Ellen DeGeneres rocked it as host! I would bet money she will be back in the future. The opening monologue sets the tone for the long ceremony and her debut couldn’t have been better. This being the most international Oscars ever with several multi-national nominees, she managed to get some laughs about the high number of British nominees and the anxiety of nominees waiting to hear their name announced…or not. Along with the short film featuring the nominees talking about the awards and what they do, the start of the show promised to be respectful to the whole film community. It was especially cool to see those nominated in the technical categories get some face time.  The montage was amusing, simple, and fun.
          Â
Most of the speeches seemed thought out and quick, while at the same time there wasn’t a feeling of winners being played off the stage unduly (except for the unfortunate winner of Best Adapted Screenplay who admitted to taking valium and then mumbled through his minute and a half of fame) before thanking their Mamas. Forgetting to thank your Mama is like forgetting to thank your spouse…it could lead to a painful divorce.
          Â
I think this is the first Oscar presentation (I believe) that has been not produced by Gil Cates in many years. I liked how the show seemed to embrace the idea of film through film montages that depicted such things as screenwriters and clever ways of presentation. These movie montages have been worked more and more into the show each year and it gives satisfaction to we film fans who are naturally cynical about dance numbers featuring jazz hands singing, “Oscar! Oscar!â€Â  The dance troop that was employed for the evening was interesting and inventive, the sound effect choir was clever, and the nominated songs were bunched together during the show without much a do. They even were minus a pair of presenters announcing the obvious (three songs from ‘Dream Girls’ and the other two). The best pictures were also presented without actors taking the stage to introduce them. Further, I loved how the costumes were presented, something about seeing them in the context of in the auditorium gives the viewer another take on both the artistry and the era of which they represent.
          Â
A tip of my hat to Jack Black, Will Ferrell, and John C. Reilly. Their song and dance about comedians at the Oscars was poignant and entertaining. The part about going home with Oscar and Helen Mirren almost was worthy of a standing O. Hopefully, Will Ferrell’s hair is for a role.Â
          Â
Thankfully, the Irving G. Thalberg Humanitarian Award was mercifully short. There have been some shows where it went on for just too damn long and the production loses some of its momentum. Yes, it is nice to honor someone who gives back, but the award usually honors someone who usually sits on boards for charities and gives money that most of us won’t see in our lifetimes…whoopee do! Thankfully, Tom Cruise who presented it managed to make an appearance without referencing to Kattie, Suri, or Scientology. Plus, for an added bonus…he didn’t even jump on a stuffed Oscar! Oh, I'm just being glib.
          Â
Speaking of special presentations, Al Gore did himself proud with a comical bit performed with Leonardo DiCaprio. Meryl Streep showed why she is Meryl Streep when she helped her fellow co-stars after they mucked up their presentation. It took her one look as her character in ‘The Devil Wears Prada’ to set their jokes aright – that’s why she is Meryl Streep and they will never be.
          Â
One major upset was when ‘Pan's Labyrinth’ lost out to best foreign film, but won most of the other categories it was nominated in. (It was robbed I tell you! Robbed! Okay, I didn’t see the other foreign films, but I’m telling you there is a theft to be reported.) Jennifer Hudson stuck it to ‘American Idol’s’ Simon Cowell by winning an Oscar thus proving he really isn’t the end all and be all of judging future success. ‘An Inconvenient Truth’ won and Al Gore, although not winning the Oscar himself, was quite gracious about putting forth his message without slamming people on top of their pointy little heads with a hammer. Thankfully, it seems people have leaned from Michael Moore’s mistake. His speech played like flock of geese flying south without wings. Also winning for ‘An Inconvenient Truth,’ thus upsetting the three nominations for ‘Dream Girls,’ was Melissa Etheridge for Best Song. I am happy, although older than me, she and I grew up practically in the same zip code. So bully for her.Â
          Â
A few WTF moments, Celine Dion performing a debut song for the guy who was being honored for his movie scores (he was the one who did ‘The Mission,’ which is the most beautiful emotional music ever). Was this her new song or something he wrote, I have no idea – it wasn’t very good. Jerry Seinfeld (stand up comedian and TV star) giving out the Oscar for Best Documentary. Jack Nicholson channeling Britney with baldhead, Philip Seymour Hoffman’s ‘I just crawled out from underneath my bed’ hair and Meryl Streep’s outfit (huh?) great actress, poor dresser. Animated cartoon characters acting like they are actually in the audience cheering on their nominations for Best Animated Feature. Yes, it has been done before, but it was remotely clever at first and now is just downright annoying.Â
          Â
My favorites won for Best Actor and Actress so I am more than delighted. Forest Whitaker should of won something just for his speech. He was emotional and it brought tears to my eyes. Poor Helen Mirren got up to the stage minus an earring and carrying her clutch, which I think threw her off a little. She ended by declaring her obviously male statuette “The Queen!â€Â Of course, we have always suspected as much, but only a nervous Brit could say it in such an unabashed manner. Side note, she forgot to thank her husband – oh-oh. George Lucas, Steven Spielberg, and Francis Ford Copula did a funny bit before presenting Best Director almost as if they could sense that this was finally Martin Scorsese’s year. He got his richly deserved standing ovation. It was such his year that ‘The Departed’ even won Best Picture.
          Â
Fashion wise, only Meryl Streep seemed as if she dressed for a dinner out with friends at Applebee’s. Few other dresses or tuxes seemed to stand out as shitiously bad. Miracle of miracles, Diane Keaton was in an outfit that didn’t look as if it was inspired by ‘Annie Hall’ or purchased at her local Salvation Army or both. I was amused that Ellen DeGeneres actually had wardrobe changes, which included velvet pantsuits of different colors. All and all there were few awkward moments, but that’s understandable considering it is a live program.
Â
In conclusion this year’s Oscar’s were fun and moving. I almost wish I could see the show again. Here is a complete list of the nominees and winners, http://www.imdb.com/features/rto/2007/oscars .
Â
copyright 2007 Westerfield




Comments: 44
I'm with you, Lisa -- Ellen was just terrific. I hope she'll be around for a few years as host. (Unfortunately I said that about Steve Martin and Chris Rock too.) I particularly liked her opening monologue and the choir and the dance.
Good for Scorsese, finally getting his award, and hats off to Helen Mirren, Cate Blanchette, and (I'm embarrassed but I don't recall her name) the humanitarian award winner for, in my opinion, having the best dresses. And of course it's always nice to look at George Clooney for a few minutes.
did you see the one about the chocolate package that accidentally broke open and the helpless victim threatened to sue the company because of a knuckle burn? I nearly cracked my ribs over that--
come-on, a company really isn't responsible for knuckle burns in the kitchen--there's always some risk when you put a bimbo in the kitchen with pre-packaged foods.
less when you have someone who does things from scratch like make jellies and syrups because they know they'll get burnt and accept responsibility for some really homemade stuff
still chuckling over above comment. nice word below:
" stand out as shitiously bad"
like the new adverb shitiously, but think shitatiously might also be viable-- such as in adj what a shitatious shirt you've got-- and the food tasted shitatiously bad.
but you're probably right since it comes from shit-shat-shat and adj is shitty and shittily just sounds pretty shitty.
and besides, why are you wearing such fine feathers if you're not into the trade? If you don;t like the feathers, then strip 'em, I say. Perhaps you'd look good like a bald chicken with a USDA approved tattoo.
Nanci B - why bother to read about stuff you don't care about?
Why should one have to justify why they care or watch?
I like to watch the Academy Awards. I like movies, I like to see what the stars are wearing and, although there are some boring parts (Celine Dion?! Time to do laundry...), I enjoy watching the show. To keep it interesting (and to explain WHY I care, not that I feel I have to justify it you you), I participate in an annual Oscar pool to see who can predict the most winners.
You obviously care enough to comment on more than one article about it.
My article on the awards last night weren't the first you deemed worthy to insult, in your grumpy words, "This is most definitely non-news. I just cannot understand why anyone cares." I care because I do. Do I care about the Oscars more than family and friends? No! Do I care about the Oscars more than the Super Bowl? Hell yes! Would I go into someone's article about the Super Bowl and say something off-putting like you did mine? No. Just because I don't have a passion for something doesn't mean I feel it necessary to attempt to belittle someone who does. Nanci, you know you didn't come into this article and the others wanting people to explain why they cared about last night's telecast, you came in a vain attempt to prove you are above such trifling matters. What you did prove to me is that you enjoy negativity, thus you may consider my comment back to you as not necessarily insulting, but an attempt to indulge you.
Mary, the word "shitiously" I borrowed from Perez Hilton who has a fantastic website, www.perezhilton.com . Another word I have lifted from him is "pAArtying" as in hard partying by starlets going through the last of the residual checks for shows no longer on the air. I don't study the origin of words as much as I would like to, but I do love when new ones crop up. Thank you for your compliment about me being sophisticated, I hope you don't mind if I quote you on that. As far as Nanci, I think she is missing the days of the epic Gather Wars.
Susan, thank you. I'm still cleaning up this piece. I was writing it during commercial breaks and tried to tie it all up while a bit bleary eyed.
Cindy, it was one of the better broadcasts. I think Ellen's comedy talents are well suited for this type of show. I really enjoyed the montages of sound editing. I also loved how the screenplays were presented by reading parts of them while the movie clip was showing. It wasn't the type of show where you held your breathe wondering if someone was going to say something controversial, but there was enough of an edge to it that kept you watching.
Joanne, thank you. As your GNN Entertainment reporter, I felt it necessary to watch. I'm hoping someday to be the 'People' magazine to your GNN 'Time.'
Tonia, Forest Whitaker's speech was awesome. You could just tell that it meant the world to him, he has always struck me as a gentle soul. The type of person if you saw on a subway in a strange city you could go up to him for directions. The Oscars is the only award show that I ADORE. For me, it goes deeper than just some self-congratulatory event – it is the worldwide show that America puts on. Few things are more identified with America than Hollywood and despite if Americans themselves love or hate the idea of Hollywood, it often is the face of America in foreign lands. When the telecast goes well and everyone looks like they at least scrubbed and slapped on something attractive, there is a pride that I as a citizen take. It may sound odd, I know, but with billions of people watching when the program has wit and appropriate emotional moments it is the best PR machine we have.
1. The fashion.
2. It is normally a show done with some wit.
3. Rooting for my favorite actor/actress or screenwriter to win.
4. The movie montages.
5. Talking to friends on the phone about the telecast as it is happening.
6. The nice surprises that I wasn't expecting.
7. The not so nice surprises I wasn't expecting.
8. People thanking their mamas.
9. The pride I take that the Academy Awards is an American tradition.
10. The pride I take that Hollywood embraces social change.
Kenneth, I know you didn't see me swing my arm and snap my fingers, but suffice to say I did to your comment about messing with me. Don't come into my kitchen (i.e. article) and make a turd sandwich, because I will call you out on it.
I don't watch the Oscars but I always look in the paper the next day so my wife can tell me about the fashion disasters. I don't care much about fashion but I enjoy hearing her talk about it.
For a different take on the Oscars see S F Chronicle TV critic Tim Goodman's Oscar Review
I'm sorry Meryl Streep was poorly dressed. She's the hottest female celebrity in her age group although Helen Mirren and Martha Stewart are contenders.
I'm glad both Forest Whitaker and Helen Mirren won Oscars for their roles. Very well deserved and Whitaker's speech was very moving!
LOL
BTW, only for you sweet Sonia, but I downloaded a pic of Meryl that I am going to include in my images because I don't know how to put it in a thread so you can see what I am talking about. Actually, this photo doesn't look half as bad as when the cameras panned her. Keep in mind that the top of her 'dress' comes down past the knee and then something is on underneath. I believe this outfit is Prada, which I personally think is a bit of frumpy design house. I get the wit about her wearing a Prada design but this is the wrong outfit. Further that necklace is so large that she had to know that it would be all over the place and that the pictures would come out all wonky. It is perfectly fine for some premiere, but we are talking Oscars.
I'm so happy you liked my article. I was writing bits and pieces of it during the commericals.
As far as the 'fashion police' go sometimes I agree with them, sometimes I don't. I often see their points on proportions involving an outfit. For instance, if you are going to where a fancy three million dollar necklace than the top part of your dress shouldn't dazzle too.
Lot of great lines here, such as: "It took her one look as her character in 'The Devil Wears Prada' to set their jokes aright – that's why she is Meryl Streep and they will never be.
and:
Jennifer Hudson stuck it to 'American Idol's' Simon Cowell by winning an Oscar thus proving he really isn't the end all and be all of judging future success.
and
Diane Keaton was in an outfit that didn't look as if it was inspired by 'Annie Hall' or purchased at her local Salvation Army or both.
Loved the Mission. I actually liked Celine's song, (her voice, not the song).