; he would have known. Now that I think about it, the letter, unsigned and hastily written, was probably written in the midst of the mission that claimed his life.
That might explain its long delayed arrival...
Hajo: Thank you! I always screw that up...Someone who reviewed my novel even mentioned it. You would think that would have cured me!
Perle: Thank you--
I don't think there is anything wrong with cross posting to your blog.
Kathryn: As Jean and others have said, it's an experience that never leaves you. p.s. Thanks for the info about x-posting; I wasn't sure...
Very romantic and surreal... but I believe the whole tale and it is heartfelt...
it caught me awestruck... irreplaceable in times.
Now I got the moral of the story...being a man--that man should not say that he owns in love a woman when it is false...
I should try to remember this knowledge of life in all the days of my life...
And the falling sands of fate as I see the hours through the looking glass...
nice story and anamnesis...
I could not say a word... it defies destiny and time of childish compassion through the growing years of somehow of pain and wondering, about the beyond--a search and a childish love, in a time of war and during your tender and adolescent years...
To me it is the Constituent of Dreams...
hmmm...
Thank you for sharing this!
Jared: "Peace" is the perfect response. Thank you.
Machiavelli: I probably wouldn't share his name here. His family may not have known about the letter I received so many months later. I wouldn't want them to find it this way.
Aaron: Thank you for seeing it that way. Your vision is always so compassionate. His words have certainly resonated with me throughout a lifetime--not just the final letter, but many other things he wrote as well.
I write to or e-mail as many soldiers as I can bear to -- it's hellish, waiting to hear back. I send them books & movies. I make friends with these strange men & women who are so happy to hear from people from home.
Officers definitely know when they're going out on a mission what the risk is. Maybe it was that, or maybe he was hot, tired, dehydrated. Maybe he'd just had a dream.
Thanks for posting this very sad story.
Yes - I often think I'm a figment of my own imagination!
I wonder where your correspondent is now - maybe six places at once - some in body, some simply energy forms - Still exploring consciousness.
What an amazing gift he gave your young mind.
Fortunately, your imagination is large enough to fill the void with vivid memories. Thanks for this.
arlene: It's a unique connection, isn't it? But I know how you feel when you say you "write to as many as you can bear to..." I've been writing to a former co-worker, and when I don't hear back as quickly as I should, the worry can overwhelm me at times.
Jen du Bay: Thank you! Have I told you yet how great it is to see you here on Gather?
I hope you love it as much as I do, but that you don't let it suck up all your writing time (a real danger for me.)
carolion: Thank you for sharing your wonderful vision of where he might be now. It's as brightly colored as your icon!
Tim: Thank you.
Douglas: Thank you for a comment that is also a poem!
Kate: I haven't read David Ball's story, but I will surely look for it. Thank you.
Connie: I appreciate it.
Beverly: You're right. It was something that made me aware of the preciousness and precariousness of life at a young age.
Frank: It's something that has remained with me all my life. Thank you!
ravi: Thank you!
The Silver Queen
Riding up the river on the good ship Silver Queen
Dancing on the water for a dime
There's a young girl and a soldier who'd just come home on leave
And he asked her for a dance just one last time
CHORUS:
And the music softly floats across the water
And the lights are dim and distant on the shore
And though those times are long since gone, they're not forgotten
But they'll go dancing on the Silver Queen no more
Each day she'd write a lettter, remembering that night
Until the day he answered her no more
Now in the front room window, there hangs a faded star
And the Silver Queen lies empty on the shore
I saw all this through the eyes of a seven year old kid, sitting on a bench that ran along the side of the boat, drinking Squirt, muching on a bag of Okee Dokee cheese-covered popcorn, with my legs dangling in the air, too short to reach the floor.
And though those times are long since gone, they're not forgotten
Jerry
letters were to him. Thanks for sharing.
Write On.
andrew: Thanks for the comment.
Carolyn: His letters were surely a blessing to me, too. Thank you!
Sandy F: Thanks for coming back. I'm glad we're connected, too.
..
U wishing you laughter
Heidi: I like your answer to the question.
Haim: It took me a long time to find words to tell it. Thanks for reading my story.