There I was with fifty years of love and admiration invested when I discovered his love meant nothing at all. What do you do when that happens?
This man had shown up on every holiday, picked me up when I fell, cried when I cried, laughed when I laughed, clapped when I sang, carried my furniture up three flights of stairs, visited me in the hospital, danced with me at my wedding, and dried my tears at funerals. What did that mean if he could just as easily hate other people for no reason?
"Nuke them all," was the first sign. I thought it was a joke (not a funny one). But he didn't laugh. "We need to nuke that whole area off the map," he continued. "And stop all the talk about giving queers special rights."
He would get over it. He would realize how wrong he was to say these things, and regret the confusion that allowed such words to slip between his lips. I had faith in him; he would never truly wish innocent people dead, or begrudge anyone happiness.
But he didn't take it back. He never did laugh, or apologize. He didn't catch the splinters of my heart as they scattered in unexplored directions.
Those people became towel heads. He wanted them dead. He said it often and loud.
I heard every possible rationalization for continuing my relationship with him from other family members. He's family. He's a good Christian man. He donates time and money to charities. He hasn't ever done anything to you. He's entitled to his opinion.
Did they agree with him?
"We aren't taking sides," they said. "Don't ask us to." I wasn't asking for sides, I was asking them to stand for principles. Everyone should have their own principles and standing for them isn't taking a side. It's being real.
As the political climate changed, so did Uncle Charles' vocabulary. Nigger and queer joined towel head and spic. Uncle Charles hates them all and his ability to hate came as a devastating surprise. I had assumed he loved everyone the same as he loved me. Should I be grateful for the climate that made openly expressing his hatred so comfortable for him, so I'd know the truth? Alternatively, was this a case of what I didn't know didn't hurt me?
"If you have nothing good to say, don't say anything," a friend advised. "He has a right to his opinion."
He has a right to hate people he doesn't know? I had to think about that. On the surface, it made sense but deeper, where my heart and mind dissected the situation into possibilities, probabilities, and consequences it wasn't acceptable. Was it my business?
Education was the answer. Somewhere along the way, he had missed some important lessons. He hadn't absorbed Grandma's seldom spoken messages of love, and everyone knew he hadn't read a book in years, and watched the news only long enough to catch the sports and weather. I would help by bringing the needed information to him. He was a good man. He'd appreciate my help.
I collected articles and books, prepared debates and composed scenarios. He didn't appreciate my effort. He didn't look or listen. He laughed. "You sound like a damned hippy," he shouted. "Keep that crap to yourself. You have a heart and a brain. The heart belongs to the church and the brain will get you in trouble if you go twisting what the church teaches this way."
"Your church doesn't teach you to love everyone?" I asked. "Don't they tell you it's wrong to kill? That's what nukes do, Uncle Charles. They kill."
"I'm not killing anyone," he offered as his final comment.
Uncle Charles didn't want to talk to me any more. But his kids had plenty to say.
"You need to keep your mouth shut and get along," one said. "You hurt his feelings," came from another. My aunt shook her head. "You've divided the family with your hatred."
My hatred? My mouth? My division? All I had done was try to talk to him about his hatred of innocent people and the death wish his mouth delivered. I was the bad guy?
Pleas came in from everywhere. "The family that prays together stays together. You have to come on Thanksgiving for the sake of the family, and don't cause trouble," they warned. "Don't ruin our holiday with your negativity."
I tried. I really did. I packed up my children and grandchildren and joined the rest of the family for a day of gratitude and kinship.
Uncle Charles said grace. While he thanked God for wealth and health, flashes of starving Iraqi children with blown off limbs distracted me and ruined my appetite. I bowed my head lower, in shame for what my country was doing to other families while we gathered to express gratitude for not suffering the same fate we forced on them. Is that how God planned it? Should I participate in thanking Him for something I believed He wanted no part in?
"Dig in everyone," brought me out of my trance. "Gramma, what's a towel head?" delivered me from my quiet.
"It's a very ugly name some people call others," I whispered.
"Why?"
"Because they don't know better," I explained. "But you do, so don't ever say that again."
"Can we teach them better?"
"We'll talk about it later."
What Uncle Charles didn't know might not have hurt him, but it did hurt me. When his hatred filtered through his family, and they used it to vote for an administration that would use their uneducated opinions to kill people in my name, they hurt me, they hurt my children and grandchildren, and they hurt innocent people in Iraq and Afghanistan. Do people really have a right to be this ignorant, and demand that I keep my mouth shut?
"Don't brainwash that baby with your liberal bullshit," the nearest cousin advised, with the amen of his hypocritical prayer still on his breath. "Towel heads are terrorists who'll kill us if we don't kill them first."
My semi-brainwashed baby's eyes stretched in fear. "Kill us?"
"Nobody is going to kill us," I said. "Eat your turkey."
"Are we going to kill them first?" My grandson asked.
"Do you want mashed potatoes?" I answered.


Comments: 48
A relative told me he wasn't sure who to vote for in 2000, but when he heard that George Bush accepted Jesus Christ as his savior THEN he knew Bush would get his vote. I told him I believed in Jesus Christ, but I didn't think his teachings allowed for any of President Bush's behavior.
I know better than to provoke a fight, but I couldn't sit still for his blasphemy (That's what I called it :) I haven't seen that branch of the family since. I don't live a perfect life, but I try to. I have no ilusions about my failings. AND I don't let expressions of hatred and bigotry go unchallanged. You are right to protect the younger generation from it, wherever it comes from. To better days!!
Good for you Sandy.
Isn't that strange?
We also know where keeping quiet to "keep the peace" gets us....Keep talking, girl, and don't let another generation buy into it.
JESSIE VOIGTS: You hit on what was another tough position for me. I never tried to shelter my children from anything. I exposed them to all the ugliness in the world, and taught them that every person serves a purpose – sometimes if only to show us what we don't want to be. For some reason, it didn't feel the same when my grandchildren were present. I'm not sure if it's because I was afraid I didn't have the same level of influence and protection over my grandchildren, or if it was because I believe this is an important time in the battle (due to it being PC to be a bigot and a bully with our current administration). Also, my daughter (the mother of my grandson) is not white. I caught her eye the day this all fell into place for me, and thought I read in her expression the same thing I was thinking – when we aren't here they probably add spic to the mix. I agree, no family peace is worth setting aside my principles.
RICHARD FRISBIE: Good point. I have gone against the adage, and chosen my family now. Some of them are related by blood, some are not. Kudos for speaking up in your family situation, also, and I'm sorry you had to give up a branch on your family tree. If you're looking for a sister – I'm available.
RON HALL: Sounds like blasphemy to me, and I agree it does seem more prevalent among those who use religion instead of living it. Martyrdom is part of using religion, so I guess their feelings of persecution naturally follow. As for wishing there was a way to confront the hypocrite without offending those who aren't, I struggled with this for a long time. When I try to discuss this with them, however, the answer I get is "we can't tell them they aren't Christians. We can't control them." Until I see an uprising from the 'real' Christians to remove the hypocrites from everything political, I think I have to lump them all together. I don't care what any of them do in their personal lives, or in their church lives. I just want them out of my government and my personal space. Your cop story makes my skin crawl. He has no right with authority or power over others, in my opinion. I met a judge just like him this week. I'm still too upset to think, much less write coherently about it, but I promise I'm all for removing all bigots from positions of power.
CARL NEELD: Yep.. ;-) It sure does seem the more a person professes to be Christian, the less that person seems to follow the teachings. I think this goes along with "when you're really good at something, you don't have to tell others, they tell you. The minute someone announces they are Christian for no apparent reason, I'm pretty sure that announcement will be followed with an attempt to belittle me, assume superiority over me, convert me, or lie to me.
NANCY SPIVEY: I promise, I'll keep talking. I do believe with each generation we dilute the bigotry a little more. But dang, it's a slow process…
BERYL: Here – I'll share my Aleve.. sorry about the chest and stomach. Thank you for the compliment – I said earlier I'm envious of someone's talent with the camera. If I can paint a picture with words, it's some consolation.
MICHAEL SPAULDING: Had to chuckle – the man could have taught bigotry at the graduate level. It is sad that these people don't see how they hurt themselves by hurting others. Glad your uncle had the paper plane to redeem him. My uncle had some redeeming qualities, also. I just wanted to leave him ugly for this article ;-)
You can't fix everyone Sandy - but you're doing a remarkable job of setting a worthwhile example for your children and grandchildren. Keep taking the higher road.
So true!
The best defense is to be entirely intolerant of intolerance.
My long standing rule is to never condone injustice, sexism, or bigotry by remaining silent. It has cost me several friends and one job - but they were friends I could live without and a job best avoided.
It's odd that I have never met a child born of tolerant parents who was an out and out bigot (I'm sure they exist - but they're a rare breed.)
Gisela said it all mate - I doubt your kids will grow up to be one eyed bigots.
Children will always tend to absorb the worst from their environment because it is easier to react than it is to think.
JAMES MOYLAN - I agree with the standing rule. It took me years to 'unlearn' those urges to be nice, never rock the boat, avoid conflict at all cost, etc. I feel so free now that I've shaken loose those shackles. And you're right, those are friends I can live without. Interesting point - never met a child born of tolerent parents who was an out and out bigot - I don't believe I have either. I'm going to think harder about this. My children can't grow up to be bigots without hating themselves ;-)
I need to add a footnote to this. This story is not an actual autobiographical recount of one event. The sentiment is real, my position is real, and the events and conversations took place, but I actually combined three relatives to create the Uncle Charles character in the story, and the actions and conversations took place over a number of years. Although very real to me, and expressive of actions I have taken and conversations I have had, I would categorize the 'story' as fiction. My outspoken Uncle Charles died several years ago. The closet Uncle Charles continues to live in a fog, and the third Charles is blissfully ignorant. My grandson is a politically savvy seven-year-old now, somewhat disappointed that his Gramma can't just say 'we're the good guys so it's okay to kill the bad guys'.
"The sentiment is real, my position is real, and the events and conversations took place" It was obviously not fiction, but I'm really sorry it was an amalgam of family members and not just one. It is bad enough to lose one. Thanks again for the sincerity and convictions that come through in your writing.
MOYA - thanks for reading, and for sharing your experience. I like your story for two reasons. It shows your kind spirit, as well as that of your grandmother, and also why I'm not positively affected when people claim to be color blind. Seeing color and appreciating the wonder and joy in others is much better.
JAMES - ah.. yet another tragic story. I wonder if this man was prejudiced before his POW experience. It's hard to understand how a person could not see himself in his own captors if so, but equally hard to understand how he could turn what was done to him onto another group of people if not. Maybe we are odd creatures.
And this thing about the president having accepted Jesus Christ and that's why so many folks voted for him, is something I've been shaking my head about for 5 years!
I feel for you.
FAITH - It is hard to believe people still think this way. Unfortunately, I don't think the south owns it alone. Thanks for reading and commenting.
BARBARY - You're very welcome. Thank YOU for reading and commenting.
JAMES - bite your tongue!! The accordian is a beautiful instrument (I have the slouched shoulders and flat chest to prove it). Thanks for dropping by!
I know your comments to Hannah are tongue-in-cheek, but so many think this way. What kind of god would do those things, and why would anyone want to praise him?
This piece pierced me. Deeply. And the wound it left are questions about my own values.
Thanks.
Now hold my hand here for a moment...
BITCH!
Squeezing your hand gently, with affection.
Thanks for reading this ugly piece, Kevin.
I'd be honored to give you a massage and work some of the tension out of your neck and shoulders.
Unfortunately, a bit of this goes with aging sometimes.
I was brought up in a liberal, Democrat household. Although both my parents are Southern, neither had ever said anything racist within my hearing. It wasn't the way I was brought up.
But, over the past ten years or so, I've heard my dad crack wise about "darkies" or "Jose" or "Ahmed." I have to say I was shocked.
He made the mistake of cracking wise like that in front of my son, who administered a SWIFT and SURE correction: "Pop pop, don't talk like that in front of the kids. You'll spoil their good impressions of you."
Embarrassed my dad like nothing else.
He won't be making THAT mistake again any time soon.