I come from one of those large (eight kids) 50's and 60's Irish Catholic families. My mom worked before she got married and went back to work full-time when I was in fourth grade. She is smart - she had been in the first graduating class of women from the Georgetown U. School of Foreign Service back in the early 50's, and was President of the local chapter of Mensa when I was a kid. So she rose quickly once she got back into the work force. But when we were little, mom was always at home. There was no such thing as preschool, that I know of - my first organized experience with other children was in kindergarten (and I was terrified to go!).
Fast forward 25 years - I'm living in Chicago, married with twin toddlers, and working my tush off as VP of HR for a technology company. I loved my job - couldn't get enough of it - but combining the job with new motherhood and double babies was a challenge. One time, my parents were visiting from out of town, and I had to work a bit late. Not very late, as corporate schedules go - but I didn't walk in the house until about 7:15, and I felt very guilty on two counts. Number one, my parents were sitting there with my husband and the kids, waiting for dinner plans to be made. Secondly, my mom would see my crazy schedule close up and probably think "What a bad mom." But actually my mom gave me a boost that evening.
As soon as I walked in the door, I hugged my parents and my husband and immediately plopped down on the floor with my twins, piling up blocks or whatever they were doing. My mom looked at that and said "I never did that." "What do you mean, Mom?" I asked. "I never got down on the floor with any of you kids," she said. "There wasn't time. Your preschool equivalent was toddling along after me as I ironed clothes, grocery-shopped, scrubbed the floors and tended the garden." I thought about that. Of course! When would a housewife in the sixties (no microwave, no household help, no car at home until Dad got home from work) have time to play blocks with the babies? I'd guess that the oldest preschoolers watched the baby-of-the-moment, in fact. Those were the days of playpens, now that I think about it.
Now, I still get down on the floor with my kids when I can. But I don't stress about it. There was a whole period when people stressed Quality Time over a simple quantity-of-time-together equation. But I'm not even down with quality time, in the sense of putting one's total focus on the child and his needs. Kids get a lot by being with their parents, whether the activity is putting together an Adirondack chair out of the box or doing something more child-focused. Above all, I know, my kids are fine. I work a lot, then I'm home a lot, and I have a ton more flexibility in terms of how to spend my time than my mom did when I was little. Full-time job and all, I have time every day to focus on each child and see what's up with him or her. Whether it's on the floor or driving home from school, we can talk and catch up.
Guilt is the disease of working moms in 2006. Guilt imposed by our employers, our non-working (outside the home, that is) friends and neighbors, sometimes by our savvy button-pushing children, and often by ourselves. Give it up. Guilt never helped a child or a mom. Your kids are golden. Look at the powerful role model they've got in their lives (I'm talking about you, honey).
My mom's remark about not getting down on the floor to do blocks with her children was offered in an incredulous, maybe even slightly disapproving way. That's fine! She let me off the hook, bigtime. I realized that it's WE PARENTS who stress about the child's mental state, the child's emotional health, the damage done to the child by our absence…..when three seconds' thought would remind us that for 100,000 years of human history, parents have not devoted their waking hours to entertaining their children. Somehow, the children survived. Ours will too.


Comments: 21
I confess, It does help that I agree with you.
Even so, this is a very nicely put together statement and very readable. Hits a lot of flash points, doesn't wander, off topic.
majority American lifestyle. Everybody is literally on their own as far as figuring out what's best for their family.
When I was a kid, parents with unusual work hours were rare. Today, it seems no one has a set schedule.
It is my firm belief that the term "quality time" is not well defined. If a parent spends an hour a day with their kids and is interacting in a genuine way with them, those kids will have a much better chance of growing up normal than kids whose parents run them all over town, but spend no time actually with them.
Kids know when somebody cares and they know when somebody doesn't care. Anyone who wants their kids to grow up with a good shot at a normal life better make sure their kids know they care. The amount of time parents take to show their kids they care is not important.
Your article reminds me a lot of when I was raising my two sons and trying to juggle work and family/household responsibilities. My own mom encouraged me to keep my priorities straight ("the housework will wait!"), and that suddenly made it OK when I was out playing with the kids instead of staying inside and dusting my furniture. Come to think of it, the furniture is still a little dusty and I still love spending time with my kids now that they're adults! :-)
how my younger brothers and sister share the income/child raising chores, and I now watch my son and his wife share both the joy of parenthood and the burden of producing income for the family.
Maybe you should take three seconds of thought and find a reason why todays children are on so many behaviour enhancing drugs, have such low self esteem, are depressed, more likely NOW than ever to end up in jail or prison....then try your theory our about guilt, parenting, and what is really impacting what in America.