In my mind, he was graduating high school on a football scholarship and enjoyed racing midget cars.
On my calendar, he was 13 weeks gestation.
In my womb, he'd stopped growing at 9 weeks and had begun to "reabsorb". He never even got big enough to be a "he", yet I had named him John Robert and planned out his life.
He was an unexpected pregnancy. His father had lost a four-year-old son ten years prior and was determined never to love again, never to feel that loss again. In the weeks we knew of my pregnancy I had gently encouraged his father to open up and trust in the future.
By the time I worked my way through the maze of health care for the uninsured, that future had already changed.
People who have not experienced pregnancy don't realize how quickly that being grows in your mind. I am sure even fathers don't quite fully understand.
When the doctor told me on the phone that the embryo was reabsorbing and needed to be removed, my first thought was, "Why?" My second thought was of my sister, who had experienced this too many times. "How did she survive this?" I think I even asked her that when I phoned her from the fetal position on the kitchen floor where I remained, crying, for several hours.
I'd already been blessed with two beautiful children, so I was one of the lucky ones. I wasn't being denied motherhood, I was only losing one "perhaps". The dream of another being. I could heal and keep going.
His father relapsed into his world of walls and is probably still there now.
John Robert is thirteen now in the world in my mind. There is no football there, no race cars, but so much love and peace. I am sure I commune with him often in my dreams; are those the ones where I wake up feeling so loved?
I think of him much more often than some would expect, those who don't know it firsthand. John Robert would have been born in the year between my nieces. I look at them and see the place he would have taken in their lives. They don't even know he once was here.
Sometimes I wonder if there is a place in the next world where the almosts and not quites gather and share stories of their families. In my beliefs, I know they often recycle and find another place to land in our lives, which makes me think the akashic records must be very confusing! How complicated to keep track of the past, present and might-have-been lives!
I also wonder how big is the sorority of mothers with an empty spot on their laps. When asked we speak of the living, "I have two daughters." Only the doctor's office asks for the full count. Even with friends, we might admit to the number of living and dead children, but we rarely bring up those that are lost before viability. Yet they exist, and they are as real in our hearts as those who made it.
So, here is to the silent sorority, the mothers who have never had the joy of hearing that first cry.
Namaste.


Comments: 36
Thanks for sharing Aileen.
My heart goes out to you.
Kathryn and Jessie, thanks for commenting.
Jerry, I can't imagine losing a child I had known for years. It must be so hard on both parents!
Nancy, thank you.
Thank you for your sublime lament. I appreciate it so very much.
I also had two sons. That doesn't keep me from mourning the ones I loved and lost.
Cheryl, mine was due in March of 1993. Interesting how close ours were.
Mary and Carol, thanks for commenting.
Sara, I hope I didn't stir up more pain.
Vicky, thanks!
Meryl, yes, we feel each one on its own. Five months is that much harder than the time I had to know mine.
love and light
Allen, I hadn't seen many men's reaction to miscarriage, so I grouped their responses as one. And, really, John Robert's fahter's response shows how real the baby was to him, too. Thanks for making me realize I was discounting the fathers so heavily in this.
Meryl, wow, I never thought about the losses the doctors feel, either. This has been a very enlightening experience for me!
Lisa, sometimes words aren't necessary to show you care.
John Robert is thirteen now in the world in my mind. There is no football there, no race cars, but so much love and peace. I am sure I commune with him often in my dreams; are those the ones where I wake up feeling so loved?
It's human nature to forever grow a lost son or daughter, to imagine what s/he would be if s/he could be in this space and time. It's a bittersweet thing, only for you the bit about dreams accentuates the positive.
Great topic, sensitively done.
You have touched my heart. I have been through this experience and even now that I know I would not have my oldest son (who I can not imagine life without) had my first pregnancy been full term my thoughts still wander to what might have been. The silent sorority is honored by your words.
Carl, if the sentence is in an opinion piece, how can I better write that?
Carl challenged this sentence: "People who have not experienced pregnancy don't realize how quickly that being grows in your mind." You could, if it says what you believe, change "don't" to "might not." That leaves open the possibility that some may be able to empathize very well.
But I don't mean to be an English teacher here, and your article has so much depth and healing to offer that I wonder if Carl's need to challenge is because he does, in fact, have a deep empathy with someone and did not want it denied. It's a measure of your effectiveness that he would speak up. Bravo!