Note: comments to this article will be addressed by Shafiq Rasul, Asif Iqbal, Ruhel Ahmed as they receive them; co-director Matt Whitecross of The Road to Guantanamo will be available for a LIVE CHAT on Thursday June 15 from 1-2pm in humanrights.gather.com
The Road to Guantanamo is in theaters June 23rd.
On September 10th 2001, the mother of 19-year old British National, Asif Iqbal, returned home from a visit to Pakistan. She had found a girl for Asif to marry. Nine days later Asif set off for a small village near Faisalabad in the Punjab where his bride-to-be lived. While he was visiting his bride, his best man called to tell him that he couldn't come out for the wedding. Asif decided to call another friend from Tipton, 19-year old Ruhel Ahmed. Ruhel agreed to come out to be best man. A few days later he flew out with two other friends – Shafiq Rasul (23) and Monir Ali (22).
The four men meet in Karachi. After a couple of days on the beach and in the arcades they visited a mosque with Shafiq's Pakistani cousin, Zahid. Later in the week, an Imam (a local religious leader) called upon the men in the village to travel to Afghanistan on a humanitarian expedition. The cost of the journey to Kandahar was only £2.50, so all five men- Rhuel, Shafiq, Monir, Asif and Zahid - volunteered.
The next day, they were taken back into Konduz. The city was bombed daily by US planes, and the Taliban forces stream into town, but after two weeks a truce is negotiated through the UN. The Taliban agrees all the foreigners should leave the city first. Monir is not with the others when he is told to get on a truck out of town. He is never heard from again.
The four others are told that foreigners have been granted safe passage, so they board a truck headed for Kandahar in the night. The convoy of trucks is bombed by US fighter planes, killing or maiming most of the passengers. Zahid is on a truck that is hit. They find him soaked in blood but still alive.
The four - Rhuel, Shafiq, Asif and Zahid - are captured by Northern Alliance troops. Along with hundreds of other prisoners, they are tied up and herded into containers. Ruhel Shafiq and Zahid are lucky. Their container has canvas sides. Asif is not lucky. His container is metal and airtight, and the prisoners begin to suffocate. Asif loses consciousness. When he comes round there are bullet holes in the sides of the container. Many prisoners are dead – either from bullets or suffocation. Asif has a gunshot wound. He licks the condensation on the walls of the metal container – a mixture of blood and water – to survive.
The four men are detained at Sheberghan prison for 10 days, and are visited by Red Cross officials, who notify the British embassy in Karachi. However, on December 28th, US forces policing the prison take the three Britons and fly them to a detention centre at Kandahar air base, where they are beaten and interrogated, by both US soldiers and the SAS. Zahid is left behind, and eventually imprisoned in Pakistan. During the flight to Kandahar, they were secured in stress position while in the cargo plane. Shafiq's recalls the flight to Khandahar:
In normal circumstances the position would have been difficult to maintain for any length of time. Given that I was extremely weak and that I was suffering from dysentery, dehydration, hunger, and exhaustion it was impossible to maintain this position for more than a few minutes at a time. If however I leant back or tried to move, I would be struck with a rifle butt. These blows were not designed to prevent us from falling back or to adjust our position, they were meant to hurt and punish us.
In Kandahar the men continued to be held largely without proper nutrition, sanitation, clothing, or shelter (an increasingly grave problem as by then winter had come to Afghanistan). In addition to suffering the daily indignities and abuses omnipresent at the facility, all three were also repeatedly interrogated by American and British forces. After recounting their stories, they were accused of belonging to radical organizations and attending radical gatherings in Britain of which they had no knowledge. As the men did not provide the "correct" answers to their interrogators' questions, these encounters often merely occasioned further violence and beatings. Asif recounts one interrogation by an American official in Kandahar:
I said I was not involved in Al-Qaeda and did not support them. At this, he started to punch me violently and then he knocked me to the floor and started to kick me around my back and in my stomach. My face was swollen and cut as a result of this attack. The kicks to my back aggravated the injuries I had received from the soldier striking me with a rifle butt. After a few moments the guards dragged me back to the tent. Whilst he was attacking me, the interrogator didn't ask me any other questions but just kept swearing at me and hitting me.
Interrogators had told the men they would be transferred to Belmarsh or other maximum security prisons in Britain for detention and trial; however, after several weeks Shafiq and Asif were instead readied for transfer to location unknown to them—Guantanamo Bay. Rhuhel was to stay at Kandahar for several additional weeks for reasons which remain unexplained. Though split up, they all recount the horror of their flights to Cuba (the transfer involved a stop in a third country presumed to be Turkey). The conditions on the flight to Cuba were similar to their previous transfer, with the notable addition of goggles, earmuffs, and other measures to achieve total sensory deprivation. Shafiq describes one element of the torment of the transfer:
During the plane journey the shackles had been so tight that they really cut into me. I still have scarring on my left arm from them and I lost the feeling in my right hand for a long time because they were on so tight.
On January 13 2002, Asif and Shafiq arrive at Guantanamo's Camp X-Ray and Ruhel joins them on February 10. The men were kept in the open-air 6'x 6' cages that have been seen in photographs. They were not allowed to speak to one another, stand up, or lean against the edge of the cages. They were allowed out once a week for 5 minutes to exercise. They slept on mats and had to keep their hands over the blankets while sleeping, which was difficult to due to constant noise, the constant high-intensity lights, and intentional sleep-deprivation by the guards. Despite the heat they were only allowed 1-2 minutes to shower each week. They were also often only given 1-2 minutes to eat, with any remaining food then being taken away. Certain cages were exposed to near constant direct sunlight during the day. Each prisoner was given two buckets, one for water and one to use as a toilet. As the cages were out in the open, they also had to contend with snakes, spiders, and scorpions. Initially denied Korans or even the right to pray at all, ritual mistreatment of the Koran later became a staple of daily life, as Asif notes:
They would kick the Koran, throw it in the toilet, and generally disrespect it. It is clear to me that the conditions in our cells and general treatment were designed by the officers in charge of the interrogation process to 'soften us up.
All three were subject to numerous and continued interrogations by both British and American military and intelligence officials. Under the pressures of repeated physical abuse and the unceasing privation of daily life, all three eventually acceded to interrogators' claims that they had come to Afghanistan for jihad—admissions which they interrogators often assured them would lead to a speedy dispensation of their cases. By contrast, the interrogators only pressed increasingly fantastical claims that the three laundered money for Mullah Omar or had known Osama bin Laden. They also describe the interrogations as often random, haphazard, and unorganized with officials from different agencies often forcing them to go over the same set of questions on repeated occasions or wait alone with a guard in the room for several hours before an interrogator arrived. Rhuhel notes:
I was interviewed every 3 or 4 days. The routine would be I was taken, short-shackled at the air-conditioner would be turned up to make the room freezing. The longest time I was short-shackled was about 6 or 7 hours.
The conditions of daily life improved slightly when the three were moved to the purpose-built facility at Camp Delta; however, they were still housed in cages in open-ended metal shipping containers. Hunger strikes by the detainees led to the relaxation of some rules. They could now converse with one another, pray more freely, and were afforded the additional luxuries of pit toilets and two extremely brief showers per week. Nevertheless, the now ritualized beatings, deprivation, shackling in stress positions, death threats, verbal abuse, occasional spates in isolation, harassment from dogs, and other provocative actions by female interrogators continued unabated. The men, of course, continued to be denied legal representation or any other contact with the outside world—aside from occasional and frustrating visits with British officials (they continued to also be interrogated by other British officials, sometimes outside the presence of American officials). They were also refused adequate medical care, resulting in permanent, debilitating conditions in some cases.
On March 5 2004, after more than two years at Guantánamo, Shafiq, Asif and Ruhel - now referred to as the "Tipton Three" - were taken back to England and interrogated in London by the Anti-Terrorist squad at Paddington Green station. The next day they were released without charge.
On Thursday June 15 from 1-2pm EST co-director Matt Whitecross of the documentary film The Road to Guantanamo (opens June 23rd) will be live on Gather.com to answer questions and discuss their story. Shafiq, Asif, and Ruhel will field questions as they are posted on the site. Please begin posting comments for the discussion directly to this article and join us in humanrights.gather.com on Thursday June 15 at 1pm to find the responses and participate in the livechat.



Comments: 22
Last time I looked it was illegal to imprison someone without some sort of trial, which requires proof. If that proof is present none of those things the alqaeda 'manual' asks you to do makes a shred of difference.
Plainly these guys were released, so there was no proof. No proof means there was no reason to capture them in the first place, and definitely none to break the geneva convention and basic human rights (no matter the semantics - decent human behaviour is self evident) upon SUSPICION.
Wrong place, wrong time and abhorrent behaviour on the part of the captors. It's hard to be just and moral when you're torturing people on suspicion.
The reason we have rule of law isn't to protect the guilty, it's to protect the innocent.
Apart from common sense, bit of history can shed some light on this too: this ALWAYS happens when the victors try to round up the enemy they have just defeated, most of whom have of course made their escape on time. One example: when the Soviets "liberated" Eastern/Central Europe from Nazi rule, they needed a number of fascist collaborators (an actual quota that Stalin demanded) to take back home as prisoners, but real fascist were hard to find. So they just gathered up whoever was available on the streets, or pointed out by malicious neighbors - innocent people at the wrong place at the wrong time. Some were never heard from again.
We cannot expect our own to be treated any differently than we treat others.
I am sorry this happened to you.
I feel horrified at their eventual treatment, torture and abuse. However, there was an underlying suspicion that needed to be explored. I only wish it had been done humanely.
1) Why did you decide to make a film about this particular story?
2) What aspects were especially compelling to you as a filmmaker?
3) Do you want or expect this film to contribute to the national dialogue on issues like: the government's infringement of civil liberties in war time, the use of torture to extract confessions from prisoners, and in an era when we're not fighting traditional armies with clearly defined nationalities, should we also change or adapt our definitions of prisoner. If so, how do you think media, in particular the film industry, helps or hurts discussion?
If this guy Winterbottom had been around 65 years ago, he would have goosestepped along with the British Union of Fascists. Or already have gone to Germany to make propaganda for Herr Hitler.
mr. Winterbottom and these little boys seemed to think Gitmo was as horrific as Auschwitz. What a laugh. The U.S. Armed Forces are NOT exterminating the terrorists at Gitmo or treating them as the late Cockroach specimen Al Zarqari treated truly innocent people in Iraq.
If you are Intellectually honest, Mr. Winterbottom, why don't you make a film about the people butchered by IslamoFASCISM. The little girl beheaded in Indonesia because she was a Christian. The slaughtered Black Kenyan dancers, murdered because Al Qaeda was upset about them greeting Israeli tourists. The Russian schoolchildren in Beisan. Or better yet, the families of the women and children on board the airliners on 9/11? Those starved, slaughtered, and slaved in the Sudan??? Or the family of the South Korean screaming to spare his life as the cockroach brought down his blade? Not to mention the British woman savagely murdered after decades of helping the people of Iraq.
No, you chose to enable a couple of spoiled brats who still don the beards and wear the clothes of the rat kingdom. Fine.
(It would be too much to ask you to interview Israeli victims and survivors of Genocidal bombings because your sympathies are obviously with the Islamofascists). And in that world purview, Jews are no better than Nazis.
These boys - and if you are reading this you know exactly what I mean - knew what they were getting into. You were NOT innocents.If you were, you would have made the wedding and gotten out. Period. Heck, it is clearly obvious you won't integrate into British Society. A Society that has already suffered terror outrages far more than the piddling treatment you received at Gitmo.
But of course there are the Intellectual types who would do anything to promote a hate America, hate Jews and Christians platform - and promote rubbish like this. If Americans were so evil, there wouldn't be a single Islamic mosque left standing in America. Middle Eastern Muslims residing in the USA would be carrying ID cards (as if that wasn't a bad idea). And there WOULD BE MASS EXECUTIONS at Gitmo. There hasn't been any, and aside from maybe some torture or neglect, there is NOTHING compared to what those poor people on the airliners or in NYC experienced moments before they were murdered.
Atta promised them their lives. He's a liar - and so are you. Be thankful you are alive, and allowed to promulugate this kind of sordid propaganda in those nations that Sharia would destroy.
Nathan Hale
i would like to thank allah swt for bringing you all out of that place and hope that you gained rather than lost something due to the situation.
i feel everything happens fora reason and allah swt knows best. i am a youth worker and feel that after watching ur film i could see that even though you strong brothers and used your knowledge to your advantage , many of our youth could end up in the same situation that they most probably did not to expect to happen to like you guys they might not be so strong or wise and anything could happen to them esp in the hands of such people. i feel we need to inform our youth of such issue's and prepare them for the worst. most people dont even know their rights, let alone what to do if they ever ended up in sucha place. may allah swt protect us i would be grateful brothers if you could take the time to be able to make our youth understand this issue.you may contact me on monalisa19@hotmail.com
The late William Herrick, a dedicated crusader against ALL forms of Totalitarian Lies and Oppression, once commented about a Lincoln Battalion commanding officer who claimed he wasn't a member of the Communist Party or a Stalinist stooge: "So what was he doing in Spain? Touring the country perhaps?"
Which is my follow-up about these guys who claim NOT to be Al Qaedist or any other kind of Islamonazi Cockroach.
Since I originally made my first post, I've learned two things. One, these guys left England AFTER 9/11, supposedly for Pakistan. Yeah, Right. Pakistan. THEY FULLY KNEW Afghanistan would soon become a major war zone, as this President, unlike his predecessor, just wasn't going to throw a couple of cruise missiles at empty murder camps. THEY ALSO KNEW that the country where they were either born in, or lived most of their lives also was NOT going to tolerate the kind of atrocity where 3000 men, women, and children were slaughtered because of a cockroach mentality.
That's right. Cockroach mentality.
I have also since learned, from a U.S. Army officer (and don't give me any bullcrap that Americans don't tell the truth...I'd sooner believe a U.S. Army Intelligence officer than guys wearing the garb and beards of the Islamonazi cockroach front), that those who are shipped to Gitmo are ONLY done so after it is ascertained that they have or are suspected of having major TERROR ties.
And if one or two or three truly innocents suffer. SO WHAT! If they were caught in a war zone, in or near where cockroaches were inhabiting the territory, then that is too bad. I will reiterate - to date, none of these cockroaches in Afghanistan, Iraq or Pakistan have suffered comparably to Jews at Auschwitz, Babi Yar, Maidenek and other death camps. Or the Khmers...or the Rwandans...or Bosnians. In fact, ironically America intervened in Bosnia to save Muslims. Something that the cockroaches and fecial material of Al Qaeda, Fatah, Hamas, Hizbullah, and other genocidal organizations have convienently forgotten. If these boys weren't major Al Qaeda figures - then for some reason they were pretty close to the mindset and goals of these murdering bastards.
Winterbottom and Whitecross are sorry corruptible British Left Wing Fascists if they cannot grasp the kind of Lying Propaganda they have made. CONGRATS, LADS, Oswald Mosley and Neville Chamberlain are smiling down on you.
Thanks!
i would like to also ask how your lives have been since you been back to uk?
has the fact that people know your names and faces and that you were accused of so called terrorism affected your lives?
what are your plans for yourselves inshallah?
have you thought of or are you carrying out any work to help people who are in your situation or who can end up in it?
i hope you can be able to answer these q's for me and that anything brought your way you should take as positive and reply positively too, hope that such ignorant, sterotyping lost people dont bother you and you should all keep strong for us all and show them what we are really all about and dont be afraid to speak the truth to whom you like and in anyway you like and stand up for justice and real freedom and peace which is what islam really stands for .allah is the greatest.
ps
itwas nice to know that brother asif got his chance to get married in the end and i hope you are having a blessed marriage inshallah
and brothers shafiq and ruhel did you get a chance to settle down and live happily ever after as they say hope you all do cos you triumphed and may allah swt reward all. ameen.if not plenty of sisters waiting to marry such real muslim men as yourselves.
pss
to the director of the film thank you for work of art and showing the world what injustice is happening under a so called fair and jsutice system huh, well we hope that many more of the worlds evil people are exposed and put a stop to. got anything similar lined up and how can people work with you if they have their own film production ideas.
if so contact me on monalisa19@hotmail.com
jazakallah khair wasalam.
I am a student in London, Canada. I release a newsletter for Muslims students. I am actually originally from Pakistan as well but my father is from Afghanistan. I was wondering if you had emails where I can contact you, I would really appreciate it because I would like to know more about your experiences and how it has affected you now. I would also like to interview you for our newsletter. I would really appreciate if you brothers agree. Thankyou