This is being reposted a and with additions, I need advice, this has gone up to the Super's office and it looks like they are not going to stop doing this to kids here. Not without a court fight. I need parents and Teachers, with advice.
---origional post from last week--------
I find myself enraged; it's not often that I get this truly angry. My son was barely able to walk the last 2 days, because he did too many exorcises (150 squats) in PE, but that's not why I am angry. Why I am angry is he was forced to do those exercises because he forgot his homework for his computer class, and he had to do the same exercises last week (only fewer 50 Squats) because he didn't get a good grade on a piece of homework for that same computer class. Then he was told next time there is a problem it would double (300 squats?). Thus, the school; at least between the computer teacher and the PE teacher are deciding on physical punishments as (in their minds) a way to educate children. So when the kids have to do this they are subjected to the pain of the exercises and the public ridicule of the other students.
This all came out when my son came to me and said," Dad, I would rather be home schooled then go to Jr. High school." I wasn't looking at him when I asked him why, and then I looked up to see him struggling to keep from crying and he said because there are so many kids who don't like him. So I asked him, "Have they (the kids who don't like him) been doing or saying anything to him at school?" and he replied with tear streaming, "they call me retarded, and even one of my good friends is now repeating it and other things". I asked him, if these were kids that knew he was going to special Ed last year? And he said some of them… Then I asked him about the teacher in PE and all the details came out.
So not only have other children been noticing and abusing my son for getting extra help, but the situation is being compounded by a set of teachers that think physical punishment is the way to teach computers.
Needless to say I am going to the school Monday morning, and the situation will be solved. First I will assume I am among friends and keep as cool as I can. If that doesn't work I will escalate including informing them of legal Consequences and others such as I will write this up and publish it for the newspapers and on the web including names of the school and the teachers and Principal and their e-mail address's… I have already researched the legal steps for taking kids out of school and home schooling (I am not ready to do this as I am presently working days, but I will change jobs or what ever I have to do if this becomes the best option). Luckily the Home Schooling laws are in the favor of the parents and are not subject to change, it has gone all the way to the Supreme Court here in Texas.
The part of all this that upsets me the most comes from my own experience in school, with special ed and my over all self view was so negative that by the age of 23 I was depressed & suicidal ideations were present. I was able to get assistance etc, but most of the problem was from the idea I had even since being a little kid that I wasn't good enough. That I couldn't do it on my own, that I needed meds or special help or something else to be good enough to be acceptable. Allowing a child to feel that way is just wrong, not that my parents or the schools back then did it on purpose, they didn't, but the lack of understanding on there part led step by step to a lack of self understanding and acceptance on my part. I will not allow this problem to continue, he disserves better then I got, I disserved better then I got. My experience, negative as it was, has given me this knowledge and I will use it, to help my son know who he is.
I have always taught him the creator doesn't make trash. I will strengthen this teaching with the added concept that while we are all equal legally, we are each unique given different gifts and different challenges for us to learn what we each need to learn. Most of all I will make sure that my wife and I make sure he knows is OK with us, that we love him. We have done this, and yet I know we must do more thus I am giving up plans for a job advancement because it would mean I have to keep working days, and I will begin looking for a job at night, carrier doesn't mean a thing if my kids don't have what they need.
I feel our responsibility is greater then anyone's for the raising of our children, and that math, language and science are not enough. David O McKay was fond of saying "What-e'er Thou Art, Act Well Thy Part." His speeches and writings also depicted many other deeply-held values, including education. "True education," he taught, "seeks . . . to make man and women not only good mathematicians, proficient linguists, profound scientists, or brilliant literary lights, but also . . . men and women who prize truth, justice, wisdom, benevolence, and self-control as the choicest acquisitions of a successful life." According to him, "Parenthood ... should be held as a sacred obligation. There is something in the depths of the human soul which revolts against neglectful parenthood. God has implanted deep in the souls of parents the truth that they cannot with impunity shirk the responsibility to protect childhood and youth. There seems to be a growing tendency to shift this responsibility from the home to outside influences, such as the school and the church. Important as these outward influences are, they never can take the place of the influence of the mother and the father. Constant training, constant vigilance, companionship, being watchmen of our own children are necessary in order to keep our homes intact."
That was some of the inspiration that guides me as I strive to bring my kids up into the world with joy in there hearts and understanding in the minds. And Finally I must quote David O. McKay again because he said it succinctly, "No Success can Compensate for Failure in the Home".


Comments: 34
Thank you all for your support,
I would see if we could get a group of parents to file a class action on behalf of the entire student body of the school system.
http://www.gather.com/viewArticle.jsp?articleId=281474976790657
BUT we are still looking for the Lawyer to help legal aid etc... I have taken my son out and as part of that I am informing them (the appropriate thing to do in Texas Law ) of my intention to home school, and I will ask them to sign something to prove they received it. In it I plan on stating why, i.e. I will say that due to the fact of the teachers abuse of my son and other children and the hostile learning environment this creates for the safety of my son I have to remove him from Yoakum, TX ISD. I will therefore be also filing civil rights law suits because of the violation this is to the IDEAct and the section 540 of the rehabilitation act of 1973 (might be 74 don't have it in front of me this sec.) and then they will need to sign receipt of this paper so I have verification that I am following the Home schooling laws etc... this will begin the process... and allow me to still sue them even though my son is out.
(if I am wrong let me know)
Thanks again for the support.
No child should be singled out like that ever....You have legetimate concern and should follow through, but I would change schools for him if possible (a school that works with children with learning dissabilities) homeschooling is an option but he still is going to have to learn to interact with peers, who unfortunately can be unkind.
I'm sure there are organizations in your area where you can get an advocate...The state mental health department may be a place to start or any dissabilities org. can point you in the right direction....
good luck
Did you check out wrightslaw.com? they do have links for attorneys who SPECIALIZE in this area.
Does your son have an IEP? I assume he does because he is in the special needs program.
We are all with you, Matthew. Keep on it, the good fight, the right fight, the tough fight.
I'll have that document on monday or tuesday, it is dictated then written then signed.
Kathryn please e-mail me your phone # if your husband is not adverse, so I might chat at him to get some of his profestian prespective...
I'll email my addy to you in a moment.
Thanks all....
What can they do if he refuses? What punishment can they pass down to him that will be any worse than if he refuses the damned excercises? He shouldn't let them intimidate him!!!
Good for you for being on his side. My parents would have just accused me of exagerating, and told me to deal with it myself.
To this day, I tend to deal with things myself, and I just don't tell them about it.
Good for you for being on his side.
Move, remove him from school, go to court, call a press conference. Just do something. NOW
YOU have become the problem. Make your choice.
I'd already read and commented on this.. did you repost? My advice was to TAKE A LAWYER with you and set a meeting but don't tell them you were bringing the mouthpiece.
Good luck.
Move, remove him from school, go to court, call a press conference. Just do something. NOW
YOU have become the problem. Make your choice. "
Daine, #1 I am fishing. I have pulled him out and will finish the process on monday. I have described above the type of paper document I will give them above that sets the stage for the court battle.
#2 Part of the problem? I'm judt going to let that go assuming you don't realise all we have done this week, esp becouse I haven't had time to update all of the info.
#3 We made our choice to 1 protect our son, and 2 to keep fighting to protect others children.
Lloyd, I wasn't asking you to comment again on this I was making a statement about your thoughts on education and students snapping and hurting others... My point was ans is that problems like my sons can and do lead to students hateing either the system or themselves and others enough by the time they are drug trough the system to snape... and thus columbine... Montreal etc...
Thank all the rest of you also for the comments. I am off to bed in a moment ...
BTW, David O. McKay is one of my favorites.
#1 this has been going on for a long time here.... the President didn't start it and never lived here anyhow. Lets not use this venue for political attacks.
#2 I don't remember us or the President cutting heads off of Innocent people on TV to prove a point?
#3 I seem to remember the people we have in GITMO were involved in terrorizing people, and killing people, and as part of the Taliban harassing women and even killing them if they went even to the hospital with a sick child without a male escort..... that's the types in GITMO... and our Hotel like accommodations are hardy torture... I mean they are receiving better then most of our Military...
#4The president is not an evil man, even if you don't agree on his policies... he is in a tough spot, and doing it like any of would with the best advice he can find and prayer and then just doing it, because the real crime would be ignoring it...
Please lets not continue political discourse here, this is a place I hope to get advice, not argue with people. All of you are friends that I need at this moment even if just to send good thoughts and prayers..
Thank you
That being said, have you filed a complaint with the Department of Justice? Try this URL:
http://www.usdoj.gov/crt/edo/faq.htm
There is a wealth of information there that I believe will be invaluable to you.
----------formatting will be off it is copied from word---------
September 17, 2006
Dear Yoakum Junior High School, Yoakum ISD,
This letter is to inform you of our decision to withdraw Joseph L. Townsend from Yoakum Junior High School and to home school him. This letter is also to assure you that we have a curriculum that covers the basic areas of reading, spelling, grammar, math and a course in good citizenship. We are pursuing it in a bona fide manner.
The reason for this decision is that the administration and its policies (both written and unwritten) have made the environment of Yoakum Junior High school hostile and threatening. This is evidenced by the pain and discomfort intentionally inflicted (as admitted by Coach in front of four witnesses on Sept 14th 2006, thus admitting Assault) upon Joseph and also evidenced by the Dr's examination of my son, for the sake of punishing Joseph for forgetting his home work. In response to the lack of care and judgment shown by the school Principal and the Superintendent's office of Yoakum ISD in response to my complaint, I must assume my learning disabled student cannot receive an equal opportunity for education in such an environment. As such Joseph L Townsend's civil rights have and are being violated and we will be pursuing the protection of his rights and the rectification of this problem with Federal authorities, not just for the sake of Joseph but also for the sake of all children who have something to fear at Yoakum Junior High School.
If you have any further questions please submit them to us in writing.
Sincerely,
Matthew Emmett Townsend (Joseph L. Townsend's Father)
________________________ Date: ___________
Leslie Waldron Townsend (Joseph L. Townsend's Mother)
________________________ Date: ___________
Proof of Receipt by Yoakum Junior High School:
________________________ _______________________ ____/ ___/2006
Name of Recipient Signature of Recipient: Date:
-------end of letter----------
I will be contacting the director of Disabilities education over this and the other district also in the morning. Contacted individuals should vbe calling me back with legal asistance this week.
Thanks, for all your support.
You can inroll him in another school in the distric and re write his IEP to include what a conciquece for forgetting his home work can be for example mabey he taks 1/2 credit if he turns it in the next day.
Yes ideally he can tell the teacher NO but looking back I never told my teacher I would or could not do somthing I did it and then looked to my parents to her me fix it for the next time. YOu are on the right track by doing somthing don't give up! Good Luck!
i think it's horrible that a mistake or error in one class is being punished in another-- as far as i'm concerned, each class or subject (and particularly teacher) should be independent of the others. at least where praise and punishment apply.
i'm an alternative high school teacher and sadly, even less extreme measures have detrimental results. you are right to do something about this-- i would seriously suggest writing a letter (or three) to the local papers about this. make it public-- people have a right to know.
pain is only a temporary reinforcers-- and pain in PE has CLEARLY not helped him remember his computer homework. reward had far better success with motivation.
it's too bad you ended up in a school system that is so wrong. teach your son from it. and i do encourage you to not be a homeschool "teacher" but rather a education guide. explore with him. debate, discuss, and make learning an adventure-- whatever his ability is.
Homeschooling may be your only option but it's too soon to tell. Keeping in mind that with homeschooling, your son will have (unless you've made arrangements for peer interaction), no friends. This, on a purely social developmental level, is not good for your son.
Also, before going to the school, if you could bring an attorney with you, it might go a long way for them to take you seriously, as well as have a witness, one on your side. I wish you the best with your son. And I really feel for you, nothing is more important or rips our hearts apart when bad things, illegal things (and what's happened is illegal in CT), happens to those we love and protect. This is terrible. Please keep us all updated.
Marilyn
I have not updated, but this is how it stands after an ARD and some policy changes..
#1 ARD. My son is now placed in 5th instead of 6th, this is not punishment and is what we had planned 4 months befor with the end of the year ARD. but they pushed us into another ard befor school began and then had him goto 6th then the problems happened but seperiate (some what) his grades in english (his LD area) were awful and he was under too much stress being mainsr=treemed into 5th with no experiance with the level of movement and responsability.
He is doing Great in 5th right now learning and reading books like eating pizzia...
#2 the policy. ( I do not have proof, aboput the policy change) suposidly they will still do the squats.
firts ofense either in PE or in the computer class the coach teaches also. 25 squats
second ofense 50
third 75
75 squats to be the total ever allowed at one time.
not good enough to me but getting there I will be getting proof or I will have all the info edited for grammer etc and such and organised and presented to the News Papers. here and In San Antonio Tx.
still fighting for the kids
Please those who "hate" the idea of homeschool give me facts and I'll read them, not emotion and suposition...
Thank you for sharing your story, it helps me to know were not alone even though I wish you had not gone through it...
Thank you,
M. Emmett Townsend