The first booksigning I did was at the New England Booksellers’ Association. I appeared in the Penguin booth, which gave me a terrific opportunity to meet some of the local and national sales people who would be working hard to get my novel into bookstores.
The New England representative and I instantly hit it off. Before the signing, he asked if I knew the two questions authors were most commonly asked.
At that point, my book hadn’t yet hit the bookstores, and I was still getting used to the word “author.” I’d been writing all my life, but I was always afraid that if I called myself a writer, people would ask if I was published. And though my work had been appearing in literary magazines for years, no one would recognize their names.
So no, I told the sales rep, I had absolutely no idea what an “author” might be asked.
“You’ll know by the end of the day,” he said. And he was right.
I don’t think I’ve ever attended an event without being asked the first question at least once. Even when there are only three or four people in attendance, at least one person will ask how long it took to write the book. It’s a good question, and in my case, the answer is easy: Three quick months to blurt out the story in a rough first draft, and then a couple of long years to hone and polish until it was ready for publication.
But the second question, also the title of this article, really stumped me the first time I heard it. Hmm...where did I get my ideas?
If I were an autobiographical writer, the answer would be clear. However, I’m not. (Those kind souls who’ve read The Liar’s Diary can breathe a sigh of relief now.) Nothing in a novel that some reviewers have called “outright chilling” and “disturbing” happened to me. On the other hand, I clearly know the emotional landscape. There is no fiction that doesn’t contain something of the author, a fragment of our obsessions, or a dream we never got a chance to live.
The idea question, however, remained unanswered. It hit home with particular resonance a couple of weeks ago when my agent called to say that my editor would like to see a synopsis and the first hundred pages of a new novel--preferrably some time in the next six weeks.
“Not a problem” I said confidently. “I’ll start tomorrow.” (After all, I'd been waiting to hear that an editor was looking for my work all my life.)
I showed up to fulfill my bargain the next morning at seven (not an easy task for a serious night owl.) The computer was on, a giant mug of extra-strong coffee was at my side, and my dogs were at my feet. Only one thing was missing: I had no plot, no character, absolutely nothing with which to begin a story.
I spent the next week desperately trolling for that elusive thing known as an idea. I sat in Borders, sucking down $3 coffees with fancy names and wondering how I would pay my bills if I didn’t get another advance. On the table before me, was a giant stack of new fiction. Systematically, I studied the book jackets, in awe of the amazing story ideas that other writers had invented. Clearly, they were brilliant and imaginative, every one of them. How had I ever dreamed I could enter their ranks?
Feeling increasingly despondent, I decided that these greedy writers had taken all the ideas! There were none left for me; and even if I tripped on one in the parking lot, I wouldn’t know what to do with it. I called a close writer in Canada (who seemed to possess an endless store of ideas) and told her I was finished. Kaput. A one-book author.
And then one morning, I woke up with the image of a house in my mind. Just that--a house, but I saw it so clearly I felt as if I’d once lived there. Within three days, I knew the people who inhabited that house by name and by heart. I knew what they wanted most, and the scent of their fears. I knew the content of their most troubling nightmares; and I couldn’t help but feel compassion for all I saw in their futures.
I called my writer friend in Canada and my agent (and the husband who had been subjected to my moaning for days) and told them all: I had one! And when I told them more about it, they all said, I did indeed. I had a real, bona fide full-of-exciting-possiblities idea. And as the days have passed, that idea has become increasingly real.
But still, the question remains unanswered. Where did it come from? For me, ideas seem to appear only after plunging deep into my subconscious, from experiencing my despair and my deepest hopes, and then allowing time to form them into something that has shape and passion and movement. Not a very good answer, I admit, but it’s the only one I have.
Now it’s my turn to play audience member. To those of you who write in whatever form, where do you get your ideas?
Patry Francis, Books Correspondent:
Patry's column, Diary of a First Novelist, published every Thursday to Gather Essentials: Books. It will detail all she knows--and is in the process of learning--about writing and publishing.
To learn more about Patry and her debut novel, The Liar's Diary, visit her Website.
You can find all of Patry's articles, Diary of a First Novelist, at www.gather.com/patryfrancis
Keep up with Patry’s other postings and Gather activity by joining her Gather network -- just click here and select the orange “Connect” button on the left-hand side of the page
You’ll find Patry and other Book Correspondents, plus celebrity author content and plenty of other bibliophiles at Books.gather.com
.


Comments: 54
Most of my ideas come when I'm not even thinking about writing.
I guess I am not a "writer" at all. I started completely differently:
I was interested in a specific era in history. Reading lots about it, I figured that all the scientific work didn't succeed envisioning the human beings who lived, acted, suffered in that era. A novel might be the best form to do this.
When I started reading novels about that time I was disappointed. Either they were placing rather flat stereotype figures, dressed in historic costumes, in the middle of a historic scenery; or they were playing with well-known mythological themes, focusing on the "reality behind the myths". None of them were really interested in the people of that era.
So I thought: It has not been done, wow, let's go and do it. I have never written a novel, I am not an expert of that era, I am not even a native speaker of the language I write in - there is a lot to learn.
When I think about it, I am heading into the category of the "one-book author". [But don't tell anybody yet!]
Even if you only write one novel, and even if it never get published you have accomplished something few ever accomplish; be proud of it
Patry,
Now to try to answer your question:
As for my short stories and novels Ron's "what if?" is probabaly also my starting place with the addendum that the 'what if?" often emerges as the result of thinking about one of the many problems that confront us as a species and as individuals.
My poetry is another matter. I'd be willing to swear one of my shorter, abstract ones was written in a dream. I woke up in the middle of the night; tt was in my head and so I wrote it down so I wouldn't forget about it by the time it was time for me to wake-up and get out of bed.
"The Butterfly" which I recently published on Gather, as part of a related image, I am pretty sure was inspired by the sight of a butterfly. When it come to my poetry the come from many place, things, people, and situations to name just a few.
I got the plot of my very first novel by praying for it. I sat down one day and said "God I always wanted to be a writer, but never seem to get past sixty pages. Please help me with this, because it is all I want in life."
Once, the idea for an entire novel came to me sitting on a city bus, coming back from a particularly disappointing music lesson, feeling kind of depressed, and watching an attractive young woman talk to a natty, elderly man with a cane, first in French and then, after some moment of mutual understanding, in boisterous Russian. And for whatever reason, I saw the whole thing, the characters, the arc of the story, everything. In the end, the two people on the bus never made it into the final tale. But the entire moment, including me and the way I was feeling, jolted something in life.
What's the Faulkner anecdote? That he conceived of the idea of The Sound and the Fury when he was walking down the street and saw a little girl in muddy underpants playing in her yard?
my immediate answer to that question is out of the silence, out of the stillness, out of the landscape, both geographical and spiritual.
it is also I question I never ask when interviewing.
Teresa: Your process sounds very similar to mine. Sometimes when you're doing "nothing," you accomplish your most important work. Hard to explain that to anyone else though--or sometimes, even to myself.
Ron: That makes perfect sense. The right "what if" is a true gift from the muse.
Dawn: I think that was how my problem developed. I was trying to "force" an idea to appear, rather than waiting for the muse to bring me one in her own time.
Hajo: Those who bring history to life by seeing them through the eyes of fully imagined characters are definitely writers! Your impulse to write the novel you want to read is one that I share.
flit: Eavesdropping has served writers well for as long as people have been telling stories. What better way to develop an ear for dialogue! And besides, when writers do it, it's called "research."
Carol: "What if" is an excellent story starter, but I think my personal favorite is "why?" I look forward to checking out your poem!
Lydia: You make an important point. When I was panicking over getting my "big idea" in time to make my six-week window, I forgot that sometimes all you need is a germ, a seed, a slender fragment. And then, as you say, you need the patience to let it expand and grow.
Thom: In only a few words about your ride on the bus, you created a story that is so vivid and multi-layered I could not only see it, I could FEEL it. Thank you for sharing it here. I also loved the anecdote about Faulkner and the girl with the muddy underpants--which I hadn't heard previously.
Ed: I wish I could tape record your words and play them back the next time I'm asked that question. You say it so eloquently, and every word had me nodding in my chair. Yes!
that's where they come from!
Kerry: What a beautiful description--and so respectful of the mystery.
Ruth: The world needs more readers like you! (Incidentally, I am the same kind of voracious book-lover.)
tamara: Sounds like a fascinating story. The fact that it's haunted you for years means (at least to me) that this is something you NEED to write.
Julie: I love your "seeing is believing" philosophy and I share it. I also like to allow the characters to take over and surprise me. Believe it or not, when I wrote The Liar's Diary, I was as surprised by the ending as everyone else was. But I also knew it was the only right and true one.
Lisa: I have such a strong image of you, finding inspiration in the blinding pain of a migraine. I can't wait to hear more about where it leads.
Sheryl: You have the right attitude, and I do believe you'll get there!
Eventually I began writing down their stories and when I made a mistake, one of them would point it out, sometimes reasonably, sometimes impatiently. I try to do them justice, since they're interesting people. The first work about them is nearly done; I don't know who's more impatient to finish it, they or I...
Kris: What a wonderful description! Now I can't wait to meet the tantalizing, neurotic occupants of your neighborhood, too!
This experience provided the seed of a story about a reclusive community of telepaths.
Cathy
Congratulations on your success.
My stories come from a multitude of sources. Often I start with a character, such as one of my beloved Gus LeGarde cast. Let's take Joe Russell, local cop, for example. In Counterpoint (not yet published, still waiting patiently as #8 in the series of 9), I started thinking, "What could have happened to Joe to make him NOT want to marry Maddy?" (a "what if," of sorts.)
Part of the humor and character depth I develop in the background of the mysteries has to do with characters like Maddy, based on my paternal grandmother. Grandma was fiery, flamboyant, loud, a beer drinker, she wore ostentatious flowery dresses, chunky sparkly jewelry, and walked into rooms in clouds of perfume. So, now that I know Maddy is pushing Joe to marry her, I need to create a conflict which will make folks relate to both sides and want to follow it through to resolution.
I'd already given Joe the history of having accidentally killed his wife, Jean, ten years earlier during an ice storm, where his car plunged into the lake and she drowned. Now, having gone stone sober since, with various low points of angst and guilt, Joe survives, but can't connect deeply with another woman. Now that Maddy is prodding him harder for a wedding date, something triggersw his repressed guilt and he's plunged into a full-blown case of anxiety/agoraphobia.
Where does this come from? I think it was from my wife's history. She suffered some of these symptoms in the early onset of her MS, so I lived through her eyes for a while, understanding the illogical but very real fear. (example of "using your life experience" for ideas). Joe, previously a stalwart, macho-type hero with a well-hidden-but-soft underbelly, completely loses it, and Gus and his family/friends work hard to help him. There are good medical and psychological reasons for this, but as that little germ developed, I found my characters asking me to connect him with the final showdown of the main plot - totally unrelated to Joe's trauma - and in the culmination of the action Joe redeems himself in an iced-over lake scenario. (used my ice storm experiences here in upstate NY for the scenery).
I guess what I'm trying to say is that the ideas build on each other, whether stemming from a scene (like your house), or a relationship (Joe/Maddy).
In addition to the usual movies, newsclips, friends' traumas, personal experiences, "what-ifs", dreams, and fears that motivate stories, I find that locales often inspire a scene or story. For example, when I rode the Fast Ferry to Rochester to Toronto and back (before they sold it, sadly.), I KNEW I had to have a scene on that boat. I pictured a fight on the incredibly windy back deck, with Gus nearly being knocked off in the brawl, and just had to fill in the "who, what, and why," to go along with it. It worked out fine, gave me some nice background imagery, and allowed me to relive the great experierence of the mini-voyage.
Well, Patry, another great and thought provoking article! Sorry for being so long-winded! LOL.
;o)
I draw my ideas from dreams, family, standing in long lines at the pharmacy, daydreaming in a bathroom stall. Since I have a profound hearing loss, I've even been inspired by ideas from things I've misunderstood! =:o)
Like Katrina, I'm ADD and usually write short stories that have ended up in Chicken Soup books. I've written a contemporary romance called "Wife Seeking Wife" and am peddling it to litarary agents who are anxiously awaiting for me to overnight it to them - LOL!
Thanks for this wonderful, thought-provoking article!
Slugs: It's so nice to be surrounded by so many people who share my dream.
Cathy: A town with no one or nothing but a solitary dog. What a vivid image! No wonder you came up with such a striking plotline.
Mary: I'd like to hear more about the story that came to you when you were surfing the net to learn about sheep. (I have a new fantasy about moving to the country where I could raise sheep and goats while writing in my "spare time.")
Aaron: Aaron, what a marvelous and thoughtful insight into the origins of some of your characters. The new novel sounds terrific. Meanwhile, I'm thoroughly enjoying Double Forte. Your characters burrow deep under the skin.
katrina: Actually, I rather like the "river of ideas" metaphor. And I know what you mean. The more you open yourself to the poems or the stories around you, the more easily they find you. It's like discovering a new way to see.
Aileen: Great description!
Jennifer: Good luck with Wife Seeking Wife! I love the title--especially since I've been seeking one for years.
Peter: I like the idea of keeping a pencil and paper handy--even when you sleep. Just today I felt an idea for a poem stirring, but I didn't have time to capture it. Then, later when I sat down with my notebook, the idea had evaporated.
Isabella: Beryl Singleton Bissell is the author of a wonderful memoir called The Scent of God, and she knows as much about the muse as anyone I know. How blessed you are to be filled with so many ideas! I hope you have the time to use every one of them.
Mariana: Fabulous description of the journey you make from wine-soaked thoughts to active inspiration to a story you're ready to share with your readers. Your "simple life" yields many riches.
Great article, Patry. Thank you.
I am not a writer in the sense that I never published a book. Last year I have finished one and my intention was to try and publish it, but it is still on my desk as I want to change some of the chapters.
What I write here in gather is from my own experience, of my own path , in the hope that it may help others discover themselves.
I have also used my imagination based on the love for the native Americans and wrote an essay for a contest in gather and everybody thought it was about my real "me". I was amazed to read this in almost every comment left. I never came to the US, but I might have been there in a previous incarnation as images are so often displayed in front of me during meditation time and I know so many things about .
Thank you for sharing
love and light
You have a gift!
I have always wanted to write fantasy fiction novels so I have started taking notes during role-playing game sessions about the events that unfold, how the different characters act/talk/think/feel etc. (as they are played by different people than myself it gives them a little more depth than what my limited perception gives.) While I may tweak the adventures now and again, actually playing through the story; living it as it happens, I'm hoping that it will eventually turn into a great story for all to read.
Ilsa: Yes, many thoughts parade through our minds, but the ones that burrow deep lead us to the stories we want to tell.
I'm just going to take what comes though. :D
Wonderful article, Patry.
amylee: As long as you have an abundance of ideas, you don't need to worry about where they come from. It's only when the muse falls silent that I begin to ask questions.
Ed: "Some of my ideas just develop by writing." Oh, yes! But I think that if a poem or a novel or a play isn't capable of startling and inspiring its author, it's not going to do much for anyone else either.
Laurun: Or walking on the beach...
Beverly: Now you've aroused my curiosity. I want to know more about the boy who lived in a dog house. Thank you...
Marge: I love dream stories--though you're right; there's a lot of transmutation between the vision or dream and the page!
It still took a couple years to write. I do have a novel or two in the works and the ideas always come fro things that interest me to the point of obsession. If the obsession wanes, the project tends to grind to a halt.
Krista: Obsession is what keeps the motor humming; that's for sure.
Alkistas: That's a great list. I especially like "human reactions to events that are out of their hands." Every novel worth reading explores that in one way or another.
Michelle: Yes! It's exactly like "looking into another dimension"--though I hadn't thought of it that way until I read your comment. Thank you!